Maybe as a separate game mode. MAYBE. Better as a mod, in which you have 100 MC days to prepare. By the way, I love your description. That was my favorite parody besides the Jesus one.
I remember when this was posted... The original idea is VERY bad. It would cause a lot of unnecessary lag. Even the edited idea is bad, as many people employ the use of mob farms. Ever heard of a toilet getting clogged? Think of the same thing, except with corpses. All the unnecessary clicking is bad too. Many just want to kill a passive mob with a diamond sword without stopping. People who desperately need food could die trying to retrieve the pork. Don't even get me started on efficient mob farms... Don't you dare mention the feature being optional. DON'T.
You must really do your research... As people have said, it is AS, sometimes in better detail. Also, shields are virtually useless unless you have a more dynamic combat system. However, the way to use it that you suggested is good. 1/5
I said at the beginning of my post that some of them may have been suggested before. And how are the boots over powered? They have half the durability of leather, but they block all fall damage. It's not like killing cows. You are actually fighting a powerful hostile mob.
Just because you say you know you are breaking the rules doesn't mean it is okay. In fact, it makes it worse.
OT: To describe how the boots are OP, let me create a hypothetical situation. A person builds a farm that kills all mobs in a swamp, which, by the way, doesn't exist yet. This person now has almost unlimited protection against fall damage.
I propose that you have the option to view the topics in three ways.
Caveat: This is, as the title states, focused towards the suggestion forum, so some reasoning is ONLY for the suggestions forum.
1. In order of popularity
Obviously, the most popular pages show up first. The popularity is determined by a liking and disliking system, similar to Facebook. I feel this would be good for devs and for newcomers, so that they may view the most popular suggestions, such as the Aether, New Nether, etc.
2. In order of the most recent
The most recently posted topics show up first. This is to see the latest ideas.
3. The current system
Pretty self explanatory. I think you would want this if you were in several arguments, so you can see as soon as the other side makes a post, or a similar situation.
Edit: Topics may also be stickied if there is enough popular support.
I'd like to say that I HAVE read the rules, and I would like to know exactly why this is.
While these are all new mob ideas, they are not at all related to each other, except for the fact that they are mobs, which does not count for anything. I believe only the first one deserves to be in the game, but the item, the boots, do not. The boots are very overpowered, especially for multiplayer. Anyway, the croc has also been suggested many times, so make sure to search.
0
1
0
0
I already saw it. Why do you think I love the description?
0
0
Please search before posting.
0
0
0
0
Just because you say you know you are breaking the rules doesn't mean it is okay. In fact, it makes it worse.
OT: To describe how the boots are OP, let me create a hypothetical situation. A person builds a farm that kills all mobs in a swamp, which, by the way, doesn't exist yet. This person now has almost unlimited protection against fall damage.
0
0
Caveat: This is, as the title states, focused towards the suggestion forum, so some reasoning is ONLY for the suggestions forum.
1. In order of popularity
Obviously, the most popular pages show up first. The popularity is determined by a liking and disliking system, similar to Facebook. I feel this would be good for devs and for newcomers, so that they may view the most popular suggestions, such as the Aether, New Nether, etc.
2. In order of the most recent
The most recently posted topics show up first. This is to see the latest ideas.
3. The current system
Pretty self explanatory. I think you would want this if you were in several arguments, so you can see as soon as the other side makes a post, or a similar situation.
Edit: Topics may also be stickied if there is enough popular support.
0
I would say this: this has been suggested many, many times. I may have seen this suggestion 100 times or more. And in much better detail, mind you,
0
While these are all new mob ideas, they are not at all related to each other, except for the fact that they are mobs, which does not count for anything. I believe only the first one deserves to be in the game, but the item, the boots, do not. The boots are very overpowered, especially for multiplayer. Anyway, the croc has also been suggested many times, so make sure to search.
0