this topic is about few random enchantments i made..give your opinion:
1-Storm [for sword]
the enchantment gives a chance to create a bolt of lightning that damages mobs upon hitting with the sword, its like a line that appears between the hit mob and the nearest mob and damages nearest mob, then disappears and appears again between the second mob and another one, and keeps jumping like that from a mob to another until its out of jumps, if it shocked all mobs around and still have jumps it returns to shock already shocked ones, which means if the shock appeared while there are only 2 mobs it will go and return to do heavy damage.
levels
I : 1 heart per shock (or per jump) , jumps 3 times
II : 1,5 heart per shock , jumps 5 times
III : 2 heart per shock , jumps 6 times
2-Blaze [for chestplate]
damages all mobs around by 0.5 heart per 2 secs, mob damage animation is not applied and particles appear at nearest mobs which are being damaged, has only one level
3-cleaver [for sword]
with every hit nearest mobs are damaged with hit mob at front of you, other mobs are damaged less than main mob
levels:
I : 40% damage for other mobs
II : 60% damage for other mobs
III : 80% damage for other mobs
4-speed [for boots]
increases wearers speed slightly, less than potion speed but lasts as long as the boot is equip
levels:
I : bonus speed 10%
II : bonus speed 20%
III : bonus speed 30%
5-Durability [for chestplate]
increases max health (WoW)
levels:
I : 2 hearts
II : 3 hearts
III : 5 hearts
6-elemental [for sword and bow]
this enchantment works only if adding potions to weapons feature is added, which will allow to craft a sword with a potion to make next hit has the potion effect, this enchantment gives more "potion-effect" hits with only 1 potion ( as i said that adding a potion gives only 1 hit with potion effect ), this enchantment will be only available at enchanted books in dungeons.
levels:
I : 1 extra use
II : 3 extra uses
7-frost [for sword and bow]
hitting with this slows target and gives it blue color for 3 secs, getting burnt removes this buff, also this enchantment deals bonus damage for endermen and blazes (like bane of athropodus for spiders)
levels :
I : slow 15%
II : slow 30%
III : slow 40%
Storm is oversuggested with the whole lightning thing. Blaze is pretty overpowered, as you could intentionally let a mob damage you so you could damage other mobs all around you (including passive ones you don't want to hurt). Cleaver is the same as the blaze one. The speed one can be mixed with a speed potion to make you move way too fast. Durability feature is being given to enchanted golden apples, so having it longer on armor is a bit too much. Elemental sounds good, but only in adventure maps. Frost turns the enemy into an easier target and ruins it for slowness potions.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
Storm is oversuggested with the whole lightning thing. Blaze is pretty overpowered, as you could intentionally let a mob damage you so you could damage other mobs all around you (including passive ones you don't want to hurt). Cleaver is the same as the blaze one. The speed one can be mixed with a speed potion to make you move way too fast. Durability feature is being given to enchanted golden apples, so having it longer on armor is a bit too much. Elemental sounds good, but only in adventure maps. Frost turns the enemy into an easier target and ruins it for slowness potions.
u gived a good answer, storm isn't over suggested ( i guess as i had more than one year at the community and no one suggested it)
blaze, maybe u are right , but if we made it about getting hit it will be just like thorns but with area damage?! that can be only if we added a new level of thorns that does area damage too..
speed gives this percent of normal speed..bonus speed from potions will not be also increase..also potions are fast enough to say they are over powered so adding also bonus speed won't make them over powered..also if u still say its over powered by adding potion speed to this enchantment then we can make drinking speed potion removes this small bonus speed
about durability i didn't hear about its given to golden apples
u gived a good answer, storm isn't over suggested There's been hundreds of times where someone suggested a weapon that can summon lightning.
blaze, maybe u are right , but if we made it about getting hit it will be just like thorns but with area damage?! that can be only if we added a new level of thorns that does area damage too.. That wouldn't change anything. You still have an overpowered area damage enchantment.
speed gives this percent of normal speed..bonus speed from potions will not be also increase..also potions are fast enough to say they are over powered so adding also bonus speed won't make them over powered.. It doesn't work that way. There's no need to spend the energy in coding a speed enchantment when we have two different kinds of speed potions that get the job done.
also if u still say its over powered by adding potion speed to this enchantment then we can make drinking speed potion removes this small bonus speed Well, it's balanced, but again, we already have the potions.
about durability i didn't hear about its given to golden apples Nor did I. Apparently you get an extra 4 hitpoints.
1-dont talk about the animation and model..what if i said it summons fire but with the same mechanic? also whats the problem if i repeated a suggestion..i just made a list of enchantments and i liked this enchantment to be a part of it
2-u may be right if u say blaze is overpowered but making last level of thorns do area damage is not over powered for 2 reasons, one is that u should be damaged to damage, two it doesn't do massive damage
3-speed potions doesn't do same job, and you are not who will waste his time for that..there are people taking money for that
4-k just forget durability or maybe we do it like speed potions and speed bootsalso why all that just because i suggested some enchantments..just say good ones or bad ones or give an edit..no need to make a problem if someone suggested it before
1-dont talk about the animation and model..what if i said it summons fire but with the same mechanic? also whats the problem if i repeated a suggestion..i just made a list of enchantments and i liked this enchantment to be a part of it Because it's a redundant, generic idea that really isn't that good in the first place. Also, what's the point of summoning lightning if the sword does damage in the first place? Why not just an enchantment that does bonus damage, like sharpness?
2-u may be right if u say blaze is overpowered but making last level of thorns do area damage is not over powered for 2 reasons, one is that u should be damaged to damage, That's the same with thorns
two it doesn't do massive damage Again, same with thorns. So this is the same thing, but spread out over a certain area which is OP.
3-speed potions doesn't do same job, and you are not who will waste his time for that..there are people taking money for that How do speed potions not do the same job? Also, I find it hard to believe anyone would "waste time" coding your suggestions.
4-k just forget durability or maybe we do it like speed potions and speed boots What? No. You can't go "k just forget it" and backpedal on your suggestion as if nothing happened.
also why all that just because i suggested some enchantments..just say good ones or bad ones or give an edit..no need to make a problem if someone suggested it before No need to make a problem out of it if someone criticizes your suggestion, either.
1-dont talk about the animation and model..what if i said it summons fire but with the same mechanic? also whats the problem if i repeated a suggestion..i just made a list of enchantments and i liked this enchantment to be a part of it Where the hell did the "don't talk about the animation and model" line come from? I wasn't even talking about that. Summoning fire is already possible with the Flare and Fire Aspect enchantments. Also, repeating a suggestion = possible locked thread.
2-u may be right if u say blaze is overpowered but making last level of thorns do area damage is not over powered for 2 reasons, one is that u should be damaged to damage, two it doesn't do massive damage None of that matters. There are over 10,000,000 people who play this game and at least one of them will find an exploit. Saying something isn't overpowered doesn't magically make that true. You still risk damaging passive mobs around when you didn't want to.
An enchantment like this could cause more complications than benefits, therefore it's best if it never exists.
3-speed potions doesn't do same job, and you are not who will waste his time for that..there are people taking money for that Don't have a damn clue what you said in the last sentence. Errr yes, speed potions DO do the same thing, they make you move faster. Just like your enchantment.
4-k just forget durability or maybe we do it like speed potions and speed boots Or we just stick with speed potions and not add pointless lines of code for an enchantment to do the same thing, which I've said for the third time now.
also why all that just because i suggested some enchantments..just say good ones or bad ones or give an edit..no need to make a problem if someone suggested it before Okay then, all of those enchantments are bad. Also, if something gets suggested enough times here, threads start getting locked.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hey, you there. Yes, you! Are you thinking about posting a suggestion on the forums anytime soon? If so, please read this before doing so.
First of all, storm is basically a viral attack that hits one mob and then everything else gets attacked by it? Wouldn't it damage you? Also Blaze enchantment is horribly OP. 0.5 hearts per 2 seconds would be a pain for everybody, especially if you're trying not to kill everyone but you're going to wound up doing that anyways. Cleaver seems even more ridiculously OP; try using something of that effect on a PVP server. You're more or likely going to be completely ruined by ANYTHING with the Cleaver enchantment...
Actually, no. I don't think I should really have to explain why this is bad... It's just bad.
Speed potions only give 20% speed...
That lightning thing sounds like copy from thaumcraft.
more than 20% will be overpowered and there is potions for extreme speed, also i didn't hear about thaum craft and if u played dota 2 the lightning will be like maelstorm or mjollnir
1-Storm [for sword]
the enchantment gives a chance to create a bolt of lightning that damages mobs upon hitting with the sword, its like a line that appears between the hit mob and the nearest mob and damages nearest mob, then disappears and appears again between the second mob and another one, and keeps jumping like that from a mob to another until its out of jumps, if it shocked all mobs around and still have jumps it returns to shock already shocked ones, which means if the shock appeared while there are only 2 mobs it will go and return to do heavy damage.
levels
I : 1 heart per shock (or per jump) , jumps 3 times
II : 1,5 heart per shock , jumps 5 times
III : 2 heart per shock , jumps 6 times
2-Blaze [for chestplate]
damages all mobs around by 0.5 heart per 2 secs, mob damage animation is not applied and particles appear at nearest mobs which are being damaged, has only one level
3-cleaver [for sword]
with every hit nearest mobs are damaged with hit mob at front of you, other mobs are damaged less than main mob
levels:
I : 40% damage for other mobs
II : 60% damage for other mobs
III : 80% damage for other mobs
4-speed [for boots]
increases wearers speed slightly, less than potion speed but lasts as long as the boot is equip
levels:
I : bonus speed 10%
II : bonus speed 20%
III : bonus speed 30%
5-Durability [for chestplate]
increases max health (WoW)
levels:
I : 2 hearts
II : 3 hearts
III : 5 hearts
6-elemental [for sword and bow]
this enchantment works only if adding potions to weapons feature is added, which will allow to craft a sword with a potion to make next hit has the potion effect, this enchantment gives more "potion-effect" hits with only 1 potion ( as i said that adding a potion gives only 1 hit with potion effect ), this enchantment will be only available at enchanted books in dungeons.
levels:
I : 1 extra use
II : 3 extra uses
7-frost [for sword and bow]
hitting with this slows target and gives it blue color for 3 secs, getting burnt removes this buff, also this enchantment deals bonus damage for endermen and blazes (like bane of athropodus for spiders)
levels :
I : slow 15%
II : slow 30%
III : slow 40%
The Unofficial Suggestion Guide - Everything you need to know to not make goofy mistakes in a suggestion! Honestly though, you should really go there.
u gived a good answer, storm isn't over suggested ( i guess as i had more than one year at the community and no one suggested it)
blaze, maybe u are right , but if we made it about getting hit it will be just like thorns but with area damage?! that can be only if we added a new level of thorns that does area damage too..
speed gives this percent of normal speed..bonus speed from potions will not be also increase..also potions are fast enough to say they are over powered so adding also bonus speed won't make them over powered..also if u still say its over powered by adding potion speed to this enchantment then we can make drinking speed potion removes this small bonus speed
about durability i didn't hear about its given to golden apples
You joined 03 August 2012. It is now 01 July 2013. Not August.
Lies and slander!
Also no support. It has been over-suggested and anymore enchantments would just be obscure.
1-dont talk about the animation and model..what if i said it summons fire but with the same mechanic? also whats the problem if i repeated a suggestion..i just made a list of enchantments and i liked this enchantment to be a part of it
2-u may be right if u say blaze is overpowered but making last level of thorns do area damage is not over powered for 2 reasons, one is that u should be damaged to damage, two it doesn't do massive damage
3-speed potions doesn't do same job, and you are not who will waste his time for that..there are people taking money for that
4-k just forget durability or maybe we do it like speed potions and speed bootsalso why all that just because i suggested some enchantments..just say good ones or bad ones or give an edit..no need to make a problem if someone suggested it before
Actually, no. I don't think I should really have to explain why this is bad... It's just bad.
u didn't get the idea, i said the lighting jumps from a mob to another..its not like that big lightning at thunder storms..its a small shock
That lightning thing sounds like copy from thaumcraft.
more than 20% will be overpowered and there is potions for extreme speed, also i didn't hear about thaum craft and if u played dota 2 the lightning will be like maelstorm or mjollnir