I want to add two items to Minecraft. Stones, and planks. Don't confuse them with the blocks, though. The reason, is because wooden planks and cobblestone are very easy to collect, it is unrealistic to have one wood or stone block give you four wooden planks or one cobblestone block. So instead I came up with this.
Planks
Planks would be crafted with one wood block. It would give you 16 planks. Planks would be the crafting ingredient of wooden planks. All items (swords, sticks, etc.) would be crafted with planks instead of the blocks. All blocks (crafting table, etc.) would not be changed.
Stones
Stones would be found when you break a stone block instead of cobblestone. You would get four stones per stone block. Like planks, all items would be crafted with stone and all blocks with cobblestone blocks. It would take four stones to make cobblestone.
Sorry if you don't like it, I am trying to get realistic. I know the stones would get annoying giving you four times as much items, but I am trying to find a way to make a plus to that.
it is unrealistic to have one wood or stone block give you four wooden planks or one cobblestone block.
Not every gameplay mechanic needs to be super realistic. The system we have now works well in the game, and ruining or changing something just for the sake of being more realistic is not always the best thing to do. Gameplay > Realism. No matter what.
Planks
Planks would be crafted with one wood block. It would give you 16 planks. Planks would be the crafting ingredient of wooden planks. All items (swords, sticks, etc.) would be crafted with planks instead of the blocks. All blocks (crafting table, etc.) would not be changed.
We've all been using sticks since Day 1, so there doesn't seem to be much drive for Mojang to replace sticks with planks for some tools. Also, it's a lot quicker to just go from wooden plank blocks to sticks, rather than having to do that boring plank stage in between.
Stones
Stones would be found when you break a stone block instead of cobblestone. You would get four stones per stone block. Like planks, all items would be crafted with stone and all blocks with cobblestone blocks. It would take four stones to make cobblestone.
This is extremely pointless. Let's just keep it where we get Cobblestone instantly from mining Stone, and not have to worry about all these little stones and crafting them.
I know the stones would get annoying giving you four times as much items, but I am trying to find a way to make a plus to that.
There isn't much "plus" to something like that, because the core idea itself is not very good. Or needed.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hey, you there. Yes, you! Are you thinking about posting a suggestion on the forums anytime soon? If so, please read this before doing so.
i see this is solely to increase the realism in Minecraft. But this lowers all of the other aspects of Minecraft. It's not worth it. It's basically just another step.
i see this is solely to increase the realism in Minecraft. But this lowers all of the other aspects of Minecraft. It's not worth it. It's basically just another step.
I know, but as easy as it is, how do you feel to make a cobble pick with three cubic meter cobble stones?
I agree with other people have been saying. This makes the game even more tedious than it already is.
Take the feedback you've been given, or leave it. Either way, I believe this will never be added to the game.
No support from me.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Kingdoms rise and fall. Just don't burn the paintings in the Louvre, that's all.
I know, but as easy as it is, how do you feel to make a cobble pick with three cubic meter cobble stones?
I feel perfectly fine with it, since it's in the same computer game where villagers have squidward noses and green bushy things with frowny faces explode, thank you.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
[quote=Badgerz]You have to keep in mind that people are stupid.
[quote=Catelite]Just because you don't understand how something works, doesn't make it broken or pointless. >_<
Planks
Planks would be crafted with one wood block. It would give you 16 planks. Planks would be the crafting ingredient of wooden planks. All items (swords, sticks, etc.) would be crafted with planks instead of the blocks. All blocks (crafting table, etc.) would not be changed.
Stones
Stones would be found when you break a stone block instead of cobblestone. You would get four stones per stone block. Like planks, all items would be crafted with stone and all blocks with cobblestone blocks. It would take four stones to make cobblestone.
Sorry if you don't like it, I am trying to get realistic. I know the stones would get annoying giving you four times as much items, but I am trying to find a way to make a plus to that.
Thank you for your time!
Not every gameplay mechanic needs to be super realistic. The system we have now works well in the game, and ruining or changing something just for the sake of being more realistic is not always the best thing to do. Gameplay > Realism. No matter what.
We've all been using sticks since Day 1, so there doesn't seem to be much drive for Mojang to replace sticks with planks for some tools. Also, it's a lot quicker to just go from wooden plank blocks to sticks, rather than having to do that boring plank stage in between.
This is extremely pointless. Let's just keep it where we get Cobblestone instantly from mining Stone, and not have to worry about all these little stones and crafting them.
There isn't much "plus" to something like that, because the core idea itself is not very good. Or needed.
I know, but as easy as it is, how do you feel to make a cobble pick with three cubic meter cobble stones?
Take the feedback you've been given, or leave it. Either way, I believe this will never be added to the game.
No support from me.
I feel perfectly fine with it, since it's in the same computer game where villagers have squidward noses and green bushy things with frowny faces explode, thank you.
[quote=Badgerz]You have to keep in mind that people are stupid.
[quote=Catelite]Just because you don't understand how something works, doesn't make it broken or pointless. >_<
LAME!