YES. IT. IS.
For one, most of the loot is just flesh and bones, both are very common. Secondly, a structure guarding mob shouldn't destroy its home, that's a huge leap in logic. Third, it's a f*cking creeper! Probably the most unoriginal mob idea ever. People have already given you examples of better temple bosses (the gold and moss golem), go read them before you talk to me again.
Threads have been read.
Potential loot is diamonds, not just rotten flesh and bones. Also, creepers have no logic, they suicide charge you. To start an argument on creeper logic would be foolish on your part.
That, and that it's just stupid. Everyone else has already explained why.
Minecraft isnt for children though, so opposing an idea on it not being child friendly enough is a bit silly. Also, if breeding animals and forcing villagers to reproduce is child friendly enough, how isnt this?
Also in SMP voices would overlap eachother and it'd just **** everyone off, and I'm sure you would be the only one who would have it turned on in options.
-GodWaffle
Basically, the voices would form a line/queue and would not overlap, they would play one by one.
I covered that when I talked about logs, pretty much. It would short out from the large amount of power, not allowing a connection with the log. Leaves don't contain sap so it doesn't work on those. If you somehow got restone on a log part of a tree without chopping it off it would still burn itself out because it would have even more alive and clean sap than a regular log.
Enough power to short itself out? Wouldnt this create heat? Heat then causing a fire?
Cuddly? Child friendly? Does having demon-possessed statues have sex (and having it work) in public sound at all child friendly to you? Because that's basically what you're suggesting.
NO SUPPORT
Why not? Is it because you dont think its child friendly enough?
Because the sticks contain more sap (which is what the redstone bonds to and reacts with), and are more alive. Planks are more cut up and processed, and is not covered in bark, therefore the wood is much less alive and contains less sap, which is also why planks don't produce a current, because the sap is more spaced out and external (exposing it to air, solidifying it and making it polluted with dust and organic material that the redstone cannot react with), where a stick has bark on the outside protecting the sap, but can be accessed by the redstone on the top.
Logs don't work because they work too well. Like inverted torches and repeater clocks, when placed on a log the redstone dust burns itself out, not letting the dust on top of it to create power using the sap in the log.
What about living trees? If i put redstone on them wont it generate power?
Since you're not getting it I'll break it up to you one more time:
REDSTONE TORCH=POWER SOURCE
REDSTONE DUST = WIRE So please understand it for heavens sake!
Yes but there is an obvious logic flaw. Redstone dust is just a piece of redstone on the ground. A redstone torch is a piece of redstone on a stick, why should only one of them produce power?
They're obviously jealous of notch's success and how the game has turned out, they dont want another game doing the same slowly pushing them further and further down the creators leader board.
If they loose it'll be good, Mojang deserves to win. Game store and Game station dont sue each other so why should scrolls be sued by elder scrolls? it's just ludicrous and I really will be devastated if mojang takes a defeat.
Yeah, Bethesda, the huge game devloper with millions in sales is jealous of Notch. They are suing because it will cause confusion, nothing more. There is no jealousy, Mojang does not "deserve" to win.
0
If breeding golems is overpowered, what does that make a mob farm or a cow farm or a pumpkin farm?
0
Thanks! Made a support list and added you to it!
0
Not really, if there was a long line it could play the messages at 2x or 3x speed.
0
Threads have been read.
Potential loot is diamonds, not just rotten flesh and bones. Also, creepers have no logic, they suicide charge you. To start an argument on creeper logic would be foolish on your part.
0
Minecraft isnt for children though, so opposing an idea on it not being child friendly enough is a bit silly. Also, if breeding animals and forcing villagers to reproduce is child friendly enough, how isnt this?
0
Basically, the voices would form a line/queue and would not overlap, they would play one by one.
0
Enough power to short itself out? Wouldnt this create heat? Heat then causing a fire?
0
Why not? Is it because you dont think its child friendly enough?
0
What about living trees? If i put redstone on them wont it generate power?
0
I'm not prepared to give up on this great idea, thats why we need to refine it so its acceptable for mojang to implement. It cannot be scrapped.
0
It fits in the theme of minecraft. One of these is perfectly unoverpowered considering how much loot you get from these places.
0
0
Doesn't explain why redstone placed on wood doesn't give off power?
0
Yes but there is an obvious logic flaw. Redstone dust is just a piece of redstone on the ground. A redstone torch is a piece of redstone on a stick, why should only one of them produce power?
0
We discussed this earlier, if there was just one supercreeper would you find this idea more aggreeable?