As you and many others have said before, Minecraft is a sandbox. However, there is a large amount of discussion about what would be appropriate or not to add to Minecraft. (This thread is a great example) But, moving back to the sandbox topic, the most perfect sandbox would allow the player to do anything. While no sandbox will ever achieve this, arbitrarily setting ideas aside due to a perhaps game imbalance or "not Minecraft" feel can be avoided.
At least you gave reasons why they shouldn't be suggested.
* Modern Guns: Agreed. The only firearms I want to see are ones found in the ancient age. Even though I think the "Minecraft is Medieval" argument is stupid. Another reason I don't want to see modern guns in the game is you'll get wave after wave about how "unrealistic" the gun system is so in the end, nobody wins.
* Cars: Somewhat agreed. All I want is a pedal car which is basically a fragile boat on wheels.
* New Dimensions: Agreed. I think we should focus on improving our existing bland dimension first before touching another dimension idea. (I still like the Jurrasicraft idea)
* Herobrine: I didn't know people want a Herobrine AI to grief you in the game. The most I want is a cameo where he flickers and disappears at random places but that's it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Minecraft. The game where you can have fun building things, but only if you have fun like everyone else.*
If your referring to cars as a general means of transportation that doesn't need tracks: I like the idea of non-track requiring transportation, but if you mean actual cars, then yes, that's far to outside the theme (unless someone made it work really well within the minecraft world.)
i know your logic and understand but let people post what they want. when they post it give them CONSTRUCTIVE criticism on why the idea might not be the best and they should change it or abolish it
]i know your logic and understand but let people post what they want. when they post it give them CONSTRUCTIVE criticism on why the idea might not be the best and they should change it or abolish it
Constructive criticism only works if the idea is a constructive idea. If they just dump stupid ideas here and leave forever, or throw a fit because not everyone likes their pointless idea, it's nearly impossible (and somewhat pointless) to be constructive.
People still can post what they want, which is why this is a problem.
Also Kira remember that story you posted a while back? On how Minecraft has become came to be? It is futuristic and all? GmMkr can you post it as a subject to explain as no one knows what era Minecraft is set in? Like it could be set in anytime?
Thank you all!
REMEMBER SIG THIS!
Edit:
Also can u also put up no crappy titles? Like it has to be right to the point and has something to hold something specifically new and unique to catch reader's eyes.
BUMP!
Also Kira remember that story you posted a while back? On how Minecraft has become came to be? It is futuristic and all? GmMkr can you post it as a subject to explain as no one knows what era Minecraft is set in? Like it could be set in anytime?
NOTE: Half this list is common sense, the other half is pure opinion, like stats/achievements, that Notch already comfirmed. Seriously, that goes under the "already confirmed" category, you don't need to make a new category for it just because you don't like it. Also, obsidian tools. You basically just assumed that every suggestion for obsidian tools was to make them the most powerful in the game, and left it at that. Do you even actually read suggestion threads? Shame on you!
shame on you for thinking your comment deserves such big letters. Now your argument is halved. On the other half, don't talk about common sense in what people are posting, or have YOU not been reading the suggestions?
Anyone who says guns are too technologically advanced should be banned from using TNTs and redstone circuits. Guns predate these technologies by more than half a millennium.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Air-dropped bombs come in 3 flavours, distinguished by their intelligence: smart, dumb and retarded.
Anyone who says guns are too technologically advanced should be banned from using TNTs and redstone circuits. Guns predate these technologies by more than half a millennium.
Anyone who says guns are too technologically advanced should be banned from using TNTs and redstone circuits. Guns predate these technologies by more than half a millennium.
Oh shut up.
What's your reason behind it? NONE!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Air-dropped bombs come in 3 flavours, distinguished by their intelligence: smart, dumb and retarded.
Anyone who says guns are too technologically advanced should be banned from using TNTs and redstone circuits. Guns predate these technologies by more than half a millennium.
Guns do not predate explosives, and redstone isn't technology, per say. It's more of a magic/alchemic energy to fit Minecraft's pseudo-fantasy theme.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Berginator94 »
I'm almost 100% positive that this have been suggested before but i'll suggest it again anyways
Anyone who says guns are too technologically advanced should be banned from using TNTs and redstone circuits. Guns predate these technologies by more than half a millennium.
Guns do not predate explosives, and redstone isn't technology, per say. It's more of a magic/alchemic energy to fit Minecraft's pseudo-fantasy theme.
Unless you actually LIKE that idea.
What about something like this: viewtopic.php?f=1&t=225530
As you and many others have said before, Minecraft is a sandbox. However, there is a large amount of discussion about what would be appropriate or not to add to Minecraft. (This thread is a great example) But, moving back to the sandbox topic, the most perfect sandbox would allow the player to do anything. While no sandbox will ever achieve this, arbitrarily setting ideas aside due to a perhaps game imbalance or "not Minecraft" feel can be avoided.
* Modern Guns: Agreed. The only firearms I want to see are ones found in the ancient age. Even though I think the "Minecraft is Medieval" argument is stupid. Another reason I don't want to see modern guns in the game is you'll get wave after wave about how "unrealistic" the gun system is so in the end, nobody wins.
* Cars: Somewhat agreed. All I want is a pedal car which is basically a fragile boat on wheels.
* New Dimensions: Agreed. I think we should focus on improving our existing bland dimension first before touching another dimension idea. (I still like the Jurrasicraft idea)
* Herobrine: I didn't know people want a Herobrine AI to grief you in the game. The most I want is a cameo where he flickers and disappears at random places but that's it.
*Everyone else meaning me and me only.
EDIT: Remember to keep suggesting! I'm going to look through the posts for any suggestions I may have missed!
If your referring to cars as a general means of transportation that doesn't need tracks: I like the idea of non-track requiring transportation, but if you mean actual cars, then yes, that's far to outside the theme (unless someone made it work really well within the minecraft world.)
Constructive criticism only works if the idea is a constructive idea. If they just dump stupid ideas here and leave forever, or throw a fit because not everyone likes their pointless idea, it's nearly impossible (and somewhat pointless) to be constructive.
People still can post what they want, which is why this is a problem.
People sig this! Please!
Also Kira remember that story you posted a while back? On how Minecraft has become came to be? It is futuristic and all? GmMkr can you post it as a subject to explain as no one knows what era Minecraft is set in? Like it could be set in anytime?
Thank you all!
REMEMBER SIG THIS!
Edit:
Also can u also put up no crappy titles? Like it has to be right to the point and has something to hold something specifically new and unique to catch reader's eyes.
I don't remember that story anymore, sorry.
Oh shut up.
Incompetence is a plague. I am the cure.
For all your wolf suggestion needs, I present the WOLF MEGATHREAD!
Stories: A Miner's Chronicle, The Lost Chronicle [Entries 32-2, 33-1, and 33-2 out!]
What's your reason behind it? NONE!
Guns do not predate explosives, and redstone isn't technology, per say. It's more of a magic/alchemic energy to fit Minecraft's pseudo-fantasy theme.
^ Bam.
Incompetence is a plague. I am the cure.
For all your wolf suggestion needs, I present the WOLF MEGATHREAD!
Stories: A Miner's Chronicle, The Lost Chronicle [Entries 32-2, 33-1, and 33-2 out!]
The Biome/Environmental Update
Monkeys
Hedgehogs
Water temperatures