Seems like a nice idea, but I don't think it is necessary. Your suggestion is also a bit vague. You also don't need to say "Just an idea..."; we know that it is an idea.
It is not what I "tthink" it is what the community "tthinks". Looks at other posts. Look at what Deonyi and 0_Zippy and the other posts say. What do you see? You see "No Support". I'm speaking the cold, hard truth. Not all suggestions are meant to be in the game. Also, you mentioned that it can be interpreted in any way. Ha! Look at actual items and dimensions that are in the real game. Do you think that this matches with everything else?
If it's not what you think than shut your mouth and don't say it plain and simple.
Wow how full of yourself are you! Opinion is not fact. You should've learned that a long time ago.
There is clearly some serious spergitary snobbery going on here. Your opinion is no greater than any others.
Simple bad wording. I meant. You can take minecraft however you want. How did you get here who cares. What time period. I don't care. It is whatever you make it and that's a magical thing that s like you ruin.
Also i think that Mojang could afford to get creative and go outside the box..
I support creative ideas that don't fit what we have seen so far more than another crowd pleaser suggestion.
If it's not what you think than shut your mouth and don't say it plain and simple.
Wow how full of yourself are you! Opinion is not fact. You should've learned that a long time ago.
There is clearly some serious spergitary snobbery going on here. Your opinion is no greater than any others.
Simple bad wording. I meant. You can take minecraft however you want. How did you get here who cares. What time period. I don't care. It is whatever you make it and that's a magical thing that s like you ruin.
Also i think that Mojang could afford to get creative and go outside the box..
I support creative ideas that don't fit what we have seen so far more than another crowd pleaser suggestion.
He has the right to speak and have an opinion, and I think that you should shut your mouth before people start to hate you even more than they already do.
He has the right to speak and have an opinion, and I think that you should shut your mouth before people start to hate you even more than they already do.
I never said he didn't What im saying is that if he is just repeating an opinion than i don't want to hear it.
I like how you have no other feedback other than maybe you should shut your mouth. Are you defending him because you share his opinion? If you find me to be too mean then i apologize. But i hate gaming snobbery. There is no excuse for it and it should be an infractionable offense. That's just my opinion. Also, i don't care if people hate me on this forum.
Just an idea that popped into my head. It's not too boring, is it?
I was held captive by your imagination, of course not lol.
But your idea needs to be much, much more expanded on... and I don't think Notch would implement something in where he's the villain lol. I also think people are going to envision this whole thing differently, for you haven't explained it well enough.
You need to bring more content if you're introducing an entirely new dimension! (this should be emphasized)
Also why is it called "Astral Plane" when there are many different layers of planes as you go up?
Shouldn't it be called Astral Planes (as in plural)...
I never said he didn't What im saying is that if he is just repeating an opinion than i don't want to hear it.
I like how you have no other feedback other than maybe you should shut your mouth. Are you defending him because you share his opinion? If you find me to be too mean then i apologize. But i hate gaming snobbery. There is no excuse for it and it should be an infractionable offense. That's just my opinion. Also, i don't care if people hate me on this forum.
I'm just saying that there is no need to be so rude. He is just expressing an opinion. I have seen you argue with the exact same user in other threads, and I don't understand why you should have any reason to hate him (or her). He has the right to express an opinion.
Also, you stated that you don't want to hear his opinion if he is just repeating it, but other people use these forums too and they want to hear his opinion. You also said that "nobody cares", when it is more like "I don't care". Other people use these forums and you cannot speak for everyone, or act like the forums revolve around you. There are other people on the forums that do care.
What I also find funny is that he didn't repeat any opinions and it is a fact that Minecraft is not an RPG game. I think that you need to think before you speak.
It is not that I am defending him, it is that I am going against you and arguing about the situation that you have brought up, because I do not believe that it is right!
I never said he didn't What im saying is that if he is just repeating an opinion than i don't want to hear it.
I like how you have no other feedback other than maybe you should shut your mouth. Are you defending him because you share his opinion? If you find me to be too mean then i apologize. But i hate gaming snobbery. There is no excuse for it and it should be an infractionable offense. That's just my opinion. Also, i don't care if people hate me on this forum.
He is giving criticism, and you don't like it because someone said it before? (Which they didn't) If not, you have no reason to be so... Argumentative.
Also you say that minecraft could be an RPG. It's a survival sandbox.
I never said he didn't What im saying is that if he is just repeating an opinion than i don't want to hear it.
I like how you have no other feedback other than maybe you should shut your mouth. Are you defending him because you share his opinion? If you find me to be too mean then i apologize. But i hate gaming snobbery. There is no excuse for it and it should be an infractionable offense. That's just my opinion. Also, i don't care if people hate me on this forum.
"Gaming Snobbery"? I was simply stating the cold hard truth. The majority (almost 100%) said that this idea needed to be improved. If you don't like listening to opinions then, well, go to a different forum ( I prefer Off-Topic), because you are going to get a lot of them here on the "Discussion" one. Also you previously stated many times "Why did I come back?". If you don't like it here on MCF, then the simple solution would be you to leave.
I'm just saying that there is no need to be so rude. He is just expressing an opinion. I have seen you argue with the exact same user in other threads, and I don't understand why you should have any reason to hate him (or her). He has the right to express an opinion. Also, you stated that you don't want to hear his opinion if he is just repeating it, but other people use these forums too and they want to hear his opinion. You also said that "nobody cares", when it is more like "I don't care". Other people use these forums and you cannot speak for everyone, or act like the forums revolve around you. There are other people on the forums that do care. What I also find funny is that he didn't repeat any opinions and it is a fact that Minecraft is not an RPG game. I think that you need to think before you speak. It is not that I am defending him, it is that I am going against you and arguing about the situation that you have brought up, because I do not believe that it is right!
So i think there is some confusion as to what's being said.
1. The reason i dismissed his opinion is because he said it in two ways.
The way he worded it sounded like "other people like this opinion and i do too.
Also he sounded REALLY snobby about his opinion being fact the "cold hard truth"
2. I made one other response. And also i would respond to anybody if their comment sounded snobbish or whatever. I like how you try playing the E-Detective but if you looked farther back, i've been doing this for a full year now. This is nothing new.
3. You have something with the nobody cares thing, my bad.
4.I can link minecraft to The Legend Of Zelda and Pokemon, Potions.
Again we go with the snobbery. Minecraft can have as many RPG elements as the creators want. You have absolutely no say in the dev process, RPG or not.
5. This one i wanted to save for last.
So immediately fall back on the defense of I wish you wern't so rude.
If you had said that about 2 posts ealier we wouldn't be doing this right now.
That obviously wasn't your main problem because if it was you would've should've COULD'VE said that erlier.
As for why im rude sometimes.... I honestly only have one answer and that's because i hate the Minecraft fanbase.
It's not a good excuse i know but that's what im stickin' to. All the whining, the snobbery as well as other things just make me a mean rude person.
Im normally pretty nice but i have a fuse that is unfortunately short when it comes to these forums.
He is giving criticism, and you don't like it because someone said it before? (Which they didn't) If not, you have no reason to be so... Argumentative. Also you say that minecraft could be an RPG. It's a survival sandbox.
A survival sandbox can have RPG elements if the devs desire. Shall i hand you your crown?
"Gaming Snobbery"? I was simply stating the cold hard truth. The majority (almost 100%) said that this idea needed to be improved. If you don't like listening to opinions then, well, go to a different forum ( I prefer Off-Topic), because you are going to get a lot of them here on the "Discussion" one. Also you previously stated many times "Why did I come back?". If you don't like it here on MCF, then the simple solution would be you to leave.
I made sure i didn't misunderstand your first post and this is what im talking about. Have a look.So you fight every developer of Minecraft eh? That means you have to fight 42 bosses. And you have to fight an "evil and giant corrupted version of Notch"? Now that's just fantasy. Minecraft was never meant to be an RPG feel. No Support. Do you see how snobbish you sound! You just come off like that.I can listen to opinions but i don't like it when people are close minded.So I should leave because i don't like the fanbase, instead of trying to show how this fandom can sound snobbish or whiny. That comment was what i was responding to.
Shut up nobody cares. Why do you get to decide what the game is supposed to be! It can be interpreted in any way. Think before speaking PLEASE! (Just think of the way you sound when you declare what you tthink a game is supposed to be.)
Actually if you do a little bit of research you would find a couple.
Im not gonna lie. This thread needs improvement. It's a bit vegue but with a little clearer explanation it could become a great suggestion.
Also the fighting the devs thing reminds me of The Binding Of Isaac.
What happens if you fall down a pit that looks bottemless
Specifics on bosses please
Any new blocks
Any new mobs
Overall support but you have a lot of things to clarify.
Please endulge me a moment as i try to piece together this post. So you don't want this new dimension because there are already plains in minecra- im so confused. That's not what he's talking about. And this part is most baffling. I just don't understand what that relates to or how that realtes to this.
(JUstin you should'a left and never came back.)
Hah! Look at your other posts! See something in common? "Shut up nobody cares." and "Point invalid, see the horse. Also who are you to decide! It'd be best if you stop talking now." I simply giving constructive criticism, while you on the other hand was being a plain jerk to other's opinions... Just because someone has different opinions from yours, doesn't mean that you can treat them with hostility.
No support!
If it's not what you think than shut your mouth and don't say it plain and simple.
Wow how full of yourself are you! Opinion is not fact. You should've learned that a long time ago.
There is clearly some serious spergitary snobbery going on here. Your opinion is no greater than any others.
Simple bad wording. I meant. You can take minecraft however you want. How did you get here who cares. What time period. I don't care. It is whatever you make it and that's a magical thing that s like you ruin.
Also i think that Mojang could afford to get creative and go outside the box..
I support creative ideas that don't fit what we have seen so far more than another crowd pleaser suggestion.
Just build the darn thing already!
He has the right to speak and have an opinion, and I think that you should shut your mouth before people start to hate you even more than they already do.
I never said he didn't What im saying is that if he is just repeating an opinion than i don't want to hear it.
I like how you have no other feedback other than maybe you should shut your mouth. Are you defending him because you share his opinion? If you find me to be too mean then i apologize. But i hate gaming snobbery. There is no excuse for it and it should be an infractionable offense. That's just my opinion. Also, i don't care if people hate me on this forum.
Just build the darn thing already!
I was held captive by your imagination, of course not lol.
But your idea needs to be much, much more expanded on... and I don't think Notch would implement something in where he's the villain lol. I also think people are going to envision this whole thing differently, for you haven't explained it well enough.
You need to bring more content if you're introducing an entirely new dimension! (this should be emphasized)
Also why is it called "Astral Plane" when there are many different layers of planes as you go up?
Shouldn't it be called Astral Planes (as in plural)...
BA
I'm just saying that there is no need to be so rude. He is just expressing an opinion. I have seen you argue with the exact same user in other threads, and I don't understand why you should have any reason to hate him (or her). He has the right to express an opinion.
Also, you stated that you don't want to hear his opinion if he is just repeating it, but other people use these forums too and they want to hear his opinion. You also said that "nobody cares", when it is more like "I don't care". Other people use these forums and you cannot speak for everyone, or act like the forums revolve around you. There are other people on the forums that do care.
What I also find funny is that he didn't repeat any opinions and it is a fact that Minecraft is not an RPG game. I think that you need to think before you speak.
It is not that I am defending him, it is that I am going against you and arguing about the situation that you have brought up, because I do not believe that it is right!
He is giving criticism, and you don't like it because someone said it before? (Which they didn't) If not, you have no reason to be so... Argumentative.
Also you say that minecraft could be an RPG. It's a survival sandbox.
I have a new account called "Mushroomsock" now, so please do not send me PMs.
"Gaming Snobbery"? I was simply stating the cold hard truth. The majority (almost 100%) said that this idea needed to be improved. If you don't like listening to opinions then, well, go to a different forum ( I prefer Off-Topic), because you are going to get a lot of them here on the "Discussion" one. Also you previously stated many times "Why did I come back?". If you don't like it here on MCF, then the simple solution would be you to leave.
So i think there is some confusion as to what's being said.
1. The reason i dismissed his opinion is because he said it in two ways.
The way he worded it sounded like "other people like this opinion and i do too.
Also he sounded REALLY snobby about his opinion being fact the "cold hard truth"
2. I made one other response. And also i would respond to anybody if their comment sounded snobbish or whatever. I like how you try playing the E-Detective but if you looked farther back, i've been doing this for a full year now. This is nothing new.
3. You have something with the nobody cares thing, my bad.
4.I can link minecraft to The Legend Of Zelda and Pokemon, Potions.
Again we go with the snobbery. Minecraft can have as many RPG elements as the creators want. You have absolutely no say in the dev process, RPG or not.
5. This one i wanted to save for last.
So immediately fall back on the defense of I wish you wern't so rude.
If you had said that about 2 posts ealier we wouldn't be doing this right now.
That obviously wasn't your main problem because if it was you would've should've COULD'VE said that erlier.
As for why im rude sometimes.... I honestly only have one answer and that's because i hate the Minecraft fanbase.
It's not a good excuse i know but that's what im stickin' to. All the whining, the snobbery as well as other things just make me a mean rude person.
Im normally pretty nice but i have a fuse that is unfortunately short when it comes to these forums.
A survival sandbox can have RPG elements if the devs desire. Shall i hand you your crown?
Just build the darn thing already!
If you think that minecraft might be an RPG, then why is it not yet, when it is fully released?
I have a new account called "Mushroomsock" now, so please do not send me PMs.
Something Jeb said Minecraft will not have any more of. He even concluded it with "stop asking!"
And you don't speak for the devs
Its their decision
So stop shooting down ideas
What's there to discuss about this lack-luster topic?
Just build the darn thing already!
Hah! Look at your other posts! See something in common? "Shut up nobody cares." and "Point invalid, see the horse. Also who are you to decide! It'd be best if you stop talking now." I simply giving constructive criticism, while you on the other hand was being a plain jerk to other's opinions... Just because someone has different opinions from yours, doesn't mean that you can treat them with hostility.
Jeez
There's more arguing than suggestions here
Exactly why I stopped.
Would rate this suggestion up again.
Just build the darn thing already!