My daughter's game no longer allows her to scroll down in the LOAD or CREATE screen. Any attempt to scroll down bounces down one then almost instantly back up (as if someone is also holding the directional pad up). This is only in this game (all others work) and only in those two screens, but obviously that brings the game to a screeching halt unless you only play in the first world on the list.
Tried new controller. No help.
Cleaned disc. No help.
Bought new disc. No help.
Repaired data files on console in SAFE MODE. No help.