Hmm. I see your point, Mind. I was seeing the thread more as a "Anyone who suggests these is an idiot, trust me, I know better than you" thread than anything else. And that irked me since guns were lumped in with the nukes, diamond dropping mobs, and cars. If this thread is directed at the newer members, then I just made quite the ass of myself, haven't I? :]
Nope you are just expressing some reasonable concern.
---------------------------------
Yeah, what I hate is that people just make an account and start a new thread and sometimes a wishlist, without looking at the rules. That is why Ygd's thread to not let anyone below tree huggers be able to start a new thread (at least in suggestions) is not too bad of an idea.
1) it will help stimulate a lot more discussion in the community.
--- I see a lot of newbie posters start a thread and we never hear of them again, or that OP's do not take care of the thread. How does any of the above help the community, and thus the game?
---Really if Notch is going to make giant servers where we can all meet and play then we [MINECRAFT FORUM] will be representing that online community.
2) It will help for the senior members be more integrative
--- this is actually idealistic, but where I am getting this from is this: out of water posters will have to post in other forums and other people's threads to get that post count up. Yes if they are new they will be flamed still etc. for just saying I support or whatnot but there are still many people who are still helping them out. <--- not too well developed or explained right, I will another time lol headache
I know not all tree huggers are "newbs" and I have seen some today who are quite insightful. But fairness is fairness.
------------------
Also Mt.Popsicle... I really did not get your last statement... do you support this thread? Or what? Because originality and creativity is not the issue here. It is the rules.
Really anyone who has not been to this website or any other MC one and only talked with friends and played this game and could think up of duplicate ideas that were already on this thread shows their creativity. But this forum has been around for what? 2 years? more? People who just insta-post are not respecting this place.
This thread now weeds out new posters for original and unseen ideas.
-----------------
Lastly, NO DO NOT STICKY THIS THING!
Only when it is done or the tree hugger rule thing is implemented. A majority of new posters do not read stickied stuffs. We have it in our mind that threads that stay in the top are the most popular [duh] and thus we MUST READ IT [in a monotonous zombie like voice].
So for now we are fine. Also after a new update we will all go --- oh man! Now we do want nukes in the game [highly doubt it] So let us keep this thread moving up and down the page.
Yes I am aware we can still post in stickies but as I said a lot of newbies don't read them. This is enforce originality.
But I can be wrong. If enough people agree I will agree on this with them.
Topic updated. Glad you guys like the topic and support it. Please be sure to post more suggestions for me to add. I'll add them every time I have a chance to.
Also is Herobrine that ghost thing/ notch's brother? If it is confirmed it is not going to be in the game then put it up but idk anything about it. Soooo... why am I even replying lol
I realise that Adventure mode is a good thing and all, but I really hate it when there are suggestions that are just "We need adventure mode" could that be added to the OP? Mod equivalent: http://adventurecraft.wikkii.com/wiki/Main_Page (Couldn't find the forum page :tongue.gif:)
also add wishlists, telling notch what to do those type of things.
Also I think you should link to the stickies >.< People do not know what suggestions are.
Mmmm and is everyone in consensus with the Herobrine addition? I think it needs to be re-worded. Like what are the pros/cons with this thing [Herobrine]?
I agree for the most part, but I'm developing an idea for a new dimension that is unique from the others. I don't expect to to be in the game, I'm just doing it for fun (although I wouldn't mind it in the game).
I realise that Adventure mode is a good thing and all, but I really hate it when there are suggestions that are just "We need adventure mode" could that be added to the OP? Mod equivalent: http://adventurecraft.wikkii.com/wiki/Main_Page (Couldn't find the forum page :tongue.gif:)
I added not to suggest things that have already been approved to the topic. :tongue.gif:
Quote from Mindcraft2.0 »
also add wishlists, telling notch what to do those type of things.
Added.
Quote from Wave01 »
I agree for the most part, but I'm developing an idea for a new dimension that is unique from the others. I don't expect to to be in the game, I'm just doing it for fun (although I wouldn't mind it in the game).
If you truly feel that it's something unique and well thought out, then by all means, post.
Topic has been updated, I await your input and suggestions. :tongue.gif:
Nope you are just expressing some reasonable concern.
---------------------------------
Yeah, what I hate is that people just make an account and start a new thread and sometimes a wishlist, without looking at the rules. That is why Ygd's thread to not let anyone below tree huggers be able to start a new thread (at least in suggestions) is not too bad of an idea.
1) it will help stimulate a lot more discussion in the community.
--- I see a lot of newbie posters start a thread and we never hear of them again, or that OP's do not take care of the thread. How does any of the above help the community, and thus the game?
---Really if Notch is going to make giant servers where we can all meet and play then we [MINECRAFT FORUM] will be representing that online community.
2) It will help for the senior members be more integrative
--- this is actually idealistic, but where I am getting this from is this: out of water posters will have to post in other forums and other people's threads to get that post count up. Yes if they are new they will be flamed still etc. for just saying I support or whatnot but there are still many people who are still helping them out. <--- not too well developed or explained right, I will another time lol headache
I know not all tree huggers are "newbs" and I have seen some today who are quite insightful. But fairness is fairness.
------------------
Also Mt.Popsicle... I really did not get your last statement... do you support this thread? Or what? Because originality and creativity is not the issue here. It is the rules.
Really anyone who has not been to this website or any other MC one and only talked with friends and played this game and could think up of duplicate ideas that were already on this thread shows their creativity. But this forum has been around for what? 2 years? more? People who just insta-post are not respecting this place.
This thread now weeds out new posters for original and unseen ideas.
-----------------
Lastly, NO DO NOT STICKY THIS THING!
Only when it is done or the tree hugger rule thing is implemented. A majority of new posters do not read stickied stuffs. We have it in our mind that threads that stay in the top are the most popular [duh] and thus we MUST READ IT [in a monotonous zombie like voice].
So for now we are fine. Also after a new update we will all go --- oh man! Now we do want nukes in the game [highly doubt it] So let us keep this thread moving up and down the page.
Yes I am aware we can still post in stickies but as I said a lot of newbies don't read them. This is enforce originality.
But I can be wrong. If enough people agree I will agree on this with them.
I agree with it. Good point on do-not-sticky-this.
Lapis lazuli is!
Diamond ore doesn't drop 4-6 diamonds when you break it though, and isn't used only for dyes.
Lol. Already I saw way too many one those threads
Also is Herobrine that ghost thing/ notch's brother? If it is confirmed it is not going to be in the game then put it up but idk anything about it. Soooo... why am I even replying lol
I still support stopping tree huggers from posting.
What makes a difference in posting one idea now than later? It could be better later than now.
OFFICIAL POSTING/REPLYING GUIDELINES
UNOFFICIAL POSTING GUIDE (PRT)
UNOFFICIAL REPLYING GUIDE (FTC)
edit:
GmMkr,
also add wishlists, telling notch what to do those type of things.
Also I think you should link to the stickies >.< People do not know what suggestions are.
Mmmm and is everyone in consensus with the Herobrine addition? I think it needs to be re-worded. Like what are the pros/cons with this thing [Herobrine]?
The Biome/Environmental Update
Monkeys
Hedgehogs
Water temperatures
I am sure after the minecraft world is near perfected we will have nothing but alt dimensions to go to lol
the ruling is up for now. With the next update the rules may change as well.
I'm going to be out most of today, but when I get back, I'll update the opening post and reply to you all! Thanks for keeping this alive! ^-^
bumpity bump
I added not to suggest things that have already been approved to the topic. :tongue.gif:
Added.
If you truly feel that it's something unique and well thought out, then by all means, post.
Topic has been updated, I await your input and suggestions. :tongue.gif: