• 1

    posted a message on Endermen Improvements

    Some of these are okay, but I don't want endermen running away with the diamond ore I was going for. Hell no.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 2

    posted a message on Guidelines for the Suggestions Forum
    Quote from Chameleonred5»

    Some things are bad. That's not a terrible thing to say. There's nothing wrong with it. It is simply a statement that describes reality. Though as a starting point, something for beginners as this thread is trying to be for? I'd say that micro-scale arguments don't fit into it, even if we'd love beginners to know them. It's more something for those who would like to be here a while or would like to earnestly put effort into one of those suggestions.

    I wish more people understood this viewpoint, instead of seeing it in the most extreme one-sided "all or nothing" way of thinking. Going "suggest whatever you want =D" is not a full positive in a forum like this. Not with things that already negatively established even outside of this forum.

    Some suggestions are a permanent no-win situation, no matter how you try to rationalize yourself out of it, or blame the forum for "just not getting it!"
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Some Mobs Drop Their "Armor"

    These sound like balance-scrambling pieces of armor with pre-enchantments on them. Not something I'd want in vanilla...


    If you want to know about suggestions that usually fall through the cracks, I'd recommend reading the unofficial suggestions guide. Or at least the portion about 'inferior suggestions'. /notpluggingatall

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 2

    posted a message on melon golems.
    Quote from Badprenup»

    Seems a bit to powerful


    "A bit"? Those seeds might as well be nukes. This thing can kill you in seconds. There's really no need for more golems, and this is just a cheap copy of the snow golem. This melon thing puts even the Iron Golem to shame. No support.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Update Ideas - Wood! Changes
    Quote from PlanetJupiderp»

    If you have your own ideas about wood, let me know!


    Yeah I have one. Give the suggestion guide a read because you made a wishlist.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on New Mobs for 1.13? Ideas
    Quote from MagmaLord»

    That's all. If they suck, please don't be rude.


    Hate to break it to you, but if someone is planning on being rude. It'll probably happen no matter what. Anyway...

    Fire Flecks - Not a fan of the name, but maybe passable mob.
    Ice Imblings - Nopex1000. There should never be a mob that just stops your movement outright.
    Amethyst Celestials - I don't get the name? Why have a copy of slimes minus fall damage?
    Flying shulkers - This feels like a classic "Less X, but more Y" mob.
    Wisp - Sadly, this might be the only mob I fully support.
    Lava Grambaler - Ehh maybe, sounds too similar to these fire fleck things.

    I wouldn't say "they suck lol" but most of them don't sound very unique.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on More Treasure Enchantments

    Retrieve and maybe Fell ('Timber' or 'Lumberjack' might be better names) are really the only ones I can get behind, the others don't fit very well or are overpowered.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Update Ideas - Chestplate Clip

    *sigh* The elytra and chestplate are not meant to be equipped together. I don't understand why so many newer users here keep suggesting that. The 'backpack' idea falls into the same overpoweredness trap. Because that is a ton more inventory slots to be walking around. Not that this is a big deal, but banners as capes kind of water down the point of rare capes. Now people are just crafting their own capes? I'll pass.


    The sponge idea is alright. The cactus is just a cheap cheat to get thorns instead of getting the enchantment, so that just punches balance in the mouth twice over. 4 free armors by clipping something cheap to yourself? I'll pass. The redstone part risks messing up circuits by starting them from the wrong end. The daylight sensor thing is random and mobile beds are another balance issue.


    The only thing supportable here is the sponge.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Biomes in the Nether and End
    Quote from PlanetJupiderp»

    The problem with the nether and the end at the moment is that there's not much to encourage the player to explore. There are end dungeons and nether fortresses, but once the player finds one of these, that's about it in terms of exploration. Also, the fact that trying to sleep in the nether or the end makes the bed explode really holds people back from staying there.


    Because you're not meant to be glued to these dimensions... That's really the whole point. These places not having biomes isn't a problem.


    A few of these ideas are copypastas from the Overworld that don't exactly make me want to explore these dimensions any more than I already do. Some of them are okay ideas, while the others don't fit all that well.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Lore Spot In Anvils

    This should just be called a description, "lore" is not really a minecraft thing.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Guidelines for the Suggestions Forum
    Quote from Gamelord»

    Why is the new status quo becoming to just list things said in the section you don't like?


    Say what you'd put in the guide regarding it, or at least offer some kind of argument.


    I think his point is that people shouldn't make suggestions that are dorky ragey rants just because the game doesn't have something you just thought up.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Guidelines for the Suggestions Forum

    Revenge Posting


    "There's the guy who hated my idea of creepers speaking l33tspeak. I'm gonna lob some serious poops at his popular thread about a new biome. That'll show him >=} !!" No, it will not show him.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on ❄ Rideable Polar Bears and Bear Armors! ❄
    Quote from Virdex»

    Bears are more rare and more cool.

    Uhhhh? :huh:

    This is a subjective, goofy and just a pinch of a not-so-mature statement. I don't think the "coolness" of bears has any weight on the quality of the suggestion.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on WE NEED APPLE PIE
    Quote from TheDoctor90520»

    Your a genious!


    *You're *genius

    It's an okay idea but it doesn't really add anything I'd cross my fingers for.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Rebalancing Lesser Armors- Giving Use to the Useless
    Quote from Badprenup»

    To me it seemed abundantly clear that the other magic armors were just examples of what could come in the future and not a core part of the suggestion.


    I thought that too, until he said he'd go into it more if it got more support. That's just a weird loop/trap. Something is better off being detailed to get someone to support, but to get the details... we need more support?
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • To post a comment, please or register a new account.