I've noticed many people posting threads on this forum about how they wanted feedback on their youtube channel. A majority of these threads have no replies, which I find a bit sad. I got the inspiration for this thread from another thread on yogscast forums. I feel like it is needed here so that people can be given proper feedback and can further improve their youtube channel. *DISCAIMER* The feedback I will give is CONSTRUCTIVE CRITISISM. Do not be offended, it is just what I think you need to do improve on.
I posted the same thread in lets play help because I feel like it fits into both categories.
Your channel will be judged on:
Video and Audio quality.
Whether the content is innovative or not.
Quality of ccommentary (it's okay if there is no commentary)
Channel Design and Upload structure.
Average video quality.
How engaging the video is
The review will be set up like this:
Video and Audio Quality:
Innovative Content?:
Quality of Commentary:
Channel Design and Structure:
Average Video Quality:
Engaging?:
Overall: 4.5/10
The review will be my opinion only. I have seen plenty of lets play videos, and I think I have an idea on what is good and what is not. I have experience making gaming videos as well so I will be able to help you with any problems you have. Ratings will be as follows :
1/10 -Terrible
5/10- Mediocre
10/10- Awesome
IN ORDER TO HAVE YOUR CHANNEL REVIEWED:
You must fill out this form detailing your channel. Give me 3 of your best videos/ videos that describe what your channel is like. I will watch your videos ONLY ONCE, and give you my first impression of your youtube channel. I will also look at your channel layout and tell you what I think.
Channel Name: (Obvious)
Channel Type: (Monogame - where you mostly play a single game, Variety, Informative, Let's play etc)
Footage Captured on: (Console/PC or a mix of both)
Microphone Model: (Blue Yeti, Buit in etc)
Age: (Obvious - doesn't matter if there is no commentary)
Gender: (Obvious - doesn't matter if there is no commentary)
Upload Structure: (For example: Whenever I want, Every Day, every Monday etc).
Video Links: (Give a Brief description of each one as well).
Do you think your videos are innovate, original or informative?:
Why do you make YouTube videos?:
Additional Information: (PC Specs, etc)
Here is an example of how I would fill out the form for my channel.
Channel Name: Sushixgaming
Channel Type: Scripted and Non scripted gaming videos
Footage Captured on: PC
Microphone Model: Im not really sure :\ It changes video to video depending on whether its just a filler lets play, or a scripted comedy video.
Age: 18
Gender: Female
Upload Structure: I upload at least once a week. Once a month, I upload a scripted comedy video.
Video Links:
1: A parody of the song "Run Devil Run" minecraft version.
2: A video on how to make a good lets play video, more informative than my other videos
3: A video NOT ment to be taken seriously. Where I teach people how to be good at Dragon Nest if they are complete slackers like me.
Do you think your videos are innovate, original or informative?: I try to upload my videos once a week so I don't dissapoint my subscribers, so some of the videos are just for fun, and are just the typical "lets play video" where I only show funny parts. But from time to time, I do like to make original, scripted videos, so I would say my channel is innovative in a way. I don't have an informative channel, because that is not the type of channel I want to create.
Why do you make YouTube videos?: I love to edit videos, and play games. So why not make a gaming youtube channel Its a hobby.
Additional Information: Intel core i7, 8 gigabyte memory, nVidia graphics card.
I use paid version of fraps to record, and Sony vegas 10 pro to edit videos.
If you are easily offended/ cannot take constructive critisism please do not post here. If I were to rate my own channel, I would give it a 6/10. You do not need a good channel to review others I guess I will try to review everyones channel as soon as possible!!!
Channel Name: JadanMC Channel Type: Monogame Let's Plays Footage Captured on: PC Microphone Model: Plantronic Headset Age: 13 Gender: Male Upload Structure: Bi/Tri Weekly Video Links: I reintroduce the series and survive my first night on Punchwood Island Do you think your videos are innovate, original or informative?: Slightly? I just have fun! Why do you make YouTube videos?: For fun. And maybe if I get a bank account, money... Additional Information: (PC Specs, etc) AMD Sempron 145 Processor NVIDIA GeForce 6150SE Graphics Card 500GB Hard Drive 2GB DDR3 Memory (2 gigs of ram)
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I posted the same thread in lets play help because I feel like it fits into both categories.
Your channel will be judged on:
- Video and Audio quality.
- Whether the content is innovative or not.
- Quality of ccommentary (it's okay if there is no commentary)
- Channel Design and Upload structure.
- Average video quality.
- How engaging the video is
The review will be set up like this:Innovative Content?:
Quality of Commentary:
Channel Design and Structure:
Average Video Quality:
Engaging?:
Overall: 4.5/10
The review will be my opinion only. I have seen plenty of lets play videos, and I think I have an idea on what is good and what is not. I have experience making gaming videos as well so I will be able to help you with any problems you have. Ratings will be as follows :
1/10 -Terrible
5/10- Mediocre
10/10- Awesome
IN ORDER TO HAVE YOUR CHANNEL REVIEWED:
You must fill out this form detailing your channel. Give me 3 of your best videos/ videos that describe what your channel is like. I will watch your videos ONLY ONCE, and give you my first impression of your youtube channel. I will also look at your channel layout and tell you what I think.
Channel Name: (Obvious)
Channel Type: (Monogame - where you mostly play a single game, Variety, Informative, Let's play etc)
Footage Captured on: (Console/PC or a mix of both)
Microphone Model: (Blue Yeti, Buit in etc)
Age: (Obvious - doesn't matter if there is no commentary)
Gender: (Obvious - doesn't matter if there is no commentary)
Upload Structure: (For example: Whenever I want, Every Day, every Monday etc).
Video Links: (Give a Brief description of each one as well).
Do you think your videos are innovate, original or informative?:
Why do you make YouTube videos?:
Additional Information: (PC Specs, etc)
Here is an example of how I would fill out the form for my channel.
Channel Type: Scripted and Non scripted gaming videos
Footage Captured on: PC
Microphone Model: Im not really sure :\ It changes video to video depending on whether its just a filler lets play, or a scripted comedy video.
Age: 18
Gender: Female
Upload Structure: I upload at least once a week. Once a month, I upload a scripted comedy video.
Video Links:
1: A parody of the song "Run Devil Run" minecraft version.
2: A video on how to make a good lets play video, more informative than my other videos
3: A video NOT ment to be taken seriously. Where I teach people how to be good at Dragon Nest if they are complete slackers like me.
Do you think your videos are innovate, original or informative?: I try to upload my videos once a week so I don't dissapoint my subscribers, so some of the videos are just for fun, and are just the typical "lets play video" where I only show funny parts. But from time to time, I do like to make original, scripted videos, so I would say my channel is innovative in a way. I don't have an informative channel, because that is not the type of channel I want to create.
Why do you make YouTube videos?: I love to edit videos, and play games. So why not make a gaming youtube channel
Additional Information: Intel core i7, 8 gigabyte memory, nVidia graphics card.
I use paid version of fraps to record, and Sony vegas 10 pro to edit videos.
If you are easily offended/ cannot take constructive critisism please do not post here. If I were to rate my own channel, I would give it a 6/10. You do not need a good channel to review others I guess
CHECK OUT MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL! you know you want to.
http://www.youtube.c...g?feature=watch
Channel Type: Monogame Let's Plays
Footage Captured on: PC
Microphone Model: Plantronic Headset
Age: 13
Gender: Male
Upload Structure: Bi/Tri Weekly
Video Links: I reintroduce the series and survive my first night on Punchwood Island
Do you think your videos are innovate, original or informative?: Slightly? I just have fun!
Why do you make YouTube videos?: For fun. And maybe if I get a bank account, money...
Additional Information: (PC Specs, etc) AMD Sempron 145 Processor
NVIDIA GeForce 6150SE Graphics Card
500GB Hard Drive
2GB DDR3 Memory (2 gigs of ram)