I think both games have a lot in common, thats why we comparise them here, to discuss which game is better. Because it would be weird if we comarise Minecraft and a fps, because they are so unlike eachother. Honestly I don't think one can say that a game is better than another, because every game has its cons and pros. It isn't as easy as counting and compare. Therefore I think it isn't needed to ''find'' out which game is better (I am not referring to this thread), the best is to discuss in my opinion. Because when you discuss, it isn't one right answer about which game is better, only what you, mentally mean. So please don't say like ''OAUH MAII GAWWDZ, MINECRAFT IZZ ZOO MUCH BETTARZ THAN ROBLOXX)because it only makes the person that like the other game frustrated.
I think both games are good in it's own way :smile.gif:
This is like going into a democrat convention and asking people whether they are republican or democrat. It is almost pointless unless you are trying to convert people to Roblox... and if that is the case, a pox on you sir.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"If it already has been done then it can be done again" or
"If its a mod its possible to be a feature"
Well i used to be a roblox fan and i saw minecraft i tryed the free demo type version and i loved the first 20 to 40 minutes of playing and i compare roblox to minecraft and was amazed minecraft is alot better (IN MY OPINION) so all roblox fans give it up you know roblox is full of deleters that delete stuff and scam each other so look what if i bought OBC lifetime for 500$ (i diddent its a ripoff i know) and someone scams me oh my gosh i lost my hard earned money now tell me minecraft people whos better?
5. Except there's a million different ways you can customize a block on RBX, like adding textures, decals, materials, transparency, reflectance, and so on, and if you want, you can even toggle features like bevels. Minecraft? Oh, right, giant cubes with varying degrees of texture quality. In this respect, Roblox is miles beyond Minecraft.
The goal of Minecraft is to create an infinite world in which you can create and explore.
The goal of Roblox is to do the following: make a physics engine that can do anything that real life can(proof), Create a completely customizable environment (self evident if you have played it), Create a wonderful community (many community related updates)
The main difference in the communities is not how they came about but how they were treated.
In the beginning of both games they had a small dedicated group of fans
At first both games focused on improving the game and cared about people's opinions.
Then Roblox started mass advertising
When Roblox reached about 1 million players they decided to stop listening to the older more experienced minority (great place makers and dedicated forumers) and only listened to the majority.
When Minecraft reached 1 million players they continued to listen to the experienced minority (Modders and dedicated wiki maintainers and forumers)
Ultimately the destination of Minecraft was a strong community and Roblox a Large community(money). Smart people don't tolerate not being cared about for long.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The greatest creations are those that you make because you want to not because you have to.
Roblox has some potential attributes, but Minecraft I consider a better game. Why
1) Minecraft has a very really excellent Community compared to Roblox, in which Roblox's Community is very facilitate which makes very uneasy grammer from the people who play the game and brings in more 7-9 year old children with very harsh grammer and spelling.
2) Single Player, is one very inportant element to Minecraft because you do not need a internet connection to play the game, in which Roblox you need a internet connection to play the game.
3) Sightly more Freedom of Speech, In Roblox there is a very high chance you get banned if you talk about other games (Minecraft,TF2,etc).
You can do more on Roblox, but Minecraft is MUCH more fun because:
1. The Roblox community is TERRIBLE
2. You get banned for every little thing
3. Your judged for the ammount of money you have
4. Hackers are almost too common
Seriously, if this didn't happen, Roblox would be a great game.
minecraft wins because if you got premium, you can play offline and there is pocket edition, only in 2-3 years
roblox has ben here scince 2007(or 2008)and you always needed internet
minecraft, mods,texturepacks and skins are free and at roblox, they are Worth REAL money
sorry roblox and builderman, but notch is the higher person
i heard roblox has REAL videos instead of the stickman fight!!!!!!!!!
first round : player number : ROBLOX WIN second round : price to get skin : MINECRAFT WIN - 3round : creativity : ROBLOX WIN 4round : deleter and griefer % : minecraftian 20% is griefer and robloxian 70% is NOOB 5round : intelligence of player : roblox win(because so in roblox you make script and not use redstone system so ROBLOX WIN THIS ROUND) 6round : popularity : MINECRAFT WIN 7round : which one to choose : i dont know i think both good because if you not eneghout intelligent and want play with a low number of noob/grief play minecraft but if you think you have a suffisent intelligence and can make script and if you very creative join roblox !
ROBLOX, gameplay-wise, is better. It gives you a lot more freedom. But it's very community dependant, and the community is terrible, which makes the game terrible. Minecraft has been better than any game made on ROBLOX so far, so Minecraft is better than anything you might see on ROBLOX for now, but again, ROBLOX has much more room for creativity and it would be possible to make a better game that Minecraft within ROBLOX.
but i think roblox better.. yea they're no one that maked a game better than minecraft and also for peopel that say minecraft have better graphic me think roblox have better graphic because you can add decal on part that can be used for texture pack on roblox and also because you can script add decal change form of stuff to make better graphic if you have a certain intelligence level i think it's possible to create a game better than minecraft and look ! they're already game on roblox that look like minecraft for free !no bc need and these genre game in roblox that named *survival* or *hunger game* on roblox so and for me it's not because it's a survival that make it be better it can be any genre of game like CALL OF DUTY or anything like that and also before say minecraft better first : say it's you think that because for example if you say "roblox better minecraft suck" it will make minecraft player be sad and will more insult roblox or if you say "minecraft better roblox suck" it will make roblox player sad and they will more insult minecraft and also PLEASE people that like minecraft stop insult roblox just because you too much stupid to make script !
Honestly, I've grown to hate that place (roblox), and here's why
They don't allow you to express your opinion about them
So many games are so much better - all the people on that game are... EFFIN' 3 YEAR OLDS.
"z0mg god darnit n00b" <- I get tired of looking at this all day long.
All the games = crap. Good thing every 100 years but otherwise dis is what happens
"oh hey lawk a gun"
"OMFG U HAKKAH"
*steps on button*
On to the next thing....
Graphics. =. I don't want to even think about the word I was going to use in this spot.
The way it's scripted. =. I don't even want to think about the word I was going to use in this spot even more than the last one.
LAG. IS. **** ***** ****** ** ***** *** ********************* *****
There are copies of minecraft on roblox (hate hate hate)
Okay I'm done.
Wait, no I'm not.
I got banned for a day for saying "man, this community is CRAP." and after a day the button to become unbanned = Y U NO WORK?
me: **** YOU YOU BASTARDS. *ragequit and come here*
Finally, a community that is effin' decent.
Minecraft is better because:
No "FFFFFFFFUUUUU" (well except when you get effin' owned)
Err... How can I put this.... it has awesome modifications made by thousands of people and they are ALL DIFFERENT. Unlike roblox where if you want to do something different you have to remake the entire system.
Mods in minecraft are easy to install and you don't need to post polls to get them approved by Sir High King who Runs the Game Here to add them in for you. Unless you are on a server, which you must do the above however this branches off into my next topic.
A Single And Multi Player Experience! In Caps Cus RO-FAIL doesn't have Single Player. If You Want to Do what you Want you have to Search and Search and Search and Search for the Game with the Exact Specifications. Or You can Make your Own, but that requires Hours of Trial and Error and May Never Ever EVER even Work. This is technically an invalid reason because this is what Notch did, however he was experienced in the art of computers. Every average guy is not, which is a huge fail on roblox's part there.
This is why minecraft is better.
**edit: I know what I'm doing. I was dealing with this stuff on roblox for over a year and didn't know there was a better thing out there waitin' for me.
Sorry for making my post super long, but here is an english translation of that (^).
Short summary of it all: In ROBLOX kids rage, they have no idea what English class is since they are brainless six year olds, and the moderators are so greedy for cash they ban people for criticising them! They also have a shitty community. In Minecraft, the people are mature 13-(endless age) year olds with the exception of a couple mind-boggled 5 year olds - possibly 3 5 year olds for every 10 13 or ups. Minecraft also has a single player experience however in ROBLOX you must search and search for a game you like and if you can't find it spend weeks of learning to script something, and maybe, guessing, 7 in 10 average people can't comprehend scripting at all, which is a huge downside to ROBLOX. One of the only upsides I see is that you have easier freedom in ROBLOX.