Problem/Setting:
Some of you might have tried to test out the firework when it was released in the snapshot or in the full version in creative. You opened the menu searched for firework and were shown "Firework Star" and "Firework", you clicked the firework and brought it to your hot bar, when you closed the menu and tried it you waited in awe for the explosion of colour that comes with fireworks, but you were greeted with a fizzle, you may have tried again thinking Mojang made it so there is a chance of the firework failing but the same result, you may have held the right click button, but again, same result. You then probably opened the creative menu, got out a crafting table, plopped it down, then had to assemble it your self, switching from the creative menu to the crafting table, which can be a slight hassle. Or maybe you have encountered hassles with dying leather armour, or even banners. In the 1.9 update there appears to be shields customized with banners, sure it is only a two item recipe (banner + shield), but shouldn't that mean that there should be a quick and easy way of accessing the crafting table?
Solution/Suggestion:
I suggest a 3 by 3 crafting grid was added to the creative menu, this will reduce the hassle and slightly reduce the time of making fireworks or other things which have the same problem. The change wouldn't be massive and would not really affect anyone negatively. It's one of those things that should have been added.
IMAGE 1: (I forgot to include the output for the grid. I had to re-size the grid to make it fit, which may lead to problems)
IMAGE 2 By Wircea: (Always on the right side of the creative menu)
Image 3 By Apocalypsing: (Separate Crafting Table Tab)
Pros :
Easier crafting of different types of fireworks
Reduced time of crafting fireworks or other items which follow the same rule
Less hassle
Solution for the con: Mojang can easily move the crafting grid to its own page on the menu. Mojang has also made HD texture packs downloadable without patcher by resizing the textures (not sure if it would still be HD), so the same could be down to the images.
You can dye leather armour without switching back and forth from crafting table go menu (use thought of after EnellGmz's comment)
Easier for snapshot videos as they have access to a crafting grid while showing recipes
For the resizing thing when I played Minecraft on the 360 and I saw the output item of the survival inventory is larger and it expands the icon. (Though, I think it was double the size, so if it was on the survival inventory on the pc version it would have to be half the size.)
Cons:
To fit the crafting grid in the menu I had to resize it, so unless Mojang has a store of mini images or put it on a separate page of the menu this can't work.
I agree. They had a 2x2 grid in the survival inventory during the snapshots, but they removed it. I don't understand why. I think they should re-add it, but 3x3, and not 2x2.
I agree. They had a 2x2 grid in the survival inventory during the snapshots, but they removed it. I don't understand why. I think they should re-add it, but 3x3, and not 2x2.
Support.
Wait, they removed it? They better re-add it as 3x3!
Thanks for all the support, this is my first suggestion so I wasn't expecting a surge of support comments.
I also searched for a similar topic, I didn't find any, if there is I didn't search hard enough.
Thanks for all the support, this is my first suggestion so I wasn't expecting a surge of support comments.
I also searched for a similar topic, I didn't find any, if there is I didn't search hard enough.
Some people are just good at making suggestions. Take Gengar_ as an example. His first suggestion was an amazing ghost suggestion. Me? Eh, I'm better at ripping bad threads to shreds with criticism.
The last part of the OP says to have it added to the Creative Inventory, so it might be a good idea to post there too. This shouldn't be closed or anything though, as some people would want this, but not to have the Crafting Grid everywhere else though.
Just some information.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
[quote=Badprenup;/comments/5853787]
This is a good idea, and is well thought out, but it has been suggested before as part of a suggestion for adding at least the 2x2 grid to all GUIs:
The last part of the OP says to have it added to the Creative Inventory, so it might be a good idea to post there too. This shouldn't be closed or anything though, as some people would want this, but not to have the Crafting Grid everywhere else though.
Just some information.
Thanks Badprenup. I will consider posting there and maybe posting this link on it.
Problem/Setting:
Some of you might have tried to test out the firework when it was released in the snapshot or in the full version in creative. You opened the menu searched for firework and were shown "Firework Star" and "Firework", you clicked the firework and brought it to your hot bar, when you closed the menu and tried it you waited in awe for the explosion of colour that comes with fireworks, but you were greeted with a fizzle, you may have tried again thinking Mojang made it so there is a chance of the firework failing but the same result, you may have held the right click button, but again, same result. You then probably opened the creative menu, got out a crafting table, plopped it down, then had to assemble it your self, switching from the creative menu to the crafting table, which can be a slight hassle. Or maybe you have encountered hassles with dying leather armour, or even banners. In the 1.9 update there appears to be shields customized with banners, sure it is only a two item recipe (banner + shield), but shouldn't that mean that there should be a quick and easy way of accessing the crafting table?
Solution/Suggestion:
I suggest a 3 by 3 crafting grid was added to the creative menu, this will reduce the hassle and slightly reduce the time of making fireworks or other things which have the same problem. The change wouldn't be massive and would not really affect anyone negatively. It's one of those things that should have been added.
IMAGE 1: (I forgot to include the output for the grid. I had to re-size the grid to make it fit, which may lead to problems)
IMAGE 2 By Wircea: (Always on the right side of the creative menu)
Image 3 By Apocalypsing: (Separate Crafting Table Tab)
Pros :
Cons:
Supporters:
StubbyEE
Waylon8tor
Jpmrocks
Sourishlegstraps
Unitedsquadron3
Dillyman2
Peagaming
Wircea
EnellGmz
BioShock_Rules
Droideka30
Acidxxrain
Olgaby
Banhammer911
WaveJones
Apocalypsing
DragonRush
113820
Zorket
Tinyds
xBublizZ
Dennis2pro
Aeaeiouuy
AngryPengin
Astro3905
Bigtry_guy
Trollsack
BlackAbsence
Humpy123
Flameoguy
The_FUSA
BadBoy6767
Redsnoopio
SparkytheHellcat
FishFruit
Roverb
Meissmart
Zitchas
MinecraftNotchinU
Kidpen
Cookiehook
Whycantipickanyusernames
Xilioth
Supercofee
People who gave the original post reputation points.
Banner:
Code:
Code:
Similar Suggestions:
The Next Evolution for In Game Interfaces
Better Creative Modes
Any other comments? Any one disagreeing or supporting? I added a poll.
Support.
I also searched for a similar topic, I didn't find any, if there is I didn't search hard enough.
Thanks.
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1650351-the-next-evolution-in-popups/
The last part of the OP says to have it added to the Creative Inventory, so it might be a good idea to post there too. This shouldn't be closed or anything though, as some people would want this, but not to have the Crafting Grid everywhere else though.
Just some information.
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
[quote=Badprenup;/comments/5853787]
This is a good idea, and is well thought out, but it has been suggested before as part of a suggestion for adding at least the 2x2 grid to all GUIs:
http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/1650351-the-next-evolution-in-popups/
The last part of the OP says to have it added to the Creative Inventory, so it might be a good idea to post there too. This shouldn't be closed or anything though, as some people would want this, but not to have the Crafting Grid everywhere else though.
Just some information.
Thanks Badprenup. I will consider posting there and maybe posting this link on it.
Yes. That's one of the cons I added after I made the photo.