• 0

    posted a message on The first 2 numbers of a seed determines a specific biome
    Awesome idea, but something like this would be "too late" to implement.

    I personally wouldn't be affected, but it would change the familiarity with most seeds because land generation would need a complete rework with this. For example, using the seed "01999282472" might not generate that desired island anymore, because it would spawn you in some plains. And I think it ruins the point of survival if you can just choose your biome like that.

    This sort of thing sounds perfect for the "Customized" world though.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 3

    posted a message on Backpacks
    Quote from TheKokoed»
    Yes, yes, I know this has probably been suggested many times, but I want to put it out again.

    Then you might be aware that redundant threads get locked here.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Dyed Arrows
    It's a clever idea, but could be complicated and inventory cluttering. If this is for stuff like archery competitions and whatnot, then this would be best suited for a mod/server plugin/whatever. This doesn't seem too useful in singleplayer.
    Quote from Gilbat

    Hmm, maybe how there are multiple damage values for colors like for wools, it would just use the lowest numbered damage value first?

    Quote from notecardpasta»
    Maybe bows randomly select a certain stack and keep using it until there's nothing left, then go on to the next stack.
    Then you wouldn't be able to choose what color arrow you fire. They could just make it so the arrow directly above the bow is the one that gets fired, but that warrants having to implement such a system in the first place just for colored arrows.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Add the Sky Dimension!! Bring Back What was going to be added! [30 SUPPORTERS!!]
    Quote from deathisfate»

    I thought we were done with this. :huh:

    Ignore that, I replied to the wrong person. And on top of that I didn't even carefully read the person's post that I meant to reply to. Sorry guys, this post is not here. You can't see this.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Add the Sky Dimension!! Bring Back What was going to be added! [30 SUPPORTERS!!]
    Quote from deathisfate»

    If you want my comments on that, please read the "arguement" from earlier.

    You mentioned how Mojang "didn't keep their word" when they actually weren't keeping any word at. The sky dimension was a possibility, an idea, not something we would be guaranteed to exist. People were just hoping for that sky dimension, didn't get it, and then took it out on Mojang whom made no actual promises.

    So it's pretty much on our end for the disappointment, not Mojang's, because we got ahead of ourselves and convinced ourselves we'd be getting a heaven sky dimension.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Balanced Emerald Tools/Armor
    I'm curious to what compels people to want emerald armor/tools so bad.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on clay golem
    Quote from Pixel_Robot
    i have been playing the game for less than a month and i don.t see any reason why not to have another golem

    The more important question here is "Why?" and not "Why not?" What makes this golem so special? So far it's just another golem with no outstanding original features other than the fact that it's just made of clay.
    Quote from Pixel_Robot»
    my last post was listed as a "wishlist" whatever that is
    A wishlist is more than one unrelated suggestions in a single thread. You should really consider reading the suggestion guide.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on Camels
    Quote from Pixel_Robot»
    i don't know how to be more specific or explain it further

    Then perhaps you should have waited until you had more info before posting a thread? Vague threads get locked here. You might want to add more info before that happens...
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on clay golem
    Quote from Pixel_Robot»
    and i'm surprised they didn't add them until now

    How long has it been since you played the game? We've had both golems for over 3 years...

    I don't see much uniqueness or reasoning for why we need yet another golem slapped in the game.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Please read THIS before making a suggestion.
    Quote from yoshi9048»

    You get no useful information from seeing 8 "yes" or 6 "no". Any information you can use is in the body of each of the critics' posts. THEREFORE: request to suggesters: do NOT add yes/no polls to your thread, you shoot yourselves in the foot every time.

    Pretty much this. Even better, do what I did with my suggestions. First ask how much someone supports your idea, then ask if your presentation was spot on regardless if they supported or not. You get way more info and have a bigger chance of improving future suggestions.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on A few fixable biological problems
    These are not "problems", these are just mechanics you don't agree with and want changed.

    The apple thing isn't an accident. I can't see why Mojang would specifically make apples have a 0.5% chance of dropping from only oak leaves (which is hugely increase when you bring down and plant many more oak trees) and then punch that in the face by making apples more common because... just because.

    As for the chicken thing... It's really not hard to find seeds and make them breed with it, and if you have even a small chicken pen, you'll be given more eggs than you'll know what to do with. No support for any of that.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Balanced Emerald Tools/Armor
    Bryself4164, I think you should add some middle-ground grey area in your poll, rather than having just "I love it!" and "I hate it!" options.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Cake, When Broken, Turns into a Drop.
    This suggestions need to be changed where only a pickaxe can turn the uneaten cake into a drop. That's a joke, because the idea is fine as is. Support.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Prismarine Ore
    Quote from Farmcollector»
    I'm always happy to see ideas that make ocean monuments even more useless. Now if we could just craft sponges out of rotten flesh already...

    Don't know if that sarcasm was needed, but I do agree with this.

    Adding 'Method B' of getting something waters down the 'Method A' of it, and things like that end up being not-so-good suggestions more often than not. Having that "people might call me stupid" thing in your thread title looks unappealing and unprofessional, and if you're sure that people won't like your idea, why post it? That showcases a huge lapse in judgement. That can also come off as you trying to get attention through self-pitying (something even the guide tells you not to do).

    I won't say this is stupid, but I do find it completely pointless because this is just copied content from ocean monuments. I'll give a 10% support because I would be interested in adding something for just ocean biomes, but not what you suggested.
    Quote from Genlems5Ever»

    Steel?
    Nah. I disagree with the guy you replied to big time, there's no need for more tools and Mojang stated there won't be more anyway...
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on /summon Player [y] [x] [z] [dataTag] to create fake players or statues
    maybe spectators could control them but thats a stretch.

    Yeah, that's a huge stretch. I think something like that requires more explanation than one sentence. If you give some more details here, I just might believe your username.
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • To post a comment, please .