• 1

    posted a message on Craftable Backpacks
    No. This has been suggested over 100 times. Learn to use search and re-read the rules before you ever post an idea again.



    Gameplay: 6/10

    Though I agree this would help us carry more stuff, I find Minecraft is easy enough already, and it needs to get harder, not easier. But I'll give you a 6 because it wouldn't be horrible

    Creativity/Originality: 2/10

    This has been suggested before. A lot. Like, 100+ times. I'm starting to get sick of telling people to use the search bar. This is in no way original and as far as creativity goes this isn't so hot there either.

    Effort: 1/10

    You didn't search and this post is barely a paragraph long. I see little to no effort in this post. You get a 1, ad be thankful it isn't a 0.

    Extras: -1 for rule-breaking

    Final Score: 1.3

    Verdict: You should re-read the rules and learn how to search before you even think of posting again. Close this thread.


    /thread
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Some ideas to make minecraft better...
    Gameplay: 6/10

    Minecraft isn't an RPG, and it isn't Terraria. You didn't say how these would make Gameplay tons better, and I can't see them making it better at all.

    Creativity/Originality: 2/10

    What originality? Of the many things you suggested, not one of them hasn't been suggested before. This idea is dead andflat-out stupid as far as originality and creativity go.

    Effort: 0/10

    You obviously put next to no effort into this idea. You didn't search ANY of the many ideas you posted, your idea was barely a paragraph of the post, and you didn't even take the effort to read the rules and see you broke 2 of them. Goose-eggs for you.

    Extras: -3 for rule-breaking twice. Rounded down for rule-breaking.

    Final Score: 3

    Verdict: This idea is against the rules. And it sucks. I recommend re-reading the rules.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on [Closed]
    Gameplay: 2/10
    Why mine it up when I can buy it? Money ruins minecraft and is quite pointless. If you want it, get the iConomy mod.

    Creativity: 1/10
    Seen this idea before, this idea is hardly new. It's been suggested and said no to quite a few times.

    Effort 4/10
    You put effort into the post, but very little into the idea. PLUS you didn't search and learnt hat this is already suggested.

    Extras: -1 for rules breaking

    Final Score: 1.3

    Verdict: No. THis suggestion is horrible. Close the thread NOW!
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 2

    posted a message on The NOTCH I BEG OF YOU Thread
    Quote from Ovus »
    Quote from Sam1234299 »
    Notch,
    I beg of you to please listen to this thread. It has so much meaning to it, and could surely help the community out! Nobody likes creepers anyway, so why put them in SMP? Please Notch, won't you please consider this?

    At least 1/4 of Minecrafters "hate" the creeper, according to an old poll. That's a hell of a lot of hate.

    Get...a...mod! Why should notch waste 2 hours of his life when you can just get the no creepers mod or the no explosions mod on your server? Quit being lazy you idiot.


    Ugh, next time read the whole post before responding.

    TLDR: Hate waiting for mods to update. Need ability to disable creepers now.


    Creepers are the staple of MInecraft. Notch will not get rid of them or give you that choice. Get a mod. The no explosions mod still works with 1.5 I believe. That should solve your problem. And not 1/4 people hate them, 1/4 people who looked at this thread did. That's a far cry from everyone looking at it.

    SOLUTION 2: Build your stuff in well lit areas. Your fault if you let it blow up.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 5

    posted a message on Anon's 5 Rules of Game Design
    Quote from Mt.popsicle »
    That doesn't mean anything on what we are arguing about. Seriously, have you read the description of the suggestions forum topic on the main page?


    Is there another place to put this? This is a suggestion about how to make a suggestion. Threads like this have been supported by mods and admins and players for quite some time now.
    Posted in: Discussion
  • 4

    posted a message on Anon's 5 Rules of Game Design
    Quote from Mt.popsicle »
    Yeah, that isn't a suggestion concerning Mine Craft. This concerns the Mine Craft forums. Two different things.


    viewtopic.php?f=1&t=279635
    Hey! One of many stickied posts pertaining to the forums! What could this mean?
    Posted in: Discussion
  • 5

    posted a message on Anon's 5 Rules of Game Design
    Quote from Mt.popsicle »
    hat are you to judge? You can't just say that sir. I think you should of chose a different forum topic because this doesn't fit in the suggestions. Problem? You bet.


    This is a suggestion pertaining to suggestions. He wrote well, and if you don't like what he has to say, get out.
    Posted in: Discussion
  • 4

    posted a message on Anon's 5 Rules of Game Design
    The title was very misleading, I came here ready to fight, and froze. You won the game mah boi, you won the game!
    Posted in: Discussion
  • To post a comment, please .