• 0

    posted a message on Name based textures

    Yeah, but isn't that a mod while your idea is meant for vanilla? 50/50 support.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Oceans

    Everything sounds plausible except the pufferfish bypassing armor (that makes so little sense it hurts) and the Depth Sinker enchantment. That sounds like concrete shoes, do I get that enchantment, from the mafia? Potential support except for those two things.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Please read THIS before making a suggestion. (v2.0)
    Quote from LeadBullet999»

    SOOOOO glad I read this


    So you've read the guide, yet in your suggestions you've...

    • Mistook criticism for "hating".
    • Expected people to finish a suggestion for you.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Auto-Mining Machine
    Quote from LeadBullet999»

    why are you just hating on all my ideas?

    really, why?


    Fun Fact: reading posts can explain why I'm """"hating"""".
    Quote from LeadBullet999»

    It mines the block in front of it, you'd need something placing/pushing those diamonds into place, it's not a quarry

    it's more for automatic cobble farms

    Do we honestly need an auto-mining cobble farm? For one of the easiest blocks you can get? The game runs more on a do-it-yourself type of playstyle, which sensibly works very well and for good reasons. I could've sworn there was a specific tweet explaining why Mojang didn't want automated things.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Add Turtles Mojang!
    Quote from LeadBullet999»

    so I can't leave anything to other's imagination?


    You're not leaving stuff "to others' imagination", you're just waiting for other people to walk in and fill in your suggestion's blanks for you. Never ever leave a suggestion incomplete for others to finish. It's not their job. It's best to ask for others' to pitch in their views after something is completed.

    Didn't you say that you read the suggestions guide? The guide does go over that.

    that means no credit to mojang other than implementation into the game (and coding it).

    That makes no sense.

    I guess the armor is silly...
    turtle meat, perhaps?, and I see what you mean about the riding...
    But I do want more pets in the game, so I suggested turtles, and we need more ocean life, all we have is the squid :(


    There should be more going for an idea than you just 'wanting it'. The turtle meat is... slightly better, but it's just more redundant food at this point. Just because there's more of something added doesn't automatically make it good.

    Again with AI, I suck at describing that, the best i can come up with is that they hide in their shell when enemies are within 10 blocks, and will sit/stand on richt click, they are 2x as slow as the player, and if attacked (untamed) will either bite for a heart of damage, or hide in their shell (which blocks all damage like the shield currently does), when hiding, only an axe or arrows can damage it.

    Sooo... you suck at describing AI, then you proceed to actually describe the AI adequately. On top of that, most of those attributes are alright.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 3

    posted a message on Auto-Mining Machine

    So you're just chilling somewhere while some machines is mining all them diamonds for you? I don't think I need to explain why that's biblically unbalanced. No support.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Add Turtles Mojang!
    Quote from LeadBullet999»

    just edited the main article to answer most of the questions I saw

    Points for effort, but I don't see any use in taming/riding a turtle. There's also no need whatsoever for another type of armor. "Turtle armor" is really, really goofy. Maybe the player could wear the shell in the chestplate slot or something, but even then it's still pretty weird.

    IDK how to describe AI, I guess others could come up with that

    Nooooooope nope nope nope. This is your suggestion, don't rely on others to finish your idea for you.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Trains

    A done before idea but a good one. I'm a little surprised we haven't gotten this yet.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 2

    posted a message on Needed Slot System Upgrade!

    Not being able to have both a chestplate and elytras at the same time is deliberately done for balance. This suggestion just cheats around that. I find all of this unbalanced and most of what's in this suggestion are already-debunked things. I'm neutral on the enchantment and quill.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Please read THIS before making a suggestion. (v2.0)
    Quote from LightningSh0ck»

    You can obviously remove more inventory slots as left hand slot and shulker boxes got added.

    I'm talking about more passive inventory slots. Not storage space. Sure you can carry a shulker box around, but you can't just nab 5 strength potions from it on the spot, you still have to put it down like a chest and manage your inventory like you would a normal chest.

    Sorry but your "80% opinion" line was kinda dumb.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on For the Critics (FTC)
    Quote from needsomehelps»

    -snip-


    This was horrendously one-sided. Maybe you just have trouble dealing with negative posts?

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Please read THIS before making a suggestion. (v2.0)
    Quote from LightningSh0ck»

    Which are still debatable and shouldn't be put on a "wall of shame".

    See, now I'm having some trouble believing that you actually read all of those. Because a good chunk of those actually have me mentioning that some of those suggestions are passable when you do them right. Hell, even the subtitle to that very section says that.

    If you can disprove any of those entries, I'll happily remove or change them. Which is something I've done before. Right now, I'm just getting general "wall of shame/I hate this thread" vibes from you with no specifics.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Please read THIS before making a suggestion. (v2.0)
    Quote from LightningSh0ck»

    See, that's why I hate this thread, it's 80% opinion.


    no.

    Did you even read that entry? Did you read any of those entries?
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Recorder Block (to record audio)

    I don't know how the game handles mics, but regardless, a good idea. Though this should be admin only as these could get real annoying.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Quests

    This idea falls into the same trap every other quests suggestion has been lying in the bottom of. I've also never seen a quests suggestion succeed, and it's all because of the same reasons every time: there is no need for direct objectives in a sandbox game where you can do what you want, and NPC's would just make Minecraft be something that too many games already are. The game also works fine with the player being one of the few humans around, unless you play multiplayer.


    It's a good idea, but not a good Minecraft idea. Quests/stories also run the risk of just being mediocre. Every time someone suggests a story for this game, it just comes out like a 4th grader's C+ writing project.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.