Now, as you all know, digging up dirt/grass in minecraft yields only dirt. But in real life, does this make sense? No, it certainly does not. When you are to go outside and dig ( for whatever reason ) you end up with rocks, bits of grass, and chunks in the dirt you dug up. Now, can you just take that dirt, plop it down, and farm on it? No. What I am getting at is this: Digging grass yields "Rocky Dirt." With the rocky dirt, you go and filter it by -INSERT YOUR SUGGESTION HERE-, and you end up with ( pure ) dirt. Now you can go and farm on it. Now that big of a suggestion, but it just hit me as I was bored in minecraft. Also, with the -INSERT YOUR SUGGESTION HERE- thing, well if you have an idea that fits in with mine as a way to filter the debris out of the dirt, suggest it.
A while ago I had to help my Dad resod the lawn, meaning rip out all of the existing dead grass, and replace it with brand new grass. We also had to clear out all the random crap in the dirt, including rocks, sticks, and mulch. Somewhat ties in with my suggestion in a weird way.
So after reading, praise or flame this suggestion forumers?
Interesting idea... But unlikely to be implimented. If you look at many of the things in Minecraft, there are imperfections everywhere, but those make the game what it is. The same argument could be used for coal, diamond, gravel, ect. And for that matter, rock.
......Wow, yeah I didnt even think about all the other things. This idea just came to me as I had just started a new world.
If you want something realistic, go outside and go live in some uninhabited forest.
In minecraft you can punch down forests, go to hell and back, make houses out of dirt, defend unrealistic hoards of zombies, skeleton archers, giant spiders, and demons that teleport.
Gotta be honest, people like you need to realise that every who plays minecraft is aware of the lack of those things. What this is about is adding something that would add a bit of depth to farming, flesh out gameplay a bit, and make just a teeny amount of sense. no, I am not asking for physics or circles in minecraft. Just a little thing that makes a little sense. Learn to understand my point of view.
Gotta be honest, people like you need to realise that every who plays minecraft is aware of the lack of those things. What this is about is adding something that would add a bit of depth to farming, flesh out gameplay a bit, and make just a teeny amount of sense. no, I am not asking for physics or circles in minecraft. Just a little thing that makes a little sense. Learn to understand my point of view.
Gotta be honest, people like you need to realise that minecraft is a sandbox game and was built to have fun and leave the sense of reality behind, that what all games are. What this is about is having a game that would test your thinking skills and expand your creative skills while being somewhat realistic, and have a good large amount of lolwut feeling to still have fun. I am not saying it can't have realism but adding overdone **** that would be too hard to implement is too much. It's just a game that is played because of these reasons. Learn to understand my point of view.
Gotta be honest, people like you need to realise that minecraft is a sandbox game and was built to have fun and leave the sense of reality behind, that what all games are. What this is about is having a game that would test your thinking skills and expand your creative skills while being somewhat realistic, and have a good large amount of lolwut feeling to still have fun. I am not saying it can't have realism but adding overdone **** that would be too hard to implement is too much. It's just a game that is played because of these reasons. Learn to understand my point of view.
Overdone ****? This is just filtrating dirt. If you want to criticize overdone ****, go check out the Better Than Wolves mod, that will keep you busy all day.
Overdone ****? This is just filtrating dirt. If you want to criticize overdone ****, go check out the Better Than Wolves mod, that will keep you busy all day.
Did it take you a while to finally pick out one thing from my passage to come back on?
The fact you want different types of dirt (over 10) to drop different crap (rocks dirt twigs ?worms?) that is not needed is worthless.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
MY MINECRAFT NOVEL HERE!Oh god why does this still exist
Quote from coalpup »
seriously how the can a man take a PIG and make THIS. Never leave this man alone with no logic and a computer
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
A while ago I had to help my Dad resod the lawn, meaning rip out all of the existing dead grass, and replace it with brand new grass. We also had to clear out all the random crap in the dirt, including rocks, sticks, and mulch. Somewhat ties in with my suggestion in a weird way.
So after reading, praise or flame this suggestion forumers?
......Wow, yeah I didnt even think about all the other things. This idea just came to me as I had just started a new world.
Filtration systems?
Different dirt types? (3rd Poster)
This seriously needs to be fleshed out a bit, anyone up for idea input?
Minecraft=/= Realism.
If you want something realistic, go outside and go live in some uninhabited forest.
In minecraft you can punch down forests, go to hell and back, make houses out of dirt, defend
unrealistic hoards of zombies, skeleton archers, giant spiders, and demons that teleport.Realistic suggestions will not be added
Gotta be honest, people like you need to realise that every who plays minecraft is aware of the lack of those things. What this is about is adding something that would add a bit of depth to farming, flesh out gameplay a bit, and make just a teeny amount of sense. no, I am not asking for physics or circles in minecraft. Just a little thing that makes a little sense. Learn to understand my point of view.
Gotta be honest, people like you need to realise that minecraft is a sandbox game and was built to have fun and leave the sense of reality behind, that what all games are. What this is about is having a game that would test your thinking skills and expand your creative skills while being somewhat realistic, and have a
goodlarge amount of lolwut feeling to still have fun. I am not saying it can't have realism but adding overdone **** that would be too hard to implement is too much. It's just a game that is played because of these reasons. Learn to understand my point of view.Overdone ****? This is just filtrating dirt. If you want to criticize overdone ****, go check out the Better Than Wolves mod, that will keep you busy all day.
Did it take you a while to finally pick out one thing from my passage to come back on?
The fact you want different types of dirt (over 10) to drop different crap (rocks dirt twigs ?worms?) that is not needed is worthless.