Minecraft Forums

So I was thinking, since many of the items are already implemented, why not create a food item like that requires almost all the necessary farmed food items and create one big item that restores 10-12 hunger points or quite possibly another group food item like cake that restores 4 hunger points and has 6 uses like Cake would (with a greater hunger saturation level)???

The items could be:

Pot Pie:
Cooked Beef (or Cooked Chicken)
Carrots
Potatoes
Bucket (to simulate a pot of some sort)
Wheat (for the crust )

Or even go further with it:

The Pot Pies + Bread = Feast of Champions or Beef Stew or Chicken Stew (Creates a group food item, and could require a wooden bowl to obtain a bowl to savor the deliciousness)

And a Bowl of Stew could grant:
4 Hunger Points
A certain amount of hunger saturation that's high enough to get back into the minefields and be out there for a while (Like 15-18 since Cooked Beef alone provides 12.8)

It'd be a great item to have in for those group sessions when say someone is the designated food farmer Plus with the item requirements it'd be somewhat of a pretty rare food item to have, yet easy enough to obtain.

How is this the greatest idea ever?

Could you please add a maybe as achoice in the poll. That's what I would choose.

I hate this idea.
It serves no purpose and is a waste of a ton of materials just for a single food item that doesn't even sound appealing in the slightest.

Also, please remove the "GREATEST IDEA EVAR!! LIKE IT NAO!!1!11!!!" part.
It's extremely childish and will bring even more negative attention to your topic.

Quote from WaterTipper

I hate this idea.
It serves no purpose and is a waste of a ton of materials just for a single food item that doesn't even sound appealing in the slightest.

Also, please remove the "GREATEST IDEA EVAR!! LIKE IT NAO!!1!11!!!" part.
It's extremely childish and will bring even more negative attention to your topic.

Quote from Mathy

No support, I'd never actually have it (I have cake and pie as a party in our faction, that's it for combo foods) and as Water said, don't say Greatest Idea Ever. We don't need subjective arguments.

For starters, the "Greatest Idea Ever" in the title was obvious hyperbole; it wasn't meant to be taken literally :\ It seems that the original post wasn't read and a few browsers simply focused on the thread title (seemingly as I stated the said item could provide more hunger points and saturation than Cooked Beef, obvious suggestions to providing something more than what could be obtained from what we already have in-game)

As for purpose, I stated to create a food item that would provide more in terms of hunger and hunger saturation which was up to discussion, since while cake and pie also requires several items yet provides a low saturation level and/or hunger point increase, a feast item could provide more since it would require more, especially in team sessions. This could be another alternative to cake (seeing as cake is the only group food item and could be explored more) in providing a group food item and not simply a single-use item.

The suggestion was up to discussion and not concrete, meaning it could be worked or fixed on.

Quote from unitedsquadron3

Could you please add a maybe as achoice in the poll. That's what I would choose.

Will do. I meant "as a choice" for the poll but should've stated it out, sorry about that sir/madam.

Dang it! I was just about to post Beef Stew myself!

Although mine was just crafted with Cooked Steak, Carrot, Potato, and Bucket of Water, which yielded the stew contained in the bucket.

Pro: Gives lots of Hunger points and high Saturation

Con: Doesn't stack, requires bucket.

Quote from Cobalt32

Dang it! I was just about to post Beef Stew myself!

Although mine was just crafted with Cooked Steak, Carrot, Potato, and Bucket of Water, which yielded the stew contained in the bucket.

Pro: Gives lots of Hunger points and high Saturation

Con: Doesn't stack, requires bucket.

Same I was thinking of Stew but then I was trying to develop off of it to have like a group stew

Quote from Mathy

I like the complete ignore of the negative feedback. Why don't you defend your idea, instead of shying away from negative comments?

1001 Posts!

What negative feedback? I was just posting frustration at an already-existing thread for an idea I wanted to post, followed by my version of the idea that I was about to post.