Zosyoung is very good at reading between the lines. And just if you guys didn't know lava bucket=could kill you
Trashcan=safe as a fly. So you tell me. I'm waiting for someone to come up with a better counterargument here rather than "use a lava bucket" or "make a lava disposal." its getting old typing the same thing over and over again. But I'm a trooper and will keep making answers to your guy's questions. ssssssssss
This reminds me of a suicide button topic. The only way you would need it is if you were extremely stupid. I guess that explains why you need it
think about possibilities for something old, but now able to be another unnecessary way.
Fixed
Quote from zosoyoung »
The point is that if there is a mod for it, then obviously somebody saw a use for it. I think with some creative contributions, (not trolling about things we already know) this idea could be pretty cool.
So your saying we should add guns and being able to craft diamonds out of gravel?
Wow, you see words that I didn't even know I wrote! That is exaaaactlyyy what i was saying.
think about possibilities for something old, but now able to be another unnecessary way.
Fixed
Quote from zosoyoung »
The point is that if there is a mod for it, then obviously somebody saw a use for it. I think with some creative contributions, (not trolling about things we already know) this idea could be pretty cool.
So your saying we should add guns and being able to craft diamonds out of gravel?
Wow, you see words that I didn't even know I wrote! That is exaaaactlyyy what i was saying.
I know, it's said that I have ESP *sarcasm returned*
I wondered why I kept on dying when I stood in a 1x2 ditch and dumped my bucket of lava in the square next to me...
THAT EXPLAINS EVERYTHING >_>.
OR... no.
Trash can is a redundant object with a suboptimal use.
That's like adding a flame thrower to light enemies on fire because the flint and steel is dangerous.
Here's a hint: You're playing a SURVIVAL game; surprisingly, more often than one would like to admit, the greatest opponent is oneself.
I don't want to be leashed because I'm a greater danger to myself than any skeleton, creeper, ghast, or lava spill. Instead of Notch taking time to program in idiot-proof solutions; why don't you stop being an idiot instead. It's a faster solution that saves you a great deal of stress in the long run.
I know, I know. It's a huge burden to have to USE your brain after you've had a long day of your hard-ass teacher going through triple digit multiplication and division with you; but I promise you, using your noodle may be much more effective than creating solutions for problems where the solution is ALREADY redundant.
Something being invented just to be "something new" isn't sufficient when there's a great thing already functioning in this capacity. Your argument is based on a changing notion, first that there isn't something that exists in this capacity, then later that there isn't something portable that exists in this capacity, and now that there isn't something new that exists in this capacity.
So you want us to come up with something new for your suggestion thread.
My answer is no, that's your job, which you should have done before making a thread.
I enjoy sarcasm. I take it to mind, and then guess who looks like the idiot? Not me posting a suggestion for a suicide button is completely unheard of! Out from space! you are obviously just trying to get some remarks so you can sleep at night. So in return i conclude that you are just commenting because of that and that you are not a expert of any kind on the topic at hand. in fact i believe that you don't really play mine craft at all. and that you are only on here to make peoples fell like crap because they came up with an idea that your brain couldn't think of!
I enjoy sarcasm. I take it to mind, and then guess who looks like the idiot? Not me posting a suggestion for a suicide button is completely unheard of! Out from space! you are obviously just trying to get some remarks so you can sleep at night. So in return i conclude that you are just commenting because of that and that you are not a expert of any kind on the topic at hand. in fact i believe that you don't really play mine craft at all. and that you are only on here to make peoples fell like crap because they came up with an idea that your brain couldn't think of!
I guess he's right. We aren't experts *note* in this case, expert=idiot.
Oh, and it's actually quite late. The only reason I'm on here is because I can't sleep. *not sarcasm*
Supporting arguments thus far:
1.) Portable
2.) Safe
3.) Easy to make
Responding arguments:
1.) All items in Minecraft are portable, including lava, cacti, etc.
2.) No safer than putting the items on the ground and forgetting them.
3.) Nothing is easier to make than the Q button.
And there you have a summary. If you want to keep flaming, don't. If you want to provide a few new reasons, then by all means go ahead and we shall see if they are valid.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Berginator94 »
I'm almost 100% positive that this have been suggested before but i'll suggest it again anyways
Ok so i got a good nights rest and and took all your comments to heart. well not really but anyway, All you people out there making stupid unneeded remarks about how "stupid" this idea is obviously think that a suggestions related posts is unneeded. SO everyone should stop giving suggestions because these "experts" disagree with the idea of adding something new.
Alright. I propose something new, then. I propose there be some sort of feature that allows the player to take whatever is in their hand or in their inventory, and take it out of their inventory. Like some way for the player to drop or throw the item they have so that it no longer takes up space. And then have another feature that takes these dropped items and deletes them after a set period of time. This completely unheard of idea would revolutionize Minecraft and would be completely portable.
well who wants there unwanted items to litter the map? plus it takes a fairly long time for them to actually disappear. Also if you walk back to the same spot you pick it back up. That's the flaw. I'm not saying that an incinerator is a bad unneeded thing, or that a lava bucket is not portable, I'm just suggesting an idea like a lot of other people on this site.
Instead of Notch taking time to program in idiot-proof solutions; why don't you stop being an idiot instead. It's a faster solution that saves you a great deal of stress in the long run.
I know, I know. It's a huge burden to have to USE your brain after you've had a long day of your hard-ass teacher going through triple digit multiplication and division with you; but I promise you, using your noodle may be much more effective than creating solutions for problems where the solution is ALREADY redundant.
Dude, take a chill pill. It's just an idea on a friendly forum.
Well all future plans for the game have to start somewhere. Why not here? I'm not being lazy by suggesting to make trashcans, i am simply asking for people who care about the future of minecraft to comment on the idea in a normal non hostile manner. obviously some people are incapable of doing that.
It may be slightly useful, maybe it will ever so slightly make the game better, but I don't think this would be worth the time of the developers. There are thousands of great updates people want, all better than this one. I'd have to say no.
It may be slightly useful, maybe it will ever so slightly make the game better, but I don't think this would be worth the time of the developers. There are thousands of great updates people want, all better than this one. I'd have to say no.
Again, thank you for talking like a human being
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Retired StaffThis reminds me of a suicide button topic. The only way you would need it is if you were extremely stupid. I guess that explains why you need it
Sig made by llama66613
Follow me on twitter
Wow, you see words that I didn't even know I wrote! That is exaaaactlyyy what i was saying.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Retired StaffI know, it's said that I have ESP *sarcasm returned*
Sig made by llama66613
Follow me on twitter
THAT EXPLAINS EVERYTHING >_>.
OR... no.
Trash can is a redundant object with a suboptimal use.
That's like adding a flame thrower to light enemies on fire because the flint and steel is dangerous.
Here's a hint: You're playing a SURVIVAL game; surprisingly, more often than one would like to admit, the greatest opponent is oneself.
I don't want to be leashed because I'm a greater danger to myself than any skeleton, creeper, ghast, or lava spill. Instead of Notch taking time to program in idiot-proof solutions; why don't you stop being an idiot instead. It's a faster solution that saves you a great deal of stress in the long run.
I know, I know. It's a huge burden to have to USE your brain after you've had a long day of your hard-ass teacher going through triple digit multiplication and division with you; but I promise you, using your noodle may be much more effective than creating solutions for problems where the solution is ALREADY redundant.
OFFICIAL POSTING/REPLYING GUIDELINES
UNOFFICIAL POSTING GUIDE (PRT)
UNOFFICIAL REPLYING GUIDE (FTC)
Alright how's this:
Something being invented just to be "something new" isn't sufficient when there's a great thing already functioning in this capacity. Your argument is based on a changing notion, first that there isn't something that exists in this capacity, then later that there isn't something portable that exists in this capacity, and now that there isn't something new that exists in this capacity.
So you want us to come up with something new for your suggestion thread.
My answer is no, that's your job, which you should have done before making a thread.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Retired StaffI guess he's right. We aren't experts *note* in this case, expert=idiot.
Oh, and it's actually quite late. The only reason I'm on here is because I can't sleep. *not sarcasm*
Sig made by llama66613
Follow me on twitter
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
Retired StaffAnd suddenly all of life's problems are solved.
Sig made by llama66613
Follow me on twitter
1.) Portable
2.) Safe
3.) Easy to make
Responding arguments:
1.) All items in Minecraft are portable, including lava, cacti, etc.
2.) No safer than putting the items on the ground and forgetting them.
3.) Nothing is easier to make than the Q button.
And there you have a summary. If you want to keep flaming, don't. If you want to provide a few new reasons, then by all means go ahead and we shall see if they are valid.
well who wants there unwanted items to litter the map? plus it takes a fairly long time for them to actually disappear. Also if you walk back to the same spot you pick it back up. That's the flaw. I'm not saying that an incinerator is a bad unneeded thing, or that a lava bucket is not portable, I'm just suggesting an idea like a lot of other people on this site.
Suggesting very insistently and getting upset with criticism.
The most portable and easy solution is to dig two blocks down, throw your **** in and cover it. Cheap and effective.
Dude, take a chill pill. It's just an idea on a friendly forum.
moving on!
I support Carrier Eagle
I support Power gloves
I support Coal Powered carts delay
Well thank you for not going on a rampage of personal attacks!
Pipes
Why?
Well pressing Q rapidly for 10 minutes is BORING!
It could have an interface like a chest and we could send all our useless dirt blocks to hell with a few clicks and in a few seconds.
Again, thank you for talking like a human being