• 0

    posted a message on Minecraft 2.22 suggestion

    We don't really need more fruits given the amount of foods we have already. At that point, it's just more sprites to eat for the sake of more sprites, unless the fruits have some uniqueness given to them. It's also best to explain what you want, instead of "more that" and "more this". The banner beds idea is mildly interesting, granted.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on New Dimension

    Mojang said there will be no new dimensions. This also sounds extremely generic. Look at the two dimensions we have, they are original and have their own things going on. This suggestion just copypastes the deep dark into its own dimension and that's it.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 2

    posted a message on NEW FOOD IDEA FOR MINECRAFT: LET'S INTRODUCE CHEESE!

    Credit words due, this isn't badly worded for your first suggestion here. I was ready to rush in and go "nope we have enough food types already", but this has added mechanics rather than just existing to be "m0re foods guys!!!" like a lot of threads here get caught up in. I don't know if I'm on board with the block of cheese nor the slices. Although I like the bait idea, which does need more explaining.


    If you're suggesting a new potion recipe or something like that, it's best to tell us the potion up front, as not everyone is gonna check back to see if you added more info, if you do, that is.


    So, for now... partial support.


    Edit: Having ALL CAPS THREAD TITLES!!111!!!! is not a good idea btw.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Make Minecarts FASTER!!!

    This isn't how you propose a suggestion. "Just make it happen!" and nothing else doesn't and won't help you.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Version based capes

    So... everybody just cheaply gets a free cape because of version changes? No thanks. Capes should be special, or at least more so than simply updating your game.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Why Minecraft needs vertical slabs.
    Quote from Bowman6464»

    I support this idea, but Mojang said vertical slabs never will be added to Minecraft. They said, it would "inhibit creativity". On the other hand, they claimed they weren't going to add "auto-crafting", but finally it' coming in 1.21 as "crafter". So, the fact that Mojang isn't going to add vertical slabs to the game isn't permanent.


    That's not really how that works. "Well, Mojang is going to add something they said they weren't in the past, so that means that this other thing - that is completely unrelated to the first idea - they said they weren't going to add will also probably be added." I'm pretty neutral to the whole vertical slab thing, but never saw too much of a point in it despite making some eye-catching designs with it. Sorry, but I'd have to agree with Mojang on this one.


    Although if it was added, I'd probably use them in a "sure. why not" sense, but I never saw them as being that important.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Owls and Arrows

    Late reply, but credit words due, the idea isn't terrible. I could get behind this if it was added, but it feels a bit redundant since enchantments could take that role. I also don't see the point of the allay arrow.


    Partial support.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Smelting objects

    Good point, Ducky!

    although material seperation might come in handy. I don't know if the Education edition has that... it has some kind of material-bending thingy, but I think that's a creative mode thing.

    What about turning doors.stairs, etc into sticks? a minor return, if sticks could be crafted back into planks with enough of them?


    yaknow what they say, Save the Planet, Recycle ROTFL (just kidding) Just a random thought.


    Hi!


    ??????????

    Woah and woah, no shade but... talk about a necro. The person you're replying to hasn't been here since 2017. As for the sticks idea, it seems extremely menial, since you're surrounded by trees, and therefore, even more planks, and therefore even more sticks. I mean, I can't imagine a situation where you need a few extra sticks that badly.


    I of course don't support the metal recycle idea since that seems abuse-able, and I'm neutral on the sticks idea because, again, it's just sticks.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on RIP Zombie Pigman

    Oh man, talk about a blast-from-the-past thread.


    What does "the baby zombie pigman can fly similar to an allay." mean?

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on The way to fix potions

    Stacking potions - even with the amount of 8 - is still painfully overpowered. Just one or two potions can turn the tide in things, so walking around with stacks of many, many different powerful potions would be overpowered beyond thought. I don't mind the Potion of Leaping idea, but that could be too high depending on where you are. The Strength potion seems to be powerful enough, the inventory idea is original (to me at least), so I'll give you that, but that seems like an... "out there", obscure way to balance the potion.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Agriculture Update!

    "More foods" suggestions don't seem to go that far, because they're just extra sprites to cram down our throats with slightly different hunger fill values. Also, you threw in a "cave update" in there. Huh? That's not how these work. The idea focuses on farms and food, what does a cave update has to do with that?


    Also, you name-dropped deer, turkeys and vultures with no explanation to them. How much health do they have? What do they do? Where do they spawn? What unique things do they add to the game that other mobs don't offer? I'm not trying to sound mean, but vultures are the only thing I'd support.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Koalas and Eucalyptus trees. (and Koalas hugging baby Koalas and players (: )

    Yeah, having the koalas overall is a decent idea, and the mechanics behind them are also okay. The hugging thing (or at the very least, the smiling thing) seems a bit too cheesy and cutesy for my liking, but that's just me talking.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Koalas and Eucalyptus trees. (and Koalas hugging baby Koalas and players (: )

    The ideas in the thread are fine, also needing the disguise just to feed these things apples feels like a pointless bit of work, unless it doesn't work that way. Also, I don't get what this means:

    and when hugging the face will smile to add more immersive feeling and cuteness to the game.

    Huh..?

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 1

    posted a message on An enchanted/upgraded lead that can be used to limit Mob Pathfinding and tether them to a location.

    This is actually one of the most original ideas I've seen. On top of that, this is also a fantastic first suggestion for someone making their first post. I think I can actually support this. Although I have this strange feeling like there's a balance issue that I can't quite see yet.

    Posted in: Suggestions
  • 0

    posted a message on Atualização

    Translation: "hello mojang you can bring the bousa and bring the fireflies to not be food for frogs but put flies for the frogs to eat and the fireflies you could give a special liquid and for old cities bring these new stone chests and bring the soul fire to make the sculk fragment and the portal to the new dimension it will be cool if it has glowing jellyfish and new beings and magnificent creatures and friendly beings like the vilager but in this dimension it would be soul beings since the sculk absorbs souls we have to fight with creatures wanting these souls and the breeze can fall sticks from the wind is one of the elements of fire and yes you could make new items for this stick and yes my theory could be wrong but you have to stop putting mobs and bring the dimension that people want and don't refuse That's why people leave mine, that's why if you bring a dimension, it can be cool and new armor and weapons, oh, also bring the copper horns, It's cool and can have special horns with magnificent effects, this update can do that, I don't want to be mean, I'm just helping with this message. Thank you: Victor"



    This is an English-speaking forum, so a lot of people would just see that, go "Uh, what..?" and just happily click elsewhere if there was no translation. Mojang doesn't come to these forums, so any "Hey Mojang! I think you guys should..." narratives don't change anything. And uhhh... wow I'm seeing lots of different vague ideas. Uhhhh... about that...
    Posted in: Suggestions
  • To post a comment, please .