• 0

    posted a message on Stages of tree growth
    Quote from BlueCoin»

    I don't think it's really fair to dismiss an idea because it might effect those who let the game play itself.. Minecraft is a survival sandbox game, not an idle game. It can be the latter but it shouldn't be prioritized over the intended ways of playing. Worst case it makes auto farms maybe a little less efficient, but who needs thousands of logs anyway?



    Anyway..

    I think this could be a neat feature that adds more immersion into the game. I'm thinking developing logs would drop sticks when cut early, and blocks in the way could halt growth, allowing you to keep a stage of tree for builds.




    "I dont think its really fair to dismiss an idea because it might effect those who let the game play itself."


    Well id have to ask, what is your definition of fair? Because i would argue that "fair" is being thoughtful of minecraft's current community, and doing your best to help it rather than carelessly ruin some of the gamers favorite parts of minecraft.


    I dont think its fair to sacrifice something that a decent portion of the minecraft community uses, just for "immersion" when there are "other" ways to make minecraft more immersive.


    "Its a survival sandbox game not an idle game


    What you must realize is a "sandbox" game allows players to do "what they want". Minecraft developers gave us pressure plates for a reason, which is so something can happen without you doing anything, like moving a bunch of blocks. Minecraft is a sandbox game for people who want to survive AND build, not just survive.


    "But who needs thousands of logs anyway?"


    I dont know about you, but i dont make small builds. Theres a lot of players, like me, who like to build big villages and nice houses and other big things like a wall.


    "Im thinking it could add more..."


    Haulting the progression of a trees growth could be used as an excellent way to add something decorative to a world. Something a lot better than just letting it grow slowly.


    BUT. As i said before, im still not fond of the idea for the same 2 reasons as my previous post.


    More types of trees i find to be a better idea, followed by more uses for trees like getting maple syrup from a maple tree would be interesting. But stages of growth offers so little. Maybe if it werent a problem for farms and it had more uses, id be more open to it cause that sounds more "fair"

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on The New Breeds Update

    It was real old, yours much better detailed

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Stages of tree growth

    Now im definently okay with us getting more types of trees


    Imagine trees with actual branches lol, could look really natural and cool

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on End Rod Horse Armor

    Welll idk, lets be creative here


    I think we can still get light from this rod using static light.


    When you stand still, the light turns on, but when you move it turns off.


    Something temporary until minecraft developers gets the cash or a team to handle the dynamic update



    Also i still question why this wouldnt work. I mean, i can make light appear to move by simply using redstone and a redstone lamp... it will follow you where ever you go to.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on End border mobs (end whales)

    I actually really like this idea lol. Kinda seems fitting with the end city ship to have flying whale looking creatures


    And the idea that their tail is like wing is absolutely perfect. It almost gives you a pirate like feeling.


    Then you also have a very good point about there not being a good way to get the elytra currently



    I honestly cant see why this, or something simular, shouldnt get added to the game! We got 3 mobs in the end world dimension so Full support lol

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Stages of tree growth

    Why? I cant see this being fun, satisfying to see, or necessary.


    Infact, minecraft is actually better with things instantly growing (rather than go through stages) when it comes to making redstone contraptions to detect growth for automatic farms


    Even if automatic farms werent an issue, theres way too many other small things, that id rather see in the game. Far too many


    Not supporting this

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Sleeping without setting your spawn point (Sleeping without a bed)

    BEFORE YOU READ: Everything under title "Old Post" can be skippied! Im only leaving it there for those who helped me with this idea!


    That is all :)


    :) >>>>>>> New Post <<<<<<< :)


    This is a new in game item suggestion


    Sleeping Bag


    ▪Crafting: 6 pieces of wool (im too lazy to think of anything better for this part)


    ▪ Its purpose: Sleep without setting a spawnpoint


    ▪Cons: You can only use the bag 10 times, it takes a long time for you to go to sleep (prehaps a minute), and you risk not spawning close to the location of your death which could result in the lost of your items.


    ▪Pros: You no longer have to worry too much about losing your spawn point after sleeping far away from your campsite/home.


    Thoughts?


    :) >>>>>>>> End of New Post <<<<<<<< :)


    >>>>> Old Post <<<<< (Badprenup's comment on October 29th, 2019 is the 19th and final comment for the old post. Any after that were made after my update above)


    ("Edit 2" that is 7th paragraph, seems to be the most favorable way of adding this idea to minecraft that people are agreeing on, check it out)


    Something ive always wanted to do in minecraft is sleep in my cool custom bed thats made out of concrete but it looks like a soft bed lol


    So what if we were given the option to lay down and sleep anywhere HOWEVER if its not done on a bed, your spawn point will not be set.


    Why


    1.) Players basically are able to sleep anywhere they want already by just taking a bed with them. So this will just make the process easier without worrying about setting a spawn point


    2.) Imagine going to a friends house in minecraft, but if you were to die you wanted to spawn in your own home instead of at your friends house. Well, now you can!


    3.) Makes the game a little more realistic since realistically speaking humans are able to sleep on floors, ive seen it before although they didnt feel too great afterwards 😂


    Edit 1: Another great reason to add to his that someone mentioned in the replies below, is that it would help us deal with Phantoms, allowing you to get rid of them without setting your spawn point. You still cant sleep while monsters are near but if you find good cover like you would with a bed, it will work just fine


    Edit 2: Just got a suggestion saying that we should have a craftable sleeping bag or something that breaks after you sleep in it. This will be used for sleeping without changing your spawn point too. To make it less "overpowered" some are saying that it should negatively affect your hunger in some way


    (I was also thinking that it would be cool if sleeping without a bed could be done in the daytime too, to make day into night. Idk about you but i like seeing my world at night sometimes)


    >>> End of Old Post<<<

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Sleep without setting your spawn point (no bed)

    Something ive always wanted to do in minecraft is sleep in my cool custom bed thats made out of concrete but it looks like a soft bed lol


    So what if we were given the option to lay down and sleep anywhere HOWEVER if its not done on a bed, your spawn point will not be set.


    Why


    1.) Players basically are able to sleep anywhere they want already by just taking a bed with them. So this will just make the process easier


    2.) Imagine going to a friends house in minecraft, but if you were to die you wanted to spawn in your own home instead of at your friends house. Well, now you can!


    3.) Makes the game a little more realistic


    I was also thinking that it would be cool if sleeping without a bed could be done in the daytime too, to make day into night. Idk about you but i like seeing my world at night sometimes

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Sounds

    It would be if they were to make a redstone component that makes contraptions quiet


    Or maybe make it to where, if you surround a redstone item with blocks, it mutes the sound

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Minecarts

    A train would be amazing! We could use leads to connect minecarts together!

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Parkour! (Do a barrel roll!)

    Why more parkour?


    So i was playing this game called Assassins Creed, and the parkour on there felt amazing! So i thought it would be cool to try and make a parkour world on minecraft. Problem is, the only thing you can do is jump and land on something. You can climb at a very slow pace too but that doesnt feel to great.


    My Suggestions:


    - Ledge hanging


    Whenever something is 1 block above your head, you are airborne, and youre facing this block, youre arms will extend upward on to the block making a hanging looking animation. Press the Jump button to pull yourself up, or the Sneak button to let your self fall down. You can also move side to side but it will be slow.


    - Slide


    Pressing the Sneak button while running makes the player slide over 4 blocks, allowing the player to fit through a 1 by 1 block hole. The player can slide another 2 blocks if they fall down 1 block and are still in their sliding animation.


    - Wall running


    When you're near a wall after jumping, you can either face a wall sideways while running to run horizontally on the wall for 5 blocks, or you face the wall dirrectly and run up the wall for 2 blocks.


    - Vaulting


    When you approach a 1 block tall fence, jumping towards will cause the player to vault over it. Imagine running from a creaper and vaulting over a fence so that it couldnt get you!


    I can see all of these changes making your exploration on minecraft maps a little funner, giving you more options to move freely around your world!


    Thoughts?

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Adding diseases/viruses in Minecraft

    I like the cold idea, the rest not so much but yea, the cold one i love

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Beehive appearance and minor alterations

    Mojang like, we kinda wanna be realistic, but also dont.


    I think the game would benefit from being realistic, and using potions or cheats to let players know theyre doing something that isnt realistic.


    Lol i went off topic, you have a good point, agree with u lol

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on The New Breeds Update

    Yea i posted an idea like this back in May. I think after cats got an update, wolves/dogs should have been next to get one. Kinda weird not to do that when so many players love dogs as much as cats

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Grizzly Bears/Brown Bears

    Yea i like this, but i wish they would have added something like this sooner. Instead of turning polar bears into grizzly or brown bears in all my favorite texture packs ☹



    Every texture pack has one or more things i dislike lmao, i hate the way they give out texture packs. Id rather purchase a textured block or mob one by one, and put into a custom texture pack, than be forced to loose my polar bears because i want to use a different texture pack lol

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • To post a comment, please .