This isn't a suggestion, I am asking whether this has ever been mentioned? Pumpkins aren't growable and are fairly rare so I would assume it would heal at least half your health.
I kinda wish pumpkins were farmable. But I also think it makes sense for them to be craftable into food. Considering that 1.8 is supposed to expand food and farming, I feel that it's likely that both will happen.
I don't why it's not been suggested though, if it indeed hasn't.
Yea, it is said that the pumpkins are going to be farmable as of 1.8, and what would be the use of farming a block that is only for decoration. Generally speaking the items that don't have a purpose and rare, Therefore making them valuable in there own way: Bragging or SMP currency for example. Also decorating your house with common farmable blocks will not make it look better, because you want your build to be unique. Like mossy cobble and book cases. So if notch implements pumpkin farming then there would be even less of a point than there was before unless he implemented an Idea such as this along with it. So I support, however if they are farmable than to balence it out the pies would have to be expensive/ costly to make and heal lots or be cheap and not hel as much (obviously). So, I am fond of this idea.
Variety is nice, multiple options are nice, but I'm sure that's over your head.
I don't why it's not been suggested though, if it indeed hasn't.
If you want variety then download a mod :I
Maybe if they were farmable, but if they were farmable why should they be more powerful than other farmable items?
BBCode Render failed due to reaching MaxNestingDepth(80) for Tag: spoiler
Damn, You beat me to it.
OT: What Strotting said.