Now, I am sure this has already been suggested. But, I figured I would resuggest, just to get a few of my ideas out there and since pumpkins will be farmable soon, they should have at least one more GOOD use.
Now, to start with the pumpkins: Smelt the pumpkin, and you get pumpkin mash. The pumpkin mash can be used in the pies and as a dye that is a mix between brown and orange. Like a caramel color.
Now, to have pie tins. If you put wheat over a bowl, you get a pie tin. The bowl has a crust in it from the wheat. If you put the pumpkin mash over that pie tin, you get the pumpkin pie. The pumpkin pie can be placed like a cake. Eating it will take out a 4th and give you 2.5 hearts each bite. It would be a nice balance between cake and golden apple. Made of a slightly more rare material: the pumpkin. Pumpkin patches are uncommon, but eggs, wheat, sugar, and milk can be found pretty much everywhere. Golden apple is as expensive as hell to get, either by crafting or by dungeon hunting. The pumpkin pie as i described it would be a nice balance.
Thanks. I wonder what other comments there will be.
inb4: "already suggested". Guess what: I don't care. It's been a while since the last one and pumpkin farming should bring a new use to pumpkins, because we'll have so many.
This suggestion is overpowered come 1.8 when we will be able to grow Pumpkins.
Maybe like, 1.5 per bite, then?
Either way. Farmable pumpkins should give pumpkins more uses, otherwise: What's the point when you have glowstone and actual protective helmets? They should have more uses than decor, lighting, and silliness.
I think this would be ideal if pumpkins were not farmable. However, if the are, they should give 1.5 or two hearts per slice. And by the way, I have never seen a pumpkin pie or pumpkin mash suggestion.
I am going to say what I said on the other pumpkin pie threads.
it is said that the pumpkins are going to be farmable as of 1.8, and what would be the use of farming a block that is only for decoration. Generally speaking the items that don't have a purpose and rare, Therefore making them valuable in there own way: Bragging or SMP currency for example. Also decorating your house with common farmable blocks will not make it look better, because you want your build to be unique. Like mossy cobble and book cases. So if notch implements pumpkin farming then there would be even less of a point than there was before unless he implemented an Idea such as this along with it. So I support, however if they are farmable than to balence it out the pies would have to be expensive/ costly to make and heal lots or be cheap and not hel as much (obviously). So, I am fond of this idea.
Although it should be crafted like this in my opinion,
I think this would be ideal if pumpkins were not farmable. However, if the are, they should give 1.5 or two hearts per slice. And by the way, I have never seen a pumpkin pie or pumpkin mash suggestion.
Now, to start with the pumpkins: Smelt the pumpkin, and you get pumpkin mash. The pumpkin mash can be used in the pies and as a dye that is a mix between brown and orange. Like a caramel color.
Now, to have pie tins. If you put wheat over a bowl, you get a pie tin. The bowl has a crust in it from the wheat. If you put the pumpkin mash over that pie tin, you get the pumpkin pie. The pumpkin pie can be placed like a cake. Eating it will take out a 4th and give you 2.5 hearts each bite. It would be a nice balance between cake and golden apple. Made of a slightly more rare material: the pumpkin. Pumpkin patches are uncommon, but eggs, wheat, sugar, and milk can be found pretty much everywhere. Golden apple is as expensive as hell to get, either by crafting or by dungeon hunting. The pumpkin pie as i described it would be a nice balance.
Thanks. I wonder what other comments there will be.
inb4: "already suggested". Guess what: I don't care. It's been a while since the last one and pumpkin farming should bring a new use to pumpkins, because we'll have so many.
The Sun rises in the North!Now these points of data make a beautiful line...
Maybe like, 1.5 per bite, then?
Either way. Farmable pumpkins should give pumpkins more uses, otherwise: What's the point when you have glowstone and actual protective helmets? They should have more uses than decor, lighting, and silliness.
We don't. The main point is to suggest a new use that could be added for pumpkins.
Maybe he'll make pumpkin pies, or something else. The main point of this is to suggest something that could be added.
We don't know what he will add, but we just make suggestions for things he COULD add.
I'm sure a new use WILL be coming, but what it will be is a mystery. So we suggest what it could be.
it is said that the pumpkins are going to be farmable as of 1.8, and what would be the use of farming a block that is only for decoration. Generally speaking the items that don't have a purpose and rare, Therefore making them valuable in there own way: Bragging or SMP currency for example. Also decorating your house with common farmable blocks will not make it look better, because you want your build to be unique. Like mossy cobble and book cases. So if notch implements pumpkin farming then there would be even less of a point than there was before unless he implemented an Idea such as this along with it. So I support, however if they are farmable than to balence it out the pies would have to be expensive/ costly to make and heal lots or be cheap and not hel as much (obviously). So, I am fond of this idea.
Although it should be crafted like this in my opinion,
he probably will, it is the suggestion forums that give notch ideas on what things to add.
Here is one asking if it has been suggested but evry one replied to it as if it where a suggestion: http://www.minecraftforum.net/topic/516693-has-pumpkin-pie-ever-been-suggested-i-think-its-a-fairly-obvious-food-to-add-next/page__gopid__6811717#entry6811717