Am I on a controlled substance or is the suggestions forum just a popularity contest basically? Obviously none of these ideas will hit the game, I don't think I've seen a single update in Minecraft that was actually suggested by anyone at any point.
1. What does this have to do with the gun suggestion?
2. Are you new here? Everybody on here knows, even the moderators have acknowledged it, that no developers for the game come onto the Minecraft Forum. Posting here is voluntary. Also, plenty of suggestions from the r/minecraftsuggestions subreddit have made it into the game.
There's plenty of ranged weapons in the game that already do a lot, and since this isn't really developed at all there's no basis for adding it.
I don't think 2 ranged bow variants and a throwable melee weapon count as "plenty". And you say it isn't really developed at all, but they already provided the guns use in the op?
Someone who's been making threads since 2017 should probably know that guns are a hated idea that will never touch the game.
Edit: Why are you suggesting something that you know will never be supported? You made another thread mentioning a gun and it got rejected. Why bring it back up?
lol it's not "strangely absent". It's rightfully absent. derp. I'd hate to see this thing in multiplayer. Guns will just never happen.
Just because people might not support his idea isn't reason for them not to post the idea. And you also gave no detail as to why you wouldn't want the gun in the game.
Minecraft currently has a lot of weapons, but one that is strangely absent, is the gun. Here are some ideas for the gun.
Basic Usage
The gun would be loaded with gunpowder and bullets which can be crafted from iron nuggets. Loading would take a while, and would be interrupted by being attacked and things like that. However, guns would have a longer range than either crossbows or bows. The bullets would also be faster. This would make guns better for attacking at a distance. Guns are crafted as shown in the attached image.
Enchantments
Extra Bullet: The gun can be loaded an extra time while crouching, allowing the gun to store 2 bullets at once.
Velocity: The bullet will go faster. 3 levels possible in survival.
Lucky Drift: The bullet will drift towards the nearest hostile/neutral mob. (not beyond what it would do randomly)
I support this suggestion! It's not OP, it doesn't go into a huge amount of uses, fairly simple and has similarities and differences to Bows and Crossbows. The idea you made, even though a gun, seems to fit in. The wooden handle also makes it seem more Minecraft fitting.
I've seen quite a bit of gun suggestions, but my problem with them is that they just don't really belong.
If you take a look at what Minecraft currently has, it has absolutely no sign of modern-day involvement, save for the redstone. What I'm saying is that most, if not all, blocks have a medieval theme (At least, that's what I think) to them. And guns weren't in the medieval ages (According to my knowledge).
Sorry, but this suggestion gets No Support from me.
Even though you said "save for redstone", you can't just randomly remove Redstone from your argument because it wouldn't fit the point you're trying to make. Everything Redstone has to offer is similar to modern day. Levers, Buttons, Pressure Plates, Command Blocks (similar to computers), you get the point. And even if a gun (a primitive, not modern day one may I note) doesn't fit into Minecraft, you still didn't give feedback to any of the points about it you made, and only talked about the fact that it wouldn't fit into the game.
But the point I want to make is that the world of minecraft is giant and can be much more explored, it would not be useless as there are many mods that bring the experience of other vegetation in the game and many of them are among the lowest, shortly after the beets were added but no one uses. I do not understand why it would be something useless quite the contrary as a user posted above (DuhDerp) could explore other functions with these fruits.
Maybe more critters in the ocean. The ambience in the oceans is already very nice (especially compared to how it used to be), but having little crabs scuttling around, for instance, would make it feel even more alive.
That would be a cool idea! Crabs and other ambient creatures could make the oceans feel more alive!
I want half slaps of grass and rocks What do you mean by rocks? This would be a great idea though! It definetley would make the terrain look way more realistic! it will make the game look far more beautiful and pleasing. If you destroy a slap you wont get it instead you get a block, the only way to get a slap is to use a certain tool. Which tool? Other then these small things, still a great suggestion!
There should also be stone shards or perhaps flint? in forests and in beaches collecting nine shards and you can create a block, aswell as sticks in forests. This could be cool and even open up some new possibilitys for potentially unique blocks or even rarely stumbling upon a reward.
More denser grass or new bushes This could be a good touch in biomes like the Savanna., and more varities of the same trees rather than same look This is already a thing with Spruce Trees, it would be great with the others!. Aswell as treestumps. Aren't fallen trees already a thing?
Some weather update where the trees change color, perhaps even the grass . I am not expecting it to snow, but atleast changing the color of trees etc during some peroid of time. Perhaps leafs on the grass during "fall" This weather update could also bring cold and warmth. Meaning. You need to build a shelter to survive. If you spend long periods of time in cold you move slower. Not draining health but making you slower. And in heat, Draining hunger faster. I don't really agree with this one. What about people going on long adventures?
I mentioned this earlier but i write it again as i expect this post to grow bigger. Calm nights, on these rare night event there should be no mobs playing perhaps fairytail music playing quiet low. I really liked that suggestion!
This forest has tall and dead trees mixed with pine trees and unique mobs like bats(aboveground) and owls Please give more details on Owls., Black wolves spawn here, they´re aggresive. Are they still tamable? Hmmm.... What if they had a unique way to tame them???
-Abounded homes Please give some more details. Good idea, though.
-Ruins Please give some more details. Good idea, though.
-Bird singing and chirping This would be a cool ambient touch in certain biomes.
-Random roads What do you mean by this?
-Wind sound blowing in tress, also make the leafs move a little. This would also be a great addition!
Adding more mobs in this game will make minecraft seem far more alive. That is true, but the only thing is how they would go about adding new mobs.
Mobs
Beaver this creature will cut down wood and steal wood. I don't really agree with mob griefing. On even more rare occasions you will see a beaverdam inside this beaverdam you can find variety of woodtypes, and if you´re lucky a gem. This would be a cool structure to come across.
Brown bear, act as an ordinary polar bear but in forest biome Would be cool. Maybe they could also be black in colour? I think though that they should spawn in Mega Taigas. Maybe occasionally they could grab Salmon out of the river? Good idea!
Chimpanzee this creature will give you fruits if you treat them well. Please elaborate.
Responses in Bold. Good ideas, overall! They could use some more details, but I like them overall!
Fun fact, in hardmode pillagers are force spawned every 5 days. Other events could easily work like that, i imagine. Something that could be interesting would be a night where phantoms spawn regardless of if you slept, although maybe that'd be silly. They just seem so easy to avoid currently.
And they should be. Phantoms are already annoying as is, they only come after 3 nights of no sleep, which is very little for someone travelling to say a Stronghold or across the map.
I have some ideas for events minecraft. Ok, this could be a good concept.
There should be a night where there are no mobs spawning, perhaps during certain lunar eclipse Certain ones?, or fullmoon. This shall be a calm night. My plan is that there should be nice and calm music playing on these rare nights, perhaps even a new mobs like fairy. If you approach the fairy she will heal you up full health.............. What does the Fairy look like? Any specific biomes? Is it neutral in any way? Drops? Is the "healing" a potion effect?
There is also a night where there shall mobs spawn even more And what is the rarity of this night?. The sky turns red And more harsher music is playing Perhaps another unique mob for these nights would be interesting?
If you fish during any one these nights you get unique fishes or items. Would these Fishes and Items be?
Responses in Bold. I like the overall ideas of some unique Minecraft events, but I think the title should be renamed from "Events in minecraft" to "Unique Nighttime Events". I also think you need to add some more detail.
Maybe calm nights where you can seek out special events with Boss fights or challenges. Would make night time more interesting if there were random encounters you could stumble upon.
Isn't the whole point of a "Calm Night" that no hostile mobs are going to spawn?
My idea would be to have some chunks with specific abilities, like the slime chunk that spawns slimes in caves. Alright, good concept.
1. Ore chunk - This chunk would have way more ores than in other ones. It also has less liquids (underground). This would be a good thing to occasionally come across. What would be the rarity, though?
2. Anti-mob chunk - This would be a chunk that mobs would rather not go to, and if there would be a mob in the chunk it will try to escape. This could be good and lead to some good concepts, but is it with EVERY mob? Rarity of chunk?
3. Crop chunk - A chunk that makes crops grow faster/slower than in other ones. This would also work for trees. Good idea. Rarity of chunk?
4. Hostile chunk - Hostile chunks would have more agressive mobs spawn in, and even more hostile ones while peaceful mobs would rather leave the chunk. Good idea. Rarity of chunk?
5. Lucky chunk - This chunk would give you extra luck while you're in it. You have a bigger chance of getting better loot while fishing, you would get more XP, and you might get multiple coals/diamonds from one ore block. Good idea. Rarity of chunk?
Of course these things probably won't ever become a reality, but it's still fun to think about. It would be extremely rare for a suggestion on this forum to become a reality. Mojang and Microsoft do not come onto here.
Responses in Bold. Overall, I like the idea of some more unique chunks. Could use with some more detail, though.
0
1. What does this have to do with the gun suggestion?
2. Are you new here? Everybody on here knows, even the moderators have acknowledged it, that no developers for the game come onto the Minecraft Forum. Posting here is voluntary. Also, plenty of suggestions from the r/minecraftsuggestions subreddit have made it into the game.
Any feedback to fix that?
1. Mojang doesn't come onto the Minecraft Forum anyways.
2. I'm sure plenty of suggestions you'd like to say in the game have already been denied by Mojang.
3. How do guns have "no place in the game"?
0
Any support for your argument or just one sentence? What about the rest of their suggestion?
I don't think 2 ranged bow variants and a throwable melee weapon count as "plenty". And you say it isn't really developed at all, but they already provided the guns use in the op?
Just because people might not support his idea isn't reason for them not to post the idea. And you also gave no detail as to why you wouldn't want the gun in the game.
0
I support this suggestion! It's not OP, it doesn't go into a huge amount of uses, fairly simple and has similarities and differences to Bows and Crossbows. The idea you made, even though a gun, seems to fit in. The wooden handle also makes it seem more Minecraft fitting.
Full Support!
Even though you said "save for redstone", you can't just randomly remove Redstone from your argument because it wouldn't fit the point you're trying to make. Everything Redstone has to offer is similar to modern day. Levers, Buttons, Pressure Plates, Command Blocks (similar to computers), you get the point. And even if a gun (a primitive, not modern day one may I note) doesn't fit into Minecraft, you still didn't give feedback to any of the points about it you made, and only talked about the fact that it wouldn't fit into the game.
0
That's the equivalent of making a suggestion and only having a title.
0
Maybe not taming, but assembling a Skeleton just like you would an Iron Golem or Snow Golem seems like a good idea.
Support
0
Well what are the other functions?
0
Oh, thanks for clearing up the confusion.
1
That would be a cool idea! Crabs and other ambient creatures could make the oceans feel more alive!
Full Support!
Btw I also like The Beatles
0
Responses in Bold. Good ideas, overall! They could use some more details, but I like them overall!
1
That would be a good idea!
Full Support.
Also, Twitch owns Minecraft Forum and that's why you need a Twitch account to log in here.
0
Alright thanks for the update. I guess I do somewhat like the idea but could still use some more work.
Somewhat Support
0
Thanks. I got confused earlier but now it's fine. What about the other feedback I gave?
0
And they should be. Phantoms are already annoying as is, they only come after 3 nights of no sleep, which is very little for someone travelling to say a Stronghold or across the map.
0
Responses in Bold. I like the overall ideas of some unique Minecraft events, but I think the title should be renamed from "Events in minecraft" to "Unique Nighttime Events". I also think you need to add some more detail.
Support, but more detail needed.
Isn't the whole point of a "Calm Night" that no hostile mobs are going to spawn?
Well the developers don't come onto this forum.
Good ideas!
0
Responses in Bold. Overall, I like the idea of some more unique chunks. Could use with some more detail, though.
Overall Support.
What about the other chunk ideas?