Horses are pretty much our closest thing to a car but what about submarines and planes.
Here are some of my ideas
Hot Air Ballon
Horse Cart
Submarine
Hang Glider
HoverCraft
Speed Boat
Canoe
Those are some of my ideas post yours in the comments below
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I love redstone, he loves redstone, you like redstone, that dog likes redstone, same with that cat, that brick likes redstone, wait no he does not, that noob needs redstone, that blender likes redstone, and same with that pile of trash, that Sethbling wants redstone, WE ALL LIKE REDSTONE !!!
Yeah I was just trying to have a long list. But any suggestions would be awesome.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I love redstone, he loves redstone, you like redstone, that dog likes redstone, same with that cat, that brick likes redstone, wait no he does not, that noob needs redstone, that blender likes redstone, and same with that pile of trash, that Sethbling wants redstone, WE ALL LIKE REDSTONE !!!
Sorry to burst the bubble here, but this is a wishlist. Wishlists are against the rules of this forum, and will be met with a swift lock.
The reason for this is to allow single, fully fleshed out ideas to be posted so everybody can understand, and eventually support. Since the rest are controversial at best, why don't you start by deleting all of these and focus on the Horse Cart, the only vehicle in here that has some merit. Let me help you by providing some questions to develop the idea:
Horse Cart:
How will it be crafted? Provide a crafting recipe via a cropped screenshot or an emote diagram (not recommended).
What will it do? (I can guess the answer: an attachment to horses. This is what people will expect it to do, given the name).
Assumming this is a vehicle, How much HP does it have? (The Minecart and Boat have HP as well as mobs).
Are there any special abilities to make the Horse Cart worth crafting?
Will the Horse Cart penalize the Horse itself in some way?
How can you balance the Horse Cart in comparison to other methods of transportation?
If you can answer all of those questions in text form, you now have a fully fledged suggestion! Once posted, it is up to the critics to either support the suggestion, or point out flaws (eg. The speed is too slow).
This is not a wish list because all of the items are closely related and that is just a list of some of my ideas.This thread is really about what other people want for more vehicles.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I love redstone, he loves redstone, you like redstone, that dog likes redstone, same with that cat, that brick likes redstone, wait no he does not, that noob needs redstone, that blender likes redstone, and same with that pile of trash, that Sethbling wants redstone, WE ALL LIKE REDSTONE !!!
This is not a wish list because all of the items are closely related and that is just a list of some of my ideas.
This thread is really about what other people want for more vehicles.
No, he's right. This is a wish list, because:
1. It's a list of things you want.
2. You didn't bother to expand them, like Oventoaster said.
If I were you I would either make a new thread with one of these ideas and expand it, or do it here. If you don't it's probable that this topic will be locked.
This is not a wish list because all of the items are closely related and that is just a list of some of my ideas.
This thread is really about what other people want for more vehicles.
In red, you clearly defined a wishlist. Your items are loosely related, but that does not make it any less of a wishlist. Take my horse cart example I posted earlier. It is perfectly okay to propose different things that work with it, such as a canopy or a ballista turret FOR the horse cart, but suggesting a new vehicle in it's entirety is not.
Here is an example of a decent general Mob suggestion by person A, in layman's terms:
This is a new mob. This is what it does. Here is it's HP. Its drop can be used to craft other things, such as this and that.
Here is another OK suggestion by person B:
Here are three boss mobs. These are their behaviors. Their drops can be fused together to make a unique item. They can be found in their own structures in these locations.
Take note of the underlined statements here. This poster suggested 10 things:
3 Boss mobs
3 useless items
1 unique item
3 generated structures
However, this is not a wishlist for these reasons:
The generated structures house the Bosses
The useless items are drops from the Bosses
The unique item is crafted from the three useless items; you must defeat the bosses to get the unique item.
Here is another suggestion by person C:
Here are two different ores. This is what ore A does. This is what ore B does. The ores themselves are not related.
This is a controversial suggestion, as the OP suggests two completely different ores that are not related to each other. Unfortunately, a moderator locked it because it was confused for a wishlist.
Your suggestion is like person C. I'm just saying.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Feel free to help out my dragon! Keep views to a minimum please!
Look at the cooking soups thread they have a list of ideas and its been running for a long timeBut I wil take the list off anyway
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I love redstone, he loves redstone, you like redstone, that dog likes redstone, same with that cat, that brick likes redstone, wait no he does not, that noob needs redstone, that blender likes redstone, and same with that pile of trash, that Sethbling wants redstone, WE ALL LIKE REDSTONE !!!
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Here are some of my ideas
Hot Air Ballon
Horse Cart
Submarine
Hang Glider
HoverCraft
Speed Boat
Canoe
Those are some of my ideas post yours in the comments below
The reason for this is to allow single, fully fleshed out ideas to be posted so everybody can understand, and eventually support. Since the rest are controversial at best, why don't you start by deleting all of these and focus on the Horse Cart, the only vehicle in here that has some merit. Let me help you by providing some questions to develop the idea:
Horse Cart:
- How will it be crafted? Provide a crafting recipe via a cropped screenshot or an emote diagram (not recommended).
- What will it do? (I can guess the answer: an attachment to horses. This is what people will expect it to do, given the name).
- Assumming this is a vehicle, How much HP does it have? (The Minecart and Boat have HP as well as mobs).
- Are there any special abilities to make the Horse Cart worth crafting?
- Will the Horse Cart penalize the Horse itself in some way?
- How can you balance the Horse Cart in comparison to other methods of transportation?
If you can answer all of those questions in text form, you now have a fully fledged suggestion! Once posted, it is up to the critics to either support the suggestion, or point out flaws (eg. The speed is too slow).Why don't you try that?
No, he's right. This is a wish list, because:
1. It's a list of things you want.
2. You didn't bother to expand them, like Oventoaster said.
If I were you I would either make a new thread with one of these ideas and expand it, or do it here. If you don't it's probable that this topic will be locked.
In red, you clearly defined a wishlist. Your items are loosely related, but that does not make it any less of a wishlist. Take my horse cart example I posted earlier. It is perfectly okay to propose different things that work with it, such as a canopy or a ballista turret FOR the horse cart, but suggesting a new vehicle in it's entirety is not.
Here is an example of a decent general Mob suggestion by person A, in layman's terms:
Here is another OK suggestion by person B:
Take note of the underlined statements here. This poster suggested 10 things:
3 Boss mobs
3 useless items
1 unique item
3 generated structures
However, this is not a wishlist for these reasons:
- The generated structures house the Bosses
- The useless items are drops from the Bosses
- The unique item is crafted from the three useless items; you must defeat the bosses to get the unique item.
Here is another suggestion by person C:This is a controversial suggestion, as the OP suggests two completely different ores that are not related to each other. Unfortunately, a moderator locked it because it was confused for a wishlist.
Your suggestion is like person C. I'm just saying.