I'd vote for the romance ending just because of how freakin weird it is. No story ever ends that way! Second choice would be for the mystery ending, as it has the most potential.
Also your writing is colorful and easy to follow but you have a huge problem with tense. You keep mixing past and present tense. Probably stick to past tense, which is normal for third person stories. For example, "There WERE (past tense) quiet whispers spreading throughout the village as everyone WATCHES (present tense) the spectacle that HAD (past tense) become Molly and her moms argument."
The easiest and most sensible solution for this is to change watches to watched. Check through each sentence and look at each verb. If it ends in "s" or "es" then it should probably end with an "ed" instead.