Minecraft Forums

You are the one who did the LOTR mod! I love your mods, SO MUCH. This mod is just amazing! must have took ages to complete.
a for you :3

http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/2730608-why-minecraft-sucks/

I have posted my personal review of the minecraft, on the game's forums. Is there any problem with that? No, all of the replies were angry minecraft players who can't accept an opposing opinion. I didn't insult your game neither was i trolling, then why are you angry? Most of them didn't even read the review and jumped into conclusions. I said that i play the game with mods and i like it, but the vannila game is bad. Many people said get of the forum or don't play the game if you don't like it, even though i did say i like the game with mods! Which proves that no one want to discuss any thing in the "DISCUSSION FORUM!". And then of course a Moderator lockes the thread. Please DISCUSS and don't hate on honest reviews.

This Mod makes the minecraft world, which is lifeless and bland, to a very amazing place. There are animals everywhere which are far better than the default and derpy mobs. A Big Thank you to the mod creator, you made minecraft playable. But i do suggest that you make the lions hostile, which can a bit of challenge to the game, overall 10/10

This....Is one of the best mods i have ever played, in any game, not just minecraft! I hated the default minecraft with its boring world and creatures, even with some mods it is kinda good...maybe. But this mod is the best, the number of mobs and biomes is just mind-blowing. But i really suggest that you add cities, even if it will take a year, i will still wait.This mod is the only reason i play minecraft. Thanks for posting this mod! i give it a 9999999/10

I heard a lot about this game called Minecraft, so i bought it and started playing for 6 hours. So this will be my personal review of Minecraft.
The First thing i noticed is that the graphics are horrible, even though i don't care much about graphics in gaming, but this game's graphics are very bad. The Gameplay is plain and simple, which isn't a bad thing, but it lacked originality. Combat is very standard and mediocre. The Biomes are bland and lifeless. The Mobs are very disappointing, and the monster's AI is just terrible. Villegers are the worst thing about this game, they don't do nothing when attacked or when they are being robbed by the player! Plus their trades are totall rip-offs. Mining is pointless, it very easy to find diamonds within the first 20 minutes, but then you never find any more of them! the multiplayer is one of the worst i have ever seen. Every server i have been into, has annoying 12 year sqeakers which make you want to quit gaming for ever. Final Verdict: 4/10 I have enjoyed to the game for the first hour or two. But When i went deep into the game, I found out that it sucks. But then i installed some mods which made the game awesome, and i still play it now (with mods only!) But The Vannilla game it self, sucks hard.

Please Post Your Opinions, But please no Fanboyism Or Bias towards the game.

Well, that's the Internet for you; it's funny how something so high tech can be so uncivilized. There are a few jerks on YouTube who do seem to hate on Minecraft just to screw with people, and I guess it's sort of become touchy at this point. Anyway, good luck with your modded fun.

Some people, especially on this forum, take offence to negative reviews on the game. I think the main reason you got hated is probably because you only mentioned the cons even though you said there were good aspects to Minecraft. You also counted things you said didn't matter (like the graphics), the immature part of the community is something I can agree on to an extent, not all the community is like that. Just make sure that you have some pros to weigh out the cons when making Minecraft reviews on the Minecraft forums. Hope that clears some things up and have a nice day.

I sorta have to agree, but I sorta have to disagree too. These types of posts are going to be common on this topic, because you might have angered some of the players here. Well, not me, but some other people.

Okay, so the graphics are supposed to be primitive, because this game was designed like that.
I agree that the biomes are lifeless. They needs more mobs.
The monster AI is... bleh... But, have you tried playing on hard mode with a horde of mobs around you?
I think villagers are supposed to be the derpy things that they are. They can defend themselves from mobs with Iron Golems, though.
I don't know what mine you're going through. TELL ME YOUR SECRETS.
And the servers... Well, I haven't seen 12 year old kids. I've seen 7-9 years old jerks.

And that's about it, I'm in the middle with you.