If you're getting aggravated, it's your own fault. I never intended for this thread to get so many comments.
The reason it's getting so many comments is because you are instigating everyone by quoting them and presenting terrible arguments. I'm fine with defending your opinion, but when you have 5 pages of nothing but negative comments, you know something is wrong.
The reason it's getting so many comments is because you are instigating everyone by quoting them and presenting terrible arguments. I'm fine with defending your opinion, but when you have 5 pages of nothing but negative comments, you know something is wrong.
Woah, woah, I think we need to all calm down! The idea could be more thought out (Craftable instead of ore), but otherwise there's no reason to attack this guy! If you don't like the idea, don't +1 his post.
It's Bedrock with a bad name. I'm think we can go Rampage Jackson on this thread.
I couldn't keep a straight face when I saw the amount of posts in this thread and you only got one upvote.
It's a little sad really, I've seen you make posts where come up with the best arguments closers with honeyed words, so I know for a fact you can think up better stuff than "an unmineable ore that only pistons can move but you can build a house with it! this is idea is so good! i win!!" Even some of your previous threads I've supported because even though they were ridiculous they'd still be awesome and balanced.
And this has gotta get old eventually, because the same thing keeps happening: Spaceboot1, "here's my idea!" someone, "no it's bad because <reasoning>" Spaceboot1, "no it's good because <reasoning deeper than the idea itself>" someone, "no it's still bad because <better reasoning than before>" Spaceboot1, "no my idea is perfect because <more deep reasoning but with insult provoking comparisons>"
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
So i dont know too much about programming, but even i know its not technically possible in any way shape or form. And dont say "im playin on a flat map herpaderp im so kewl an so smart"
I couldn't keep a straight face when I saw the amount of posts in this thread and you only got one upvote.
It's a little sad really, I've seen you make posts where come up with the best arguments closers with honeyed words, so I know for a fact you can think up better stuff than "an unmineable ore that only pistons can move but you can build a house with it! this is idea is so good! i win!!" Even some of your previous threads I've supported because even though they were ridiculous they'd still be awesome and balanced.
And this has gotta get old eventually, because the same thing keeps happening: Spaceboot1, "here's my idea!" someone, "no it's bad because <reasoning>" Spaceboot1, "no it's good because <reasoning deeper than the idea itself>" someone, "no it's still bad because <better reasoning than before>" Spaceboot1, "no my idea is perfect because <more deep reasoning but with insult provoking comparisons>"
So because you aren't countering my arguement with your ridicoulously trolly ideas, does that mean i'm correct? You cant come up with something like "nuhhh, helicopters have been suggested before! i'm just going to ignore the part about clouds and saplings AND THE ACTUAL FLIPPEN POINT OF HER FLIPPEN ARGUEMENT.
Don't think im biased because of all your other ideas, no no no.
i'm acting this way because if this was anyone else, they'd say "okay, no one likes this, ill just forget about it."
But you fail to realize that people are starting to think your trolling and that this idea is HORRIBLE. Don't act egotistical and stubborn, accept that it doesnt matter how good this idea is if the majority's opinion says this is bad. Whether it's good or not is a matter of the majority of the consumers opinions and mojangs ideas.
- "building in mountains is hard!"
- "lets add bedrock ore only movable by pistons, with no use at all, because its just a minor inconvenience!"
- "if you disagree, you dont understand and are stupid!"
l2build, l2troll, l2think
This is the guy who thinks helicopters made of clouds spitting magic saplings is a commonly suggested idea. This is the guy who wants to make going afk more dangerous. This is the guy who wants to have bedrock spawn above level 5.
Whaddya expect? He's got enough time to push an ore approximately 300 blocks back to his base but he hast got enough time to flatten out a mountain with about five blocks of tnt.
Amazing how this is still dragging off on the front page... let me have a compilation of the reasons why people think this is a terrible suggestion.
1. Not minecraft-y, not minecraft-y at all. Starting from the name called "pistonium".
2. Nobody loves pistoning up an unbreakable block for few hundred blocks.
3. Griefers may, and WILL use it. You mentioned that "griefers are never at your top list while you're thinking of cool blocks", but griefing is going to happen. When making suggestions like these you have to consider every single factor(and I mean EVERY.SINGLE.FACTOR.). When I made my suggestion thread, I even ran a simulation in the game to see how my suggestion would be like in the game, then edit my thread if it's too OP.
4. You're not listening. You are not trying to fix this thread even after all the majority of people who is disliking this. You have to listen to opinions and decide which one is a good piece of feedback.
I'm just trying to convince you to make things right, but you're probably still going to argue with it.
Amazing how this is still dragging off on the front page... let me have a compilation of the reasons why people think this is a terrible suggestion.
1. Not minecraft-y, not minecraft-y at all. Starting from the name called "pistonium".
2. Nobody loves pistoning up an unbreakable block for few hundred blocks.
3. Griefers may, and WILL use it. You mentioned that "griefers are never at your top list while you're thinking of cool blocks", but griefing is going to happen. When making suggestions like these you have to consider every single factor(and I mean EVERY.SINGLE.FACTOR.). When I made my suggestion thread, I even ran a simulation in the game to see how my suggestion would be like in the game, then edit my thread if it's too OP.
4. You're not listening. You are not trying to fix this thread even after all the majority of people who is disliking this. You have to listen to opinions and decide which one is a good piece of feedback.
I'm just trying to convince you to make things right, but you're probably still going to argue with it.
Everything you said I agree with,
NoobGalaxies. Upvote for you.
Ugh, no thanks. It wouldn't be a productive method of defending one's home when obsidian provides as much blast durability as you'd need and is literally 3000 times easier to mine (by blast resistance alone).
This suggestion has large amounts of disapprovium abounding within.
Better suggestion: take a day off, stop making suggestions, and stop whining when they're not approved by a large number of posters. Take some time, browse the forums and see what works and what doesn't, this'll take about a week. After that week, come back with a more refined idea of what to post and how to post. Until then, expect every thread (including your good ones) to be lambasted and lampooned.
*But they're all haters* - Nope. This isn't a case of vocal minority, you've overall gotten a reputation for awful ideas.
*You have a bad reputation too, yoshi!* - The difference is my bad reputation is because I'm an uncompromising jerk, not because I have uncompromisingly bad ideas.
I've seen maybe two that I liked, and a handful I didn't care for while the vast majority are horrid.
I am not strongly opposed as most people here are. I think it has the potential to be a very fun addition, but not in the current state. I dont mean add less, I mean add more. Maybe zombies can break through it, and when they do, it drops as a resource which can be used for one thing or another (New redstone device(s), quick travel/teleport gates, etc.) Then it would be worth it to move the blocks somewhere to harvest it via zombie.
EDIT: I claim this page in the name of Sentient Eyeballs!
Also, I am a bit disappointed in how some of the opponents of this suggestion are behaving here. I am not saying the OP's idea is perfect, And i most definitely see how this block may not be a good idea in the current state, but it is certainly not so atrocious that you have to mock and ostracize him or the suggestion itself.
Also, I am a bit disappointed in how some of the opponents of this suggestion are behaving here. I am not saying the OP's idea is perfect, And i most definitely see how this block may not be a good idea in the current state, but it is certainly not so atrocious that you have to mock and ostracize him or the suggestion itself.
Things kind of get out of hand with him. He has a history of poorly accepting criticism and this causes him to be the brunt of attacks. Basically, he's built a notoriety that carries with him. While he could do a lot of things to curb this, it's also the fault of those that would simply attack him and knee-jerk on the suggestion because of who posted it. To this effect, the merits of the suggestion are not sufficient alone. You're doing wonders by providing more credibility to the suggestion, but I fear that his opponents will disregard such help and lampoon him some more.
It's always fun to be the bully until you're the one being bullied :P. Note to the audience: If you're not going to be everyone's friend, don't leave any openings.
The reason it's getting so many comments is because you are instigating everyone by quoting them and presenting terrible arguments. I'm fine with defending your opinion, but when you have 5 pages of nothing but negative comments, you know something is wrong.
Most of Space_Boot1's posts cause flame wars...
"Wake me, when you need me."
The default block will be spongechiseled / circle stone brickEDIT: Finished!
I feel quite pleased with myself.
http://dev.bukkit.org/bukkit-plugins/dense-chiseled-stone/
No support.
It's Bedrock with a bad name. I'm think we can go Rampage Jackson on this thread.
It's a little sad really, I've seen you make posts where come up with the best arguments closers with honeyed words, so I know for a fact you can think up better stuff than "an unmineable ore that only pistons can move but you can build a house with it! this is idea is so good! i win!!" Even some of your previous threads I've supported because even though they were ridiculous they'd still be awesome and balanced.
And this has gotta get old eventually, because the same thing keeps happening:
Spaceboot1, "here's my idea!"
someone, "no it's bad because <reasoning>"
Spaceboot1, "no it's good because <reasoning deeper than the idea itself>"
someone, "no it's still bad because <better reasoning than before>"
Spaceboot1, "no my idea is perfect because <more deep reasoning but with insult provoking comparisons>"
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
So i dont know too much about programming, but even i know its not technically possible in any way shape or form. And dont say "im playin on a flat map herpaderp im so kewl an so smart"
Don't think im biased because of all your other ideas, no no no.
i'm acting this way because if this was anyone else, they'd say "okay, no one likes this, ill just forget about it."
But you fail to realize that people are starting to think your trolling and that this idea is HORRIBLE. Don't act egotistical and stubborn, accept that it doesnt matter how good this idea is if the majority's opinion says this is bad. Whether it's good or not is a matter of the majority of the consumers opinions and mojangs ideas.
This is the guy who thinks helicopters made of clouds spitting magic saplings is a commonly suggested idea. This is the guy who wants to make going afk more dangerous. This is the guy who wants to have bedrock spawn above level 5.
Whaddya expect? He's got enough time to push an ore approximately 300 blocks back to his base but he hast got enough time to flatten out a mountain with about five blocks of tnt.
1. Not minecraft-y, not minecraft-y at all. Starting from the name called "pistonium".
2. Nobody loves pistoning up an unbreakable block for few hundred blocks.
3. Griefers may, and WILL use it. You mentioned that "griefers are never at your top list while you're thinking of cool blocks", but griefing is going to happen. When making suggestions like these you have to consider every single factor(and I mean EVERY.SINGLE.FACTOR.). When I made my suggestion thread, I even ran a simulation in the game to see how my suggestion would be like in the game, then edit my thread if it's too OP.
4. You're not listening. You are not trying to fix this thread even after all the majority of people who is disliking this. You have to listen to opinions and decide which one is a good piece of feedback.
I'm just trying to convince you to make things right, but you're probably still going to argue with it.
Everything you said I agree with,
NoobGalaxies. Upvote for you.
"Wake me, when you need me."
This suggestion has large amounts of disapprovium abounding within.
Better suggestion: take a day off, stop making suggestions, and stop whining when they're not approved by a large number of posters. Take some time, browse the forums and see what works and what doesn't, this'll take about a week. After that week, come back with a more refined idea of what to post and how to post. Until then, expect every thread (including your good ones) to be lambasted and lampooned.
*But they're all haters* - Nope. This isn't a case of vocal minority, you've overall gotten a reputation for awful ideas.
*You have a bad reputation too, yoshi!* - The difference is my bad reputation is because I'm an uncompromising jerk, not because I have uncompromisingly bad ideas.
I've seen maybe two that I liked, and a handful I didn't care for while the vast majority are horrid.
OFFICIAL POSTING/REPLYING GUIDELINES
UNOFFICIAL POSTING GUIDE (PRT)
UNOFFICIAL REPLYING GUIDE (FTC)
The texture doesn't blend well with stone, either. Maybe a bit entertaining on SMP, but that's about it.
EDIT: I claim this page in the name of Sentient Eyeballs!
I play Slave Hack, give it a try!
"Wake me, when you need me."
OFFICIAL POSTING/REPLYING GUIDELINES
UNOFFICIAL POSTING GUIDE (PRT)
UNOFFICIAL REPLYING GUIDE (FTC)
:L
Ok.
"Wake me, when you need me."
I play Slave Hack, give it a try!
It's always fun to be the bully until you're the one being bullied :P. Note to the audience: If you're not going to be everyone's friend, don't leave any openings.
OFFICIAL POSTING/REPLYING GUIDELINES
UNOFFICIAL POSTING GUIDE (PRT)
UNOFFICIAL REPLYING GUIDE (FTC)