Umm tbch, that wasn't EXACTly constructive, but sorry...
"Constructive" does not always mean "positive." If someone is giving you constructive criticism on something, they will not always go and say "woah dude this is the best suggestion ever theres nothing wrong with it its awesome!!!" In this case, he was saying "Why do we need a new ore?" It's a legitimate question. Minecraft already has plenty of ores. Suggesting a new ore for the sake of a new ore doesn't really do much. (By the way, Mojang has said there will never be an ore above diamond.) Speaking of it being above diamond, how is malachite stronger than diamond? In real life, malachite is copper. Copper is in no way better than diamond. Now, with all of that said, it doesn't mean that there's no reason at all for a new ore. If you were suggesting some other mechanic that this new ore was a part of, then that could be more considerable, but as is there is no need for another ore. Even the "bucket that holds 3 times more" thing doesn't really make sense. How does a bucket made of the exact same amount of material as a normal bucket have more storage? Is it some sort of TARDIS bucket? And why do we need that anyways? With all that said, keep in mind that I'm not saying you're a horrible person, I'm not absolutely trashing your suggestion, I'm telling you how it could be improved. That's what constructive criticism is. Now it's your choice how you respond.
This is a nice idea, I like it a lot. I feel like the skeletons dropping the cloak half the time might be a bit high, but it isn't too overpowered, so it might not be a problem. Another question I have is, does it slowly degrade while you're using it like an Elytra? If so, you may want to increase the hit points, but that's just an idea.
I think this would be a good addition. I'm also assuming that Husks and Strays would have the same footprint as their counterparts (strays use the skeleton one, husks use the zombie one)?
Edit: Also, would slimes and magma cubes have prints? I mean, they don't really have feet, but the prints could just be a single square the size of the mob.
2
"Constructive" does not always mean "positive." If someone is giving you constructive criticism on something, they will not always go and say "woah dude this is the best suggestion ever theres nothing wrong with it its awesome!!!" In this case, he was saying "Why do we need a new ore?" It's a legitimate question. Minecraft already has plenty of ores. Suggesting a new ore for the sake of a new ore doesn't really do much. (By the way, Mojang has said there will never be an ore above diamond.) Speaking of it being above diamond, how is malachite stronger than diamond? In real life, malachite is copper. Copper is in no way better than diamond. Now, with all of that said, it doesn't mean that there's no reason at all for a new ore. If you were suggesting some other mechanic that this new ore was a part of, then that could be more considerable, but as is there is no need for another ore. Even the "bucket that holds 3 times more" thing doesn't really make sense. How does a bucket made of the exact same amount of material as a normal bucket have more storage? Is it some sort of TARDIS bucket? And why do we need that anyways? With all that said, keep in mind that I'm not saying you're a horrible person, I'm not absolutely trashing your suggestion, I'm telling you how it could be improved. That's what constructive criticism is. Now it's your choice how you respond.
1
Not everyone has played TF2, you know.
0
This is a nice idea, I like it a lot. I feel like the skeletons dropping the cloak half the time might be a bit high, but it isn't too overpowered, so it might not be a problem. Another question I have is, does it slowly degrade while you're using it like an Elytra? If so, you may want to increase the hit points, but that's just an idea.
Overall, support.
0
This really makes a lot of sense, and I think would fit well.
And I sorta get why they shouldn't be craftable, but I still feel they should be.
Either way, Support.
2
I think this would be a good addition. I'm also assuming that Husks and Strays would have the same footprint as their counterparts (strays use the skeleton one, husks use the zombie one)?
Edit: Also, would slimes and magma cubes have prints? I mean, they don't really have feet, but the prints could just be a single square the size of the mob.
Either way, support.
2
I pretty much agree with all the other critic's arguments.
And... Why do you use the "-__-" emote so much? And what is ":2" supposed to mean?
1
Haha, good luck keeping this alive for a while.
Anyways, I'm a pony. Like, a MLP pony. I have a feeling this post will be ignored though considering who made it...
0
0
Burritos!
0
0
0
Nice! I like it.
0
lyra u wot
A
0
You have been proven wrong, sir.
0
I made this btw