Minecraft Forums

SCORE

Total 060 /100

Presentation 15 /20
Formatting 15 /20

Usefulness 10 /20
Originality 20 /20
Vanilla? 00 /20

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Usefulness (10/20) - I see how this could be useful but its just a hat right?

Originality (20/20) - Well i will say ive NEVER heard this one before. was this a joke?

Vanilla? (00/20) - This is just too silly. a hat as a boat/minecart?


OVERALL - No. Just NO...

Notes-
Score By
-DINGO_WINTERWOLF
Suggestion Forum Critic

SCORE

Total 020 /100

Presentation 05 /20
Formatting 05 /20

Usefulness 00 /20 -Im Not Seeing Much Point In This Mob

Originality 10 /20 - Well, There Are Quite A Few Horror Suggestions, but there is Already Creepers/Endermen

Vanilla? 00 /20 Maybe As A Mod But Its Not Vanilla

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
OVERALL - Sorry Mate But This Is Not For Minecraft.
Score By
-Dingo_Winterwolf
Suggestion Forum Critic

THIS IS THE CUTOFF FROM WHEN I REBUILT THE THREAD

I'm sorry to say that all of your threads that ive read have been ridiculous. and not at all Vanilla and not worth a mod.... don't give up, just THINK!

ok.....
1; I cannot understand ANYTHING you are saying!
2; I am a Critic and understand most of what people mean when they make a suggestion but i still have no idea WTH you are saying.
3; Try adding more detail like, health, movement and other factors.
4; I give this thread an F-.

Quote from yoshi9048

Here's the thought.

When you run out of air bubbles, you begin taking heart damage in the form of blue (deoxygenated) hearts. This is the "damage".

When all of the hearts turn blue, you drown and die. RIP is your name.

If you surface but are in water, you regain your air, but your hearts remain blue as you are drowning and fatigued.

If you step on dry land, you regain a half-red heart at the same rate that you would lose bubbles while submerged.

You can only regain as much as you have blue hearts, you will not regain hearts you do not have.

thank you again yoshi, ill add that to the thread

Quote from yoshi9048

FailedAssassin

Most epic turnaround of new poster I think I've seen. Highly receptive to criticism and clear in thought. Haven't seen him lately, shame.

Thank You Yoshi! You found the post. its nice to hear from you again.

Quote from Jellomob

Meh,


HERP

Didn't see the "You Re-spawn" part


Putting "You die" would cause less confusion btw

Ill Remember That Next Time

I'm Not Evan Going To Bother Righting A Review!
......ITS MINECRAFT! NOT TREECRAFT! God Mate, If you don't like it go buy a Virtual Garden Game!

Quote from CVGX

so basicly we won't lose anything for drowing? also that makes no sense, as that is basicly just a second air meter.

Logic. you need it.

also I can tell by the pics that computer is bad

When I Say Respawn, Its The Technical Term For, "YOU DIE"
EDIT: ALSO No Need To Slander Me Because My Computer Is "BAD"
It Is Obvious You Did Not Read The Whole Thread.

EDIT

Due to recent events i have broken this Suggestion.


The Good News Is
MOJANG ACCEPTED REMOVING DROWNING KNOCKBACK!

It Just Goes To Show You That The Forums Do Help MineCraft

Being A Critic, I Usually Post A Score Sheet.... For This All I Have To Say Is, This Is Pointless. Just Get New Baby Animals. Simple As That. Score 0/100

Quote from TyberAlyx

Dungeon designs will be awesome but limit it to 100x100x100 the guild is 80x90x40 so its pretty big. (order is length x width x height)

Great, Where do i send them?

Quote from tuckermon123

my ideas are the dwarfs should be the honeydew skin. the elves kingdom could be a giant hollow tree and the warriors could use bows? reply back if like

So, That Means.... Maybe You Can Recruit Dwarvern Axemen And Elven Archers?

Once Again, I Have But One Question.... What Can I Expect QuestWize?
Also, With The Great Chance Of Notch Adding RED DRAGONS Wouldn't You Include The Clasic
"Dragon Slayer" Quest?
Also, If I Sent You Some Dungeon Designs, Would You Conciser Them?