If you don't know what it is you should probably go away.
Rather than be a toilet for bad suggestions, perhaps the subforum can be retooled to support a better way of keeping track of all of the good ideas and mega-threads (although they are AGAINST THE ****ING RULES).
This can be helped by making a sticky. No, not a sticky to home all of the shitty ideas that have been collected since 2009 (like the one we have now), perhaps a list of ideas that have a lot of effort put into them, that aren't just garbage (hey this is cool) ideas filled with a bunch of nobodies going "I AGREE " a hundred times and then sinking to the 500th page.
Another alternative is of course, is what Ygdrasel-sama and the others have stated before, banning tree-punchers and out-of-the-water posters from posting suggestions.
There have been 0 good suggestions from these people that have developed into good ideas. Let me repeat that to you. ZERO. ZILCH. ****ING BRUTAL Z TO THE E TO THE -RO, YO. Hell, most of them should spend more time reading stickied threads and commenting on good ideas rather than making threads here and then vanishing forever, or bumping their retarded idea with whining, or bumps.
"They can spend time in the Off-Topic section or the Forum games though!" and Griefers can use client-side cheats to avoid admins. So ****ing what. It will happen and there's nothing you can do.
And perhaps....we can get mods to actually pay attention to this forum? I know it's the honeypot to keep suggestions out of everywhere else of the forum, but what is the point of making a garbage dump on the forum that NOBODY ever ****ing monitors or looks at? All it does is take up bandwidth.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Ygdrasel »
Welcome to the forums, by the way. I'll be your brutally honest dream-crushing critic for...Well, your entire stay. So make your ideas good ones. [Diamond]
This can be helped by making a sticky. No, not a sticky to home all of the shitty ideas that have been collected since 2009 (like the one we have now)
:<
I try my best to not put shitty ideas on there...
Look at this ****. This does not look like you are trying hard. It's not even alphabetized or pruned yet.
Get to work, god damn it. Do something to renew all of the dumb-ass ideas or old ones that are old and rotten, into ones like GreyAcumen would make, the GOD OF MINECRAFT, EVEN DOMINATING NOTCH HIMSELF.
and other people that are of little importance.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Ygdrasel »
Welcome to the forums, by the way. I'll be your brutally honest dream-crushing critic for...Well, your entire stay. So make your ideas good ones. [Diamond]
We do however need more moderators which can direct new members, act quickly on troll threads and stop as many on site arguments possible. That being said the current moderators are not that bad either, but I hardly see fixes where they should be.
This can be helped by making a sticky. No, not a sticky to home all of the shitty ideas that have been collected since 2009 (like the one we have now)
:<
I try my best to not put shitty ideas on there...
Look at this ****. This does not look like you are trying hard. It's not even alphabetized or pruned yet.
Get to work, god damn it. Do something to renew all of the dumb-ass ideas or old ones that are old and rotten, into ones like GreyAcumen would make, the GOD OF MINECRAFT, EVEN DOMINATING NOTCH HIMSELF.
and other people that are of little importance.
Oh, shut up. Kira's got more sense than you. She doesn't need your help.
Good point about bad early posts (I'm sure you would know all about them.)
Mega-threads are within the rules, I think, as long as they have a central theme.
A thread with around 10 suggestions that aren't all in one theme, or revolved around a very vague theme tend to be very hard to discuss if you are talking about a singular idea in general.
Like a Half-block thread or a crafting thread or a plant thread. This involves way too many ideas in one area when they can be spread out easier and not hoarded. There are different ways to work with boomerangs or crossbows than just one thread where your suggestions may or may not affect the opening post in any way.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Ygdrasel »
Welcome to the forums, by the way. I'll be your brutally honest dream-crushing critic for...Well, your entire stay. So make your ideas good ones. [Diamond]
Shitlist: Krypton and LeDutchGuy
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
If you don't know what it is you should probably go away.
Rather than be a toilet for bad suggestions, perhaps the subforum can be retooled to support a better way of keeping track of all of the good ideas and mega-threads (although they are AGAINST THE ****ING RULES).
This can be helped by making a sticky. No, not a sticky to home all of the shitty ideas that have been collected since 2009 (like the one we have now), perhaps a list of ideas that have a lot of effort put into them, that aren't just garbage (hey this is cool) ideas filled with a bunch of nobodies going "I AGREE
Another alternative is of course, is what Ygdrasel-sama and the others have stated before, banning tree-punchers and out-of-the-water posters from posting suggestions.
There have been 0 good suggestions from these people that have developed into good ideas. Let me repeat that to you. ZERO. ZILCH. ****ING BRUTAL Z TO THE E TO THE -RO, YO. Hell, most of them should spend more time reading stickied threads and commenting on good ideas rather than making threads here and then vanishing forever, or bumping their retarded idea with whining, or bumps.
"They can spend time in the Off-Topic section or the Forum games though!" and Griefers can use client-side cheats to avoid admins. So ****ing what. It will happen and there's nothing you can do.
And perhaps....we can get mods to actually pay attention to this forum? I know it's the honeypot to keep suggestions out of everywhere else of the forum, but what is the point of making a garbage dump on the forum that NOBODY ever ****ing monitors or looks at? All it does is take up bandwidth.
Shitlist: Krypton and LeDutchGuy
Surely, more of an exception than a precedent; to be assured.
What we need is a moderator that is capable of simply locking threads and redirecting toward currently active threads.
OFFICIAL POSTING/REPLYING GUIDELINES
UNOFFICIAL POSTING GUIDE (PRT)
UNOFFICIAL REPLYING GUIDE (FTC)
In answer to the inevitable question: Yeah, I'm that egotistical. Sue me.
Seriously though. Need moderators.
Incompetence is a plague. I am the cure.
For all your wolf suggestion needs, I present the WOLF MEGATHREAD!
Stories: A Miner's Chronicle, The Lost Chronicle [Entries 32-2, 33-1, and 33-2 out!]
:<
I try my best to not put shitty ideas on there...
Look at this ****. This does not look like you are trying hard. It's not even alphabetized or pruned yet.
Get to work, god damn it. Do something to renew all of the dumb-ass ideas or old ones that are old and rotten, into ones like GreyAcumen would make, the GOD OF MINECRAFT, EVEN DOMINATING NOTCH HIMSELF.
and other people that are of little importance.
Shitlist: Krypton and LeDutchGuy
We do however need more moderators which can direct new members, act quickly on troll threads and stop as many on site arguments possible. That being said the current moderators are not that bad either, but I hardly see fixes where they should be.
Oh, shut up. Kira's got more sense than you. She doesn't need your help.
Incompetence is a plague. I am the cure.
For all your wolf suggestion needs, I present the WOLF MEGATHREAD!
Stories: A Miner's Chronicle, The Lost Chronicle [Entries 32-2, 33-1, and 33-2 out!]
Mega-threads are within the rules, I think, as long as they have a central theme.
Mostly moved on. May check back a few times a year.
A thread with around 10 suggestions that aren't all in one theme, or revolved around a very vague theme tend to be very hard to discuss if you are talking about a singular idea in general.
Like a Half-block thread or a crafting thread or a plant thread. This involves way too many ideas in one area when they can be spread out easier and not hoarded. There are different ways to work with boomerangs or crossbows than just one thread where your suggestions may or may not affect the opening post in any way.
Shitlist: Krypton and LeDutchGuy