I like regular fish. It's like saying we should take out chicken because we have pork chops and steak.
No, it isn't. Pork chops and steak aren't types of chicken. Salmon, clownfish, and pufferfish, however, are types of fish.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! This is The_Signature477. Above is The_Post477. Below is The_NextPost477. Further above is The_PreviousPost477. You are The_ViewerOfThe_UsernamesSignature477. Such is the life of The_Username477.
Please stop with the histrionics, everyone. This is not becoming a war, but just a bunch of people whining about how it's becoming a war. Also, the suggestion's impact on the suggestion forums is ultimately less important than the suggestion's impact on the game.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! This is The_Signature477. Above is The_Post477. Below is The_NextPost477. Further above is The_PreviousPost477. You are The_ViewerOfThe_UsernamesSignature477. Such is the life of The_Username477.
We are not just talking about the forums, were talking about the entire Minecraft community, a lot of people play Minecraft, even though only like 1/10th of all people who have a Minecraft account also go on this forum, its still a large amount and people are going to be complain, which might even cause people to quit
(I can't for the life of me find a way to quote that post)
*sobs loudly*, PLEASE!!!, do the world a favour, no "Minecraft War 5", i wasn't around for the Battle Of Gravel, or the Pig Snout Stampede, or the Cobble Calamity, but i saw the War Of The Roses, and it wasn't pretty.
Please stop with the histrionics, everyone. This is not becoming a war, but just a bunch of people whining about how it's becoming a war. Also, the suggestion's impact on the suggestion forums is ultimately less important than the suggestion's impact on the game.
It's not a war YET. That is due to the simple fact that regular fish hasn't been removed. Trust me on this, Nostaligicrafters aren't open to change, or at least no changes to minuscule "wouldn't really matter if they did" changes and those of us who really don't care will get dragged down with the weight of topics like "Bring Back the Fish!!!1!1!!" and "Minecraft forgot their roots!!"
As for you saying they're awkward, I have to disagree respectfully. I sure as Nether don't feel disappointed when I catch a regular fish in Survival; it still heals a decent amount of hunger and serves its purpose well when no other food source is around (happens all too often for me). If any of the fish is awkward, it's the Clownfish. Only 1/2-1 hunger healed and serves no other purpose, so it always takes up my inventory.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
SDM and Squid Army fanboys/girls. You're as ridiculous as each other. Gold=Butter=Gold. Why do you harp on about something as trivial as what people call it?
We should keep it in, sure we have a few specific fish, but the plain fish item is there to represent all the other types of fish that don't have specific items. So instead of making an item for every fish item in existence, we have a few specific fish types and then one to represent every single last other fish. You act as if they must remove this item and add every fish species to the game as an individual item, that would be stupid and be pointlessly tedious to code when we can just keep the generic fish.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The problem with the truth, is that it never lies.
We are not just talking about the forums, were talking about the entire Minecraft community, a lot of people play Minecraft, even though only like 1/10th of all people who have a Minecraft account also go on this forum, its still a large amount and people are going to be complain, which might even cause people to quit
(I can't for the life of me find a way to quote that post)
I really don't believe that a small change like that can force significant numbers of people to quit. Even people saying "#RoseRedArmy" are still playing Minecraft. Also, you don't need to quote me. I can tell by context.
We should keep it in, sure we have a few specific fish, but the plain fish item is there to represent all the other types of fish that don't have specific items. So instead of making an item for every fish item in existence, we have a few specific fish types and then one to represent every single last other fish. You act as if they must remove this item and add every fish species to the game as an individual item, that would be stupid and be pointlessly tedious to code when we can just keep the generic fish.
That logic is flawed. If I really wanted to have every variety of fish, I would suggest every variety of fish. I only want a few varieties, but having something generic to represent the other varieties doesn't make sense.
I think it's a little pedantic to demand something be done about it. And more than a little pedantic to demand it be removed altogether. Old things from Minecraft should not be removed. It would be like removing pigs. Renaming it is a sensible compromise in my opinion.
People have not fished extensively before the overhaul in the snapshots, and the plain fish is not considered a symbol of Minecraft in any sense. So I would not consider it a great loss.
Hello! This is The_Signature477. Above is The_Post477. Below is The_NextPost477. Further above is The_PreviousPost477. You are The_ViewerOfThe_UsernamesSignature477. Such is the life of The_Username477.
Plain fish still reminds us of older versions (not sure if that's good or bad) but as a few people have said, it should just be renamed.
It isn't good or bad that it reminds us of older versions. Remember, I still think renaming is a viable option. I just would prefer removal and/or replacement for similar reasons to the replacement of the poppy.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! This is The_Signature477. Above is The_Post477. Below is The_NextPost477. Further above is The_PreviousPost477. You are The_ViewerOfThe_UsernamesSignature477. Such is the life of The_Username477.
That logic is flawed. If I really wanted to have every variety of fish, I would suggest every variety of fish. I only want a few varieties, but having something generic to represent the other varieties doesn't make sense.
While I know that my post was flawed, if you are going to try and point out my flawed logic, do not make your counter-argument a subjective opinion. Arguing with opinions is the epitome of flawed logic.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The problem with the truth, is that it never lies.
While I know that my post was flawed, if you are going to try and point out my flawed logic, do not make your counter-argument a subjective opinion. Arguing with opinions is the epitome of flawed logic.
Well played. But like I said before, I do not want all varieties of everything to be represented, whether by an umbrella item or all together.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! This is The_Signature477. Above is The_Post477. Below is The_NextPost477. Further above is The_PreviousPost477. You are The_ViewerOfThe_UsernamesSignature477. Such is the life of The_Username477.
Do we really need to remove more items from Minecraft?
No support.
We haven't even removed that many.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hello! This is The_Signature477. Above is The_Post477. Below is The_NextPost477. Further above is The_PreviousPost477. You are The_ViewerOfThe_UsernamesSignature477. Such is the life of The_Username477.
No, it isn't. Pork chops and steak aren't types of chicken. Salmon, clownfish, and pufferfish, however, are types of fish.
It seems like the only argument you are not listening to is mine, the one a lot of pepole seem to be agreeing with
Click them or they will click you
I agree with this, no support.
We are not just talking about the forums, were talking about the entire Minecraft community, a lot of people play Minecraft, even though only like 1/10th of all people who have a Minecraft account also go on this forum, its still a large amount and people are going to be complain, which might even cause people to quit
(I can't for the life of me find a way to quote that post)
Click them or they will click you
It's not a war YET. That is due to the simple fact that regular fish hasn't been removed. Trust me on this, Nostaligicrafters aren't open to change, or at least no changes to minuscule "wouldn't really matter if they did" changes and those of us who really don't care will get dragged down with the weight of topics like "Bring Back the Fish!!!1!1!!" and "Minecraft forgot their roots!!"
If it were changed, even a simple name and retexturing, we would see tonnes of those topics pop up. The big thing at the moment is the Rosé v Poppy thing, a couple of months ago it was Pigs v Horses v Minecarts. Point is if you remove the regular fish because you think it serves no purpose...well...these forums have enough Nostalgicrafters to kick up an almighty rukkus on these forums.
As for you saying they're awkward, I have to disagree respectfully. I sure as Nether don't feel disappointed when I catch a regular fish in Survival; it still heals a decent amount of hunger and serves its purpose well when no other food source is around (happens all too often for me). If any of the fish is awkward, it's the Clownfish. Only 1/2-1 hunger healed and serves no other purpose, so it always takes up my inventory.
SDM and Squid Army fanboys/girls. You're as ridiculous as each other. Gold=Butter=Gold. Why do you harp on about something as trivial as what people call it?
I really don't believe that a small change like that can force significant numbers of people to quit. Even people saying "#RoseRedArmy" are still playing Minecraft. Also, you don't need to quote me. I can tell by context.
That logic is flawed. If I really wanted to have every variety of fish, I would suggest every variety of fish. I only want a few varieties, but having something generic to represent the other varieties doesn't make sense.
People have not fished extensively before the overhaul in the snapshots, and the plain fish is not considered a symbol of Minecraft in any sense. So I would not consider it a great loss.
It isn't good or bad that it reminds us of older versions. Remember, I still think renaming is a viable option. I just would prefer removal and/or replacement for similar reasons to the replacement of the poppy.
While I know that my post was flawed, if you are going to try and point out my flawed logic, do not make your counter-argument a subjective opinion. Arguing with opinions is the epitome of flawed logic.
Well played. But like I said before, I do not want all varieties of everything to be represented, whether by an umbrella item or all together.
No support.
Also, here is an awesome suggestion I had: http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1745550-biome-effects/
We haven't even removed that many.
That's what I said!
"And so I go fast. Not because I want to, because no one else will."
-Sanic Hegehog
Bass are pretty common all-around.