Since 1.8, cookies are useless restoring only half of an icon. I suggest to make them instantly edible, maybe also limiting them to being stackable to 16 if that's too OP. It's a pretty mechanic and fits well for them.
Well, cookies are used more like a Trophy than food. They do, of course, involve Chocolate/Cocoa Beans. However, I do agree that they should Heal more Hunger. In fact, Cookies might even become the Food that restores Health, too.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Excuse me, but that was my comment you just read there, bub.
Even if cocoa beans become renewable, it would be still useless, and increasing their amount of nourishment will only make them harder to get melon slices, if instant eating is OP, maybe just make them faster to eat since they're small