Basically, a JDI (Just Do It) is a minor and realistic feature that you're not quite sure why not already in the Vanilla game and which you want Mojang to "just do." For example, I created a topic about Nether Brick Fence Gates, which seem insensible to not exist yet.
Your JDI idea will be added to the list if at least 5 people choose to support it by replying on this thread, and if it's actually a JDI.
They don't have to be realism improvements; minor gameplay improvements could also be considered JDI's.
Okay, it's just that you described it as "a minor and realistic addition" or something like that. I do like the idea of netherbrick fences though, sorry, I accidently misread that the first time as "netherbrick furnaces", which I do NOT want.
Okay, it's just that you described it as "a minor and realistic addition" or something like that. I do like the idea of netherbrick fences though, sorry, I accidently misread that the first time as "netherbrick furnaces", which I do NOT want.
No, I didn't mean realistic as in real-life-realistic, I meant that it should be realistic to add to the game.
Here's the problem:
Everyone thinks their thing is "worthy" of being the main focus of Mojang's attention. They usually aren't. That's why the suggestions forum exists in the first place, as a refinery of ideas. Compiling random ideas into a list will not get them noticed more. Making a good suggestion that everyone likes, will.
This thread helps no one, is not a suggestion, and overall does nothing useful. Believe me, it's been done before (and to be frank, with a lot more effort put into organization than this). If you want your suggestion to be noticed, actually put thought and effort into it, that's all there is to it.
Here's the problem:
Everyone thinks their thing is "worthy" of being the main focus of Mojang's attention. They usually aren't. That's why the suggestions forum exists in the first place, as a refinery of ideas. Compiling random ideas into a list will not get them noticed more. Making a good suggestion that everyone likes, will.
This thread helps no one, is not a suggestion, and overall does nothing useful. Believe me, it's been done before (and to be frank, with a lot more effort put into organization than this). If you want your suggestion to be noticed, actually put thought and effort into it, that's all there is to it.
So you would have us clutter the suggestion forum with these sometimes small changes, only to have them likely sink to the back of the forum because other suggestions pop up and people focus on those as they pop up; Instead of telling us off for participating - or the OP for making - this thread, tell us why you think there is no netherbrick fence gate - or cobblestone fence gate, for that matter - in the game yet? Why is it that arrows, however small, always hit you if you jump? Where is that topic I saw - and supported if I recall - of different wood types being used to create different colors of wood products? We already get slabs, stairs, planks in different colors, but almost every other wood product is one color scheme, and one color scheme only. That isn't sensible at all - the creation of different colored planks would lead you to believe you can make different colored chests, fences, fence gates, wooden doors...
Not to mention the creation of netherfence and cobblestone/mossy cobblestone wall leads you to look for fence gates of the same. This topic is a decent idea, and not just a list of "I WANT THESE ANYONE ELSE WANT THESE OR SOMETHING ELSE?" - It's still like that, somewhat, but it also is for things that SHOULD be "just done". (Nike not included)
If you're opposed to that, and would have us split up and recreate topics that have fallen to the back of the forum when suggested before - despite being sensible and good ideas - Okay. I'll go post a topic for each one I think of. That's one for netherbrick and fence gates, one for arrow jumping, one for different wood colored products - three topics condensed into one as that is, and I'm too tired to remember the others I thought of last night. I'd prefer to keep it confined to this topic, instead of helping clutter the forum...
Rules are merely a thinking man's frame of reference.
That said, the "Small Suggestions" thread does exist, and seems like the place for something like netherfencegates. I don't know if that thread is updated very often or indexed very well, though...
Rules are merely a thinking man's frame of reference.
That said, the "Small Suggestions" thread does exist, and seems like the place for something like netherfencegates. I don't know if that thread is updated very often or indexed very well, though...
I don't often use small suggestions because looking at it, I doubt it's all that watched.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Basically, a JDI (Just Do It) is a minor and realistic feature that you're not quite sure why not already in the Vanilla game and which you want Mojang to "just do." For example, I created a topic about Nether Brick Fence Gates, which seem insensible to not exist yet.
Your JDI idea will be added to the list if at least 5 people choose to support it by replying on this thread, and if it's actually a JDI.
The List:
Any Questions? Reply.
And arrow jumping (like TF2 rocket jumps).
Okay, it's just that you described it as "a minor and realistic addition" or something like that. I do like the idea of netherbrick fences though, sorry, I accidently misread that the first time as "netherbrick furnaces", which I do NOT want.
No, I didn't mean realistic as in real-life-realistic, I meant that it should be realistic to add to the game.
Oh, okay. Now that this is explained a bit better, and we have this in the replies, I supportz.
Fence that changes color/texture based on what wood was used to make it;
Kind it atm.
Everyone thinks their thing is "worthy" of being the main focus of Mojang's attention. They usually aren't. That's why the suggestions forum exists in the first place, as a refinery of ideas. Compiling random ideas into a list will not get them noticed more. Making a good suggestion that everyone likes, will.
This thread helps no one, is not a suggestion, and overall does nothing useful. Believe me, it's been done before (and to be frank, with a lot more effort put into organization than this). If you want your suggestion to be noticed, actually put thought and effort into it, that's all there is to it.
[quote=Badgerz]You have to keep in mind that people are stupid.
[quote=Catelite]Just because you don't understand how something works, doesn't make it broken or pointless. >_<
So you would have us clutter the suggestion forum with these sometimes small changes, only to have them likely sink to the back of the forum because other suggestions pop up and people focus on those as they pop up; Instead of telling us off for participating - or the OP for making - this thread, tell us why you think there is no netherbrick fence gate - or cobblestone fence gate, for that matter - in the game yet? Why is it that arrows, however small, always hit you if you jump? Where is that topic I saw - and supported if I recall - of different wood types being used to create different colors of wood products? We already get slabs, stairs, planks in different colors, but almost every other wood product is one color scheme, and one color scheme only. That isn't sensible at all - the creation of different colored planks would lead you to believe you can make different colored chests, fences, fence gates, wooden doors...
Not to mention the creation of netherfence and cobblestone/mossy cobblestone wall leads you to look for fence gates of the same. This topic is a decent idea, and not just a list of "I WANT THESE ANYONE ELSE WANT THESE OR SOMETHING ELSE?" - It's still like that, somewhat, but it also is for things that SHOULD be "just done". (Nike not included)
If you're opposed to that, and would have us split up and recreate topics that have fallen to the back of the forum when suggested before - despite being sensible and good ideas - Okay. I'll go post a topic for each one I think of. That's one for netherbrick and fence gates, one for arrow jumping, one for different wood colored products - three topics condensed into one as that is, and I'm too tired to remember the others I thought of last night. I'd prefer to keep it confined to this topic, instead of helping clutter the forum...
Or is that not okay?
That said, the "Small Suggestions" thread does exist, and seems like the place for something like netherfencegates. I don't know if that thread is updated very often or indexed very well, though...
I don't often use small suggestions because looking at it, I doubt it's all that watched.