If you look at all of the posts i quoted you can see make excuses such as "too hard to code" or "Too RPGish" That doesn't make the suggestioning worse. So yes Theriasis i had a reason to say they were not invalid. I didn't respond cause i felt like it.
As you may or may not know i take pride in finding and criticizing bad suggestions. This is the most ambitios post i have made and i have wanted to tackle this one for a while. I just find the idea of guns in minecraft silly and unneeded.
But before i get to that here are some quotes.
Or it might be a game about a modern-day college professor who was sucked through an inter-dimensional portal.
Or maybe it's science-fiction, and Steve is an astronaut who narrowly escaped the destruction of his starship.
Or it could be a completely abstracted setting, whose only unifying trait is an aesthetic style.
(The point being, it is virtually impossible to pin down Minecraft's setting, and whatever you pick, someone will always be able to provide evidence for something else, thus making it an exceedingly bad point to try to argue.)
When given contradictory information regarding the actual setting of a medium; apply Occam's Razor. In this case, the setting that allows for the most contradictory elements to simultaneously occur is the most suspect.
Given that guns have been used in Final Fantasy. STOP! You do realize that just because Final Fantasy has that word in it doesn't make it a 100% fantasy. To me it seems like a midevil setting with fantasy elements. There is also 13 in which firearms are present. But that is a futuristic setting.
Not only that, but actual LASER RIFLES, the "guns aren't fantasy" theory holds little weight. Final Fantasy VI, originally for the Super Famicon was the earliest mainstream game to explore the concept of actual firearms used as weapons. Chrono Trigger also had firearms during 1000AD (considered it's Renaissance period) carried by Chrono's nerdy best friend, Lucca.
Guns and other weapons are only limited by YOU. Your imagination. If i wanted a world where dinosaurs and demons terrorized people but the protagonist Was a panda bear in his 80's using a highly advanced space laser than that is what would happen in a game idea.
Naah, it's the story of a demi-god who has been sent to a punishment location until they can defeat the guardian and learn the truth about reality.
Cool idea.
Guns as a generic weapon would not work. They would overshadow the bow and be a bit overpowered. If we have to have a gun based weapon why not portable dispensers? 2 iron and a dispenser. Using this in a craft table with something that represents an element would add an elemental effect to the items fired.
Fire-Blaze powder
Ice-Snowball
Explosive-Gunpowder.
You get the idea. I just find the idea silly and unneeded. But that's just me.
I don't think this would fit Minecraft well. The game is just too... 'stupid'. Alongside with that, it is very difficult to code. But if it were to be implemented, I swear the game would never be boring again. Support!
I really like this idea. However, I can see that many players would feel that this is completely game changing and too "rpg". So was enchanting, and villager trading. The game evolves, and we should welcome it. Support
Diamonds are the stuff that every single Minecraft player wants, Diamonds are the best tool in the game, but some people like iron and gold, Especially Sky Army.(I'm problably going to get hate comments for not calling it butter) But that stuff is not as valuebuale as Diamonds. The soulotion, More Ores! Minecraft should have More Ores, some as valuebuale as Iron, Some Diamond, and Some even Higher. These are the ores Minecraft Should have.
Copper-Same Strength as Stone Tools
Alluminum-1 Higher than Iron
Platnium- Same strength as Alluminum
Ruby-Same strength as Diamond
Emerald-1 Higher Than Diamond (I know they already have Emeralds, but they shoulf have Emerald Tools)
I know many mods have these ores but this is for Vanilla Minecraft.
These seem pretty pointless. I wouldn't mind new ores that can be used to make new stuff. But new teirs just arn't one of them for me.
When i saw this news post i thought well look at that they got their handed to them and they are gonna come up with a lame excuse but the unfunny train continues.
0
0
0
But before i get to that here are some quotes.
Proof? At least in pikmin there is evidence to suggest it.
I agree! I like your ideas.
Guns and other weapons are only limited by YOU. Your imagination. If i wanted a world where dinosaurs and demons terrorized people but the protagonist Was a panda bear in his 80's using a highly advanced space laser than that is what would happen in a game idea.
Cool idea.
Guns as a generic weapon would not work. They would overshadow the bow and be a bit overpowered. If we have to have a gun based weapon why not portable dispensers? 2 iron and a dispenser. Using this in a craft table with something that represents an element would add an elemental effect to the items fired.
Fire-Blaze powder
Ice-Snowball
Explosive-Gunpowder.
You get the idea. I just find the idea silly and unneeded. But that's just me.
0
All of these are invalid cretiques. Makining excuses for something not being in the game.
This isn't exactly what i would want from villager upgrades but it's still good.
0
Maybe you should take this up with support.
Also what emails are you getting? You only have 4 posts there can't be THAT many unless you are getting a lot of warnings.
0
0
These seem pretty pointless. I wouldn't mind new ores that can be used to make new stuff. But new teirs just arn't one of them for me.
That's a kinda bad reason to make new ores. You have the right intentions but your reasoning is flawed.
0
0
0
I like the ideas though.
0
0
0
0
Nevertheless I Support.
0