Since she signed saying the design was up to his discretion, does the lawsuit really stand much chance of success?
Of course it does.
Rafe put this up...
I have reviewed the evidence, and find for the plaintiff in the amount of $100,000, plus the costs of tattoo removal. While Girlfriend did sign the consent form (and did allegedly cheat on Boyfriend), a tattoo of a pile of excrement was not within the range of "discretion" reasonably provided to the tattoo artist Boyfriend here. In the alternative, I find that Girlfriend was intoxicated and unable to provide consent under the circumstances.