I was enchanting diamond swords in Minecraft... When I had some ideas for enchantments for items.
Its just two enchantment ideas, but I like them. Smelting I
*Applies to Pickaxes Only
-Can only be obtained in 5+ enchanting table Level
When a ore is mined, such as gold ore or iron ore, a ingot drops instead of the ore. Butcher I - II
*Applies to Swords Only
-Can be obtained in any enchanting table level
Each level Butcher is, will deal 1 extra heart of damage to passive mobs
(Similar to Smite & Bane of Arthropods but for passive mobs like cows, pigs, mooshrooms, etc)
I think the Smelting one should have a low to very low chance of working, as it puts a heavy dampening on the use of furnaces. The Butcher one isn't that useful as passive mobs can be downed with one or two critical hits from nearly any kind of sword, and the Sharpness enchantment already does this.
I personally find Bane of Athropods and Smite to be rather silly too. You need to be using a high level of the Enchantments to take advantage of that 0.5 HP of damage per level, and even then if you put it on a high level sword normal mobs will be going down in 2 hits at most anyways.
I like Smelting, but it needs to have a low chance of working. Possibly doing 3 levels, 11%, 22%, and 33%
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
Its just two enchantment ideas, but I like them.
Smelting I
*Applies to Pickaxes Only
-Can only be obtained in 5+ enchanting table Level
When a ore is mined, such as gold ore or iron ore, a ingot drops instead of the ore.
Butcher I - II
*Applies to Swords Only
-Can be obtained in any enchanting table level
Each level Butcher is, will deal 1 extra heart of damage to passive mobs
(Similar to Smite & Bane of Arthropods but for passive mobs like cows, pigs, mooshrooms, etc)
Not a bad idea how about a 50% chance
Butcher I-II
Smite is this enchantment.
Nope. Smite is only active against skeletons, zombies and zombie pigmen.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
ModeratorI like Smelting, but it needs to have a low chance of working. Possibly doing 3 levels, 11%, 22%, and 33%
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
i like smelting, and smite is for undead like zombies. I think swords kill passives easy enough so butcher is not necessary.