1a:The reliance on the wiki/community.
Honestly, I would never ever use the book, if I knew about the wiki. Your 'fix' would just force a player to keep another item in their inventory, and should they die in lava, well, time to restart all over. Also, not having a book at all makes it more fun. Instead of giving everything handed to you with every snapshot, you have to try thing out in game, and look through the community for what the patch notes even mean. I love seeing new snapshots are available, because it is honestly the most fun I have, racing others to find out what the latest items are. A book would absolutely ruin this.
Granted, this would make things easier, I believe it would take away from the mystery that lays in the game, even after playing the game for a year.
2a: The difficulty.
If you don't like being able to change the difficulty in the middle of a game, there is an extremely simple fix for that: DON'T. I hate when I see people complaining about features that are completely avoidable, but they still complain about it. Some people out there like being able to have a dynamic difficulty, while others don't.
Pretend that you like being able to change the difficulty (ONLY in single player mind you, which is how it currently is), and you suddenly have that ripped away from you, because someone didn't like it. How would you feel? I personally don't even know what difficulty I'm playing on because I don't change it, but I know people who like to change it if they are about to die.
Honestly, tell me this: how does this affect you in any way? Seriously, how does the fact that I can magically make mobs disappear affect you, and why should this be taken away from me when you can just not use it? Not everything is about you, and if you really feel this way, you are just an arrogant jagoff and shouldn't be pleased anyway.
3a: The mobs.
I love the mobs. When I play MINEcraft (not Combat-RPG-Craft), I love the combat physics. Everything is so simple, and I love it. I know how every mob behaves, because there's like one thing they do: they hit you, you take damage. I mean seriously, why do people expect this super intricate combat system in Minecraft? If you want advanced mobs, play a different game. I'm usually not one to say 'dont like it leave', but seriously, you know the physics of Minecraft.
Again, imagine that you like the current combat/mob system (like I do, very much), and suddenly one day you have an entirely different combat system. You would be pissed, gauranteed.
4a: The biomes and terrain in general.
I hear people constantly complaining about this, and for good reason too. This is literally the only thing you have mentioned that I remotely agree with.
That being said, I think you can look forward to the next update, with pyramids and jungle temples.
5a: Lack of equipment choice.
As previously stated, this isn't an RPG game, its the simplistic game that is Minecraft. I can understand that you want a 'better' combat system, so I would advise looking into the massive community of modders. If your desired mod doesn't exist, I'm sure that there is someone out there that would be willing to program it with you.
6a: Lack of player abilities
Again, it's Minecraft, I don't understand why there should be intricate controls, when mining and placing materials is what the game is about
7a: The community is terrible.
Every open community is terrible. If it is free to sign up for, it is terrible because people like that exist. In the age of the internet and anonymity, anyone can be a troll with no consequences. Go to YouTube, go to any forum, look on MinecraftForums. It's all the same.
If you can find a community that is kind and considerate, please notify me, because I seriously don't believe it exists.
- andrew52525
- Registered Member
-
Member for 13 years and 15 days
Last active Sun, Jun, 10 2012 11:03:17
- 2 Followers
- 485 Total Posts
- 2 Thanks
-
51
j4k3s7a posted a message on The "survival" part of the game is bad on a fundamental level.Posted in: Survival Mode -
232
Kastrel posted a message on The Collector: RebornNews!Posted in: Survival Mode
- List up to date as of February 1, now with 1.1 items and current snapshots!
Ever since The Collector and 2 Double Chests I have been very driven to accomplish some semblance of this goal. Filling a double chest with every item in the game is a daunting task, but in some ways, is not quite as bad as many imagine. Resource aquisition is my favorite aspect of Minecraft, and I feel I cannot build until I have a sufficient quantity of a certain item. There has been some demand for my to make my own thread on this subject for a little while, and I guess its not such a bad idea. I want to give credit to Arbitrax and Eleutherius for creating their original threads; I can never claim this was originally my idea.
The biggest difference between my final goal, and that of the makers of these inspirational threads is that I have never had any hope to truly achieve "a double chest of EVERYTHING". Maybe I'm a pessimist; certain items just sound SO unrealistic, I don't want to set my sights too high. In some ways, certain items don't seem like they warrant having. For instance, why make a double chest full of wooden shovels? I can make it at any time, it only takes 27 wood.
Some advanced items also seem like a waste of time. Using 3456 (the amount held within a double chest) of a resource is a very distinct possibility. Using 3456 jukeboxes, on the other hand . . . seems out of the question.
That being said . . . I'm not willing to entirely ignore these items, but in the name of not burning myself out, I have made a "moderate" list which will still be sufficiently difficult to achieve, without being completely out of the question. I will include excluded items in a separate list, as a bonus, but I will not feel driven to complete them until I finish.
I invite anyone to join me in this endeavor. There is no shame in trying, and then giving up. I myself have no intention of doing so.
I've gone on long enough. Here is my list and current completion, as well as a list of currently excluded items!
My Collection:
Blocks:
Dirt - DONE
Sand - DONE
Sandstone - DONE
Sandstone Half-block - DONE
Glass - DONE
Glass Panes - DONE
Gravel - DONE
Clay - DONE
Bricks - DONE
Brick Stairs
1/54 stacks
Brick Half-Block
18/54 stacks
Cobblestone - DONE
Mossy Cobblestone - DONE
Cobblestone Half-block - DONE
Cobblestone Stairs
2/54 stacks Stone
Smoothstone - DONE
Smoothstone Half-block - DONE
Stone Brick - DONE
Cracked Stone Brick - DONE
Mossy Stone Brick - DONE
Stone Brick Half-Block
4/54 stacks
Stone Brick Stairs - DONE
Normal Wood - DONE
Birchwood - DONE
Pinewood - DONE
Jungle Wood
0/54 stacks
Planks - DONE
Wood Half-block - DONE
Wooden Stairs - DONE
Netherrack - DONE
Soul Sand - DONE
Nether Bricks - DONE
Nether Stairs
2/54 stacks
Nether Fences
14/54 stacks
Snow Block - DONE
Obsidian
24/54 stacks
End Stone - DONE
Ores and Valuable Minerals:
Coal/Charcoal - DONE
Iron Ingot - DONE
Iron Block
19/54 stacks
Gold Nuggets
0/54 stacks
Gold Ingot
39/54 stacks
Diamond
17/54 stacks
Lapis Lazuli - DONE
Redstone Dust - DONE
Flint - DONE
Glowstone Dust - DONE
Glowstone
33/54 stacks
Plant Matter:
Red Flower - DONE
Yellow Flower - DONE
Normal Wood Sapling - DONE
Birchwood Sapling - DONE
Pine Sapling - DONE
Jungle Sapling
0/54 stacks
Leaves - DONE
Birch Leaves - DONE
Pine Leaves - DONE
Jungle Leaves
0/54 stacks
Apples
3/54 stacks
Golden Apples
0/54 stacks
Cactus - DONE
Sugar Cane - DONE
Tall Grass - DONE
Ferns
0/54 stacks
Vines
18/54 stacks
Lily Pads
9/54 stacks
Seeds - DONE
Wheat - DONE
Red Mushrooms - DONE
Brown Mushrooms - DONE
Pumpkin Seeds - DONE
Pumpkin - DONE
Jack'o'Lantern - DONE
Watermelon Seed - DONE
Watermelon Blocks - DONE
Watermelon Slices - DONE
Glistering Melon
0/54 stacks
Nether Wart Seeds - DONE
Mob Drops:
Raw Pork
9/54 stacks
Cooked Pork
18/54 stacks
Raw Beef
1/54 stacks
Cooked Beef
1/54 stacks
Leather - DONE
Raw Chicken
1/54 stacks
Cooked Chicken
0/54 stacks
Feather - DONE
Eggs - DONE
White Wool - DONE
Light Grey Wool
9/54 stacks
Grey Wool
9/54 stacks
Black Wool
9/54 stacks
Pink Wool
9/54 stacks
Brown Wool
6/54 stacks
Orange Wool
9/54 stacks
Red Wool
9/54 stacks
Yellow Wool
9/54 stacks
Lime Wool
9/54 stacks
Green Wool
9/54 stacks
Cyan Wool
0/54 stacks
Light Blue Wool
0/54 stacks
Blue Wool
0/54 stacks
Purple Wool
0/54 stacks
Magenta Wool
0/54 stacks
Ink Sacks - DONE
String - DONE
Spider Eye
2/54 stacks
Gunpowder - DONE
Slimeballs - DONE
Bones - DONE
Rotten Meat - DONE
Enderpearls
21/54 stacks
Blaze Rod
26/54 stacks
Food:
Bread - DONE
Bowl - DONE
Mushroom Soup - DONE
Sugar - DONE
Cake - DONE
Raw Fish
1/54 stacks
Cooked Fish
1/54 stacks
Bucket of Milk
0/54
Technology, Circuitry and Doorways:
Wooden Door - DONE
Iron Door - DONE
Trapdoor - DONE
Fence Gates
12/54 stacks
Minecart Track
21/54 stacks
Powered Rail
0/54 stacks
Detector Rail
0/54 stacks
Minecart
11/54
Storage Cart
0/54
Powered Cart
0/54
Boat - DONE
Lever
1/54 stacks
Button
2/54 stacks
Stone Pressure Plate
1/54 stacks
Wooden Pressure Plate - DONE
Noteblock
0/54 stacks
Dispenser - DONE
Piston
0/54 stacks
Sticky Piston
0/54 stacks
Redstone Torch
6/54 stacks
Redstone Repeater - DONE
TNT - DONE
Alchemy:
Brewing Stand
0/54 stacks
Glass Bottles
8/54 stacks
Cauldron
0/54 stacks
Blaze Powder
0/54 stacks
Magma Cream
0/54 stacks
Fermented Spider Eye
0/54 stacks
Tools:
Flint and Steel - DONE
Fire Charge
0/54 stacks
Bow - DONE
Arrows - DONE
Torch - DONE
Bucket - DONE
Bucket of Water
27/54 gained
Bucket of Lava - DONE
Fishing Rod - DONE
Map
1/54 gained
Shears
0/54 gained
Saddle - DONE
Miscellaneous:
Workbench - DONE
Chests
11/54 stacks
Furnace
1/54 stacks
Bed - DONE
Ladder - DONE
Fences - DONE
Iron Bars
7/54 stacks
Stick - DONE
Sign - DONE
Painting - DONE
Brick Ingot - DONE
Clay Ball - DONE
Paper - DONE
Books - DONE
Bookcase - DONE
Bonemeal - DONE
Snowball - DONE
"13" Golden Record
36/54 gained
"Cat" Neon Green Disc
35/54 gained
"Blocks" Red Disc
0/54 gained
"Chirp" Crimson Disc
0/54 gained
"Far" Light Green Disc
0/54 gained
"Mall" Blue Disc
0/54 gained
"Mellohi" Purple Disc
0/54 gained
"Stal" Black Disc
0/54 gained
"Strad" White Disc
0/54 gained
"Ward" Dark Green Disc
0/54 gained
Empty List for Newcomers!:
Blocks:
Dirt
0/54 stacks
Sand
0/54 stacks
Sandstone
0/54 stacks
Sandstone Half-block
0/54 stacks
Glass
0/54 stacks
Glass Panes
0/54 stacks
Gravel
0/54 stacks
Clay
0/54 stacks
Bricks
0/54 stacks
Brick Stairs
0/54 stacks
Brick Half-Block
0/54 stacks
Cobblestone
0/54 stacks
Mossy Cobblestone
0/54 stacks
Cobblestone Half-block
0/54 stacks
Cobblestone Stairs
0/54 stacks Stone
Smoothstone
0/54 stacks
Smoothstone Half-block
0/54 stacks
Stone Brick
0/54 stacks
Cracked Stone Brick
0/54 stacks
Mossy Stone Brick
0/54 stacks
Stone Brick Half-Block
0/54 stacks
Stone Brick Stairs
0/54 stacks
Normal Wood
0/54 stacks
Birchwood
0/54 stacks
Pinewood
0/54 stacks
Jungle Wood
0/54 stacks
Planks
0/54 stacks
Wood Half-block
0/54 stacks
Wooden Stairs
0/54 stacks
Netherrack
0/54 stacks
Soul Sand
0/54 stacks
Nether Bricks
0/54 stacks
Nether Stairs
0/54 stacks
Nether Fences
0/54 stacks
Snow Block
0/54 stacks
Obsidian
0/54 stacks
End Stone
0/54 stacks
Ores and Valuable Minerals:
Coal/Charcoal
0/54 stacks
Iron Ingot
0/54 stacks
Iron Block
0/54 stacks
Gold Nuggets
0/54 stacks
Gold Ingot
0/54 stacks
Diamond
0/54 stacks
Lapis Lazuli
0/54 stacks
Redstone Dust
0/54 stacks
Flint
0/54 stacks
Glowstone Dust
0/54 stacks
Glowstone
0/54 stacks
Plant Matter:
Red Flower
0/54 stacks
Yellow Flower
0/54 stacks
Normal Wood Sapling
0/54 stacks
Birchwood Sapling
0/54 stacks
Pine Sapling
0/54 stacks
Jungle Sapling
0/54 stacks
Leaves
0/54 stacks
Birch Leaves
0/54 stacks
Pine Leaves
0/54 stacks
Jungle Leaves
0/54 stacks
Apples
0/54 stacks
Golden Apples
0/54 stacks
Cactus
0/54 stacks
Sugar Cane
0/54 stacks
Tall Grass
0/54 stacks
Ferns
0/54 stacks
Vines
0/54 stacks
Lily Pads
0/54 stacks
Seeds
0/54 stacks
Wheat
0/54 stacks
Red Mushrooms
0/54 stacks
Brown Mushrooms
0/54 stacks
Pumpkin Seeds
0/54 stacks
Pumpkin
0/54 stacks
Jack'o'Lantern
0/54 stacks
Watermelon Seed
0/54 stacks
Watermelon Blocks
0/54 stacks
Watermelon Slices
0/54 stacks
Glistering Melon
0/54 stacks
Nether Wart Seeds
0/54 stacks
Mob Drops:
Raw Pork
0/54 stacks
Cooked Pork
0/54 stacks
Raw Beef
0/54 stacks
Cooked Beef
0/54 stacks
Leather
0/54 stacks
Raw Chicken
0/54 stacks
Cooked Chicken
0/54 stacks
Feather
0/54 stacks
Eggs
0/54 stacks
White Wool
0/54 stacks
Light Grey Wool
0/54 stacks
Grey Wool
0/54 stacks
Black Wool
0/54 stacks
Pink Wool
0/54 stacks
Brown Wool
0/54 stacks
Orange Wool
0/54 stacks
Red Wool
0/54 stacks
Yellow Wool
0/54 stacks
Lime Wool
0/54 stacks
Green Wool
0/54 stacks
Cyan Wool
0/54 stacks
Light Blue Wool
0/54 stacks
Blue Wool
0/54 stacks
Purple Wool
0/54 stacks
Magenta Wool
0/54 stacks
Ink Sacks
0/54 stacks
String
0/54 stacks
Spider Eye
0/54 stacks
Gunpowder
0/54 stacks
Slimeballs
0/54 stacks
Bones
0/54 stacks
Rotten Meat
0/54 stacks
Enderpearls
0/54 stacks
Blaze Rod
0/54 stacks
Food:
Bread
0/54 stacks
Bowl
0/54 stacks
Mushroom Soup
0/54
Sugar
0/54 stacks
Cake
0/54
Cookie
0/54 stacks
Raw Fish
0/54 stacks
Cooked Fish
0/54 stacks
Bucket of Milk
0/54
Technology, Circuitry and Doorways:
Wooden Door
0/54
Iron Door
0/54
Trapdoor
0/54 stacks
Fence Gates
0/54 stacks
Minecart Track
0/54 stacks
Powered Rail
0/54 stacks
Detector Rail
0/54 stacks
Minecart
0/54
Storage Cart
0/54
Powered Cart
0/54
Boat
0/54
Lever
0/54 stacks
Button
0/54 stacks
Stone Pressure Plate
0/54 stacks
Wooden Pressure Plate
0/54 stacks
Noteblock
0/54 stacks
Dispenser
0/54 stacks
Piston
0/54 stacks
Sticky Piston
0/54 stacks
Redstone Torch
0/54 stacks
Redstone Repeater
0/54 stacks
TNT
0/54 stacks
Alchemy:
Brewing Stand
0/54 stacks
Glass Bottles
0/54 stacks
Cauldron
0/54 stacks
Blaze Powder
0/54 stacks
Magma Cream
0/54 stacks
Fermented Spider Eye
0/54 stacks
Tools:
Flint and Steel
0/54 stacks
Fire Charge
0/54 stacks
Bow
0/54
Arrows
0/54 stacks
Torch
0/54 stacks
Bucket
0/54 stacks
Bucket of Water
0/54
Bucket of Lava
0/54 stacks
Fishing Rod
0/54 stacks
Map
0/54 gained
Shears
0/54 gained
Saddle
0/54
Miscellaneous:
Workbench
0/54 stacks
Chests
0/54 stacks
Furnace
0/54 stacks
Bed
0/54
Ladder
0/54 stacks
Fences
0/54 stacks
Iron Bars
0/54 stacks
Stick
0/54 stacks
Sign
0/54 stacks
Painting
0/54 stacks
Brick
0/54 stacks
Clay Ball
0/54 stacks
Paper
0/54 stacks
Books
0/54 stacks
Bookcase
0/54 stacks
Bonemeal
0/54 stacks
Snowball
0/54 stacks
"13" Golden Record
0/54 gained
"Cat" Neon Green Record
0/54 gained
"Blocks" Red Disc
0/54 gained
"Chirp" Crimson Disc
0/54 gained
"Far" Light Green Disc
0/54 gained
"Mall" Blue Disc
0/54 gained
"Mellohi" Purple Disc
0/54 gained
"Stal" Black Disc
0/54 gained
"Strad" White Disc
0/54 gained
"Ward" Dark Green Disc
0/54 gained
Total: 102/187
Bonus/Silk Touch Exclusives:
Mycelium
Grassy Dirt
Mushroom Blocks Stalk
Mushroom blocks (red cap)
Mushroom blocks (brown cap)
Redstone Ore
Bonus/Exempt List:
Excluded List:
Too Difficult
Cookies
Cocoa Beans
Gold Ore
Gold Block
Diamond Block
Diamond Ore
Lapis Block
Lapis Ore
Jukebox
Compass
Clock
Enchanting Table
Ghast Tear
Eye of Ender
Diamond Ore
Lapis Ore
Red Dye
Green Dye
Purple Dye
Light Blue Dye
Light Grey Dye
Grey Dye
Pink Dye
Lime Dye
Yellow Dye
Cyan Dye
Magenta Dye
Orange Dye
Redundant:
Coal Ore
Iron Ore
Wooden Pickaxe
Wooden Axe
Wooden Sword
Wooden Shovel
Wooden Hoe
Stone Pickaxe
Stone Axe
Stone Sword
Stone Shovel
Stone Hoe
Iron Pickaxe
Iron Axe
Iron Sword
Iron Shovel
Iron Hoe
Diamond Pickaxe
Diamond Axe
Diamond Sword
Diamond Shovel
Diamond Hoe
Golden Pickaxe
Golden Axe
Golden Sword
Golden Shovel
Gold Hoe
Leather Helmet
Leather Body
Leather Legs
Leather Boots
Iron Helmet
Iron Body
Iron Legs
Iron Boots
Diamond Helmet
Diamond Body
Diamond Legs
Diamond Boots
Golden Helmet
Golden Body
Golden Legs
Golden Boots
-
17
trolllolol posted a message on What Grinds your gears?Posted in: Survival ModeQuote from Buhwahdmoda
Hello again Minecraftians!
I would like to know what grinds your gears.
Post what you dislike like..... ummm I hate it when I have 32 diamonds and I fall into lava and lose it all!
I dislike creative sandbox games' that involves circles.......... Push the plus botton in the corner of this message if you agree!
Only 17 people? thats sad - To post a comment, please login.
1
(puts a invedited diamond into a chest in an abandoned mine)
YEP!
JUST WAIT A SECOND
1
But yes, I enjoy making them.
:biggrin.gif:
2
But yea, in minecraft,
one chest for wood
one chest for wooden things
5 chests for cobble
1 chest for other stone related things
1 chest for redstone
one chest for coal/glowstone/everything that isnt listed here
5 chests for dirt
1 chest for nether materials
1 chests for plants
1 chest for iron/gold
one chest for mob drops
one chest for wool/dyes
one chest for food
one chest for tools
one chest for my diamonds/alchemy stuff
did i miss anything.................
I forgot minecarts.
I like minecarts.
1
cover myself with dirt.
and stay there.
FOREVER.
1
rofl.
on topic: have been looking for a thing like this for a while, hope it works!
1
i love mods!