The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Location:
Ohio
Join Date:
5/4/2019
Posts:
47
Location:
Ohio
Xbox:
NORCALXxMrDxX
Member Details
Mostly just a realistic nit pick. Many will be against this idea mainly because of the over abundance of food in the game, but I will still suggest this assuming that one day Mojang updates the hunger system.
Sugar: Would only offer a half hunger bar, but would give a small increase of speed for ten seconds, and then slow you down for five seconds. This would demonstrate sugar highs.
Eggs: Would give a full hunger bar, but would have a chance of making you hunger sick.
Brown Mushrooms: Would give you a half hunger bar
Red Mushrooms: Would give you a half hunger bar, but would poison you similarly to getting poisoned from a pufferfish.
Pumpkin Seeds: Would give you half a hunger bar. Can be cooked for a full hunger bar
Cocoa Beans: Would give you half a hunger bar
Dandelions: Would give you half a hunger bar (dandelions are edible in real life, and are highly nutritious)
Only eggs i really only see being a good idea you should be able to cook the eggs. Mushrooms should just be useful for the stew and should stay in the crafting recipe for it and flowers shouldn't be edible i cant see that being a feature it's a decoration item. Eating sugar would remove the use of speed potions as everyone would eat sugar instead of making potions. Seeds shouldn't be food because you plant them for food.
Mostly just a realistic nit pick. Many will be against this idea mainly because of the over abundance of food in the game, but I will still suggest this assuming that one day Mojang updates the hunger system.
I would avoid using the term "realism" as a foundation on why should the suggestion be implemented into the game. Mostly because Minecraft isn't a realistic game.
Sugar: Would only offer a half hunger bar, but would give a small increase of speed for ten seconds, and then slow you down for five seconds. This would demonstrate sugar highs.
Seems pretty gimmicky considering I can do that with Suspicious Stew with the absence of slowing down debuff.
Eggs: Would give a full hunger bar, but would have a chance of making you hunger sick.
This item already has a preexisting right-click function (which is throwing).
Brown Mushrooms: Would give you a half hunger bar
Again, already has a preexisting right click function.
Red Mushrooms: Would give you a half hunger bar, but would poison you similarly to getting poisoned from a pufferfish.
Why would the Player want to eat that? Also, like the brown mushroom with the preexisting right click function.
Pumpkin Seeds: Would give you half a hunger bar. Can be cooked for a full hunger bar
Cocoa Beans: Would give you half a hunger bar
Dandelions: Would give you half a hunger bar (dandelions are edible in real life, and are highly nutritious)
Okay, pretty much the same criticism as above. The only reason why I see this being suggested is realism which is already a pretty weak foundation for a suggestion. Overall sorry but No Support.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Frist Dimension. 4th Dimension of Minecraft created through collaboration and brainstorming. Join now:
Mostly just a realistic nit pick. Many will be against this idea mainly because of the over abundance of food in the game, but I will still suggest this assuming that one day Mojang updates the hunger system.
Sugar: Would only offer a half hunger bar, but would give a small increase of speed for ten seconds, and then slow you down for five seconds. This would demonstrate sugar highs.
Eggs: Would give a full hunger bar, but would have a chance of making you hunger sick.
Brown Mushrooms: Would give you a half hunger bar
Red Mushrooms: Would give you a half hunger bar, but would poison you similarly to getting poisoned from a pufferfish.
Pumpkin Seeds: Would give you half a hunger bar. Can be cooked for a full hunger bar
Cocoa Beans: Would give you half a hunger bar
Dandelions: Would give you half a hunger bar (dandelions are edible in real life, and are highly nutritious)
A towel is about the most massively useful thing an interstellar hitchhiker could have.
Not a good idea tbh
When I thought minecraft forums was being archived I was mad I was told June 16th now its June16th and I'm still posting loL!
Only eggs i really only see being a good idea you should be able to cook the eggs. Mushrooms should just be useful for the stew and should stay in the crafting recipe for it and flowers shouldn't be edible i cant see that being a feature it's a decoration item. Eating sugar would remove the use of speed potions as everyone would eat sugar instead of making potions. Seeds shouldn't be food because you plant them for food.
I would avoid using the term "realism" as a foundation on why should the suggestion be implemented into the game. Mostly because Minecraft isn't a realistic game.
Seems pretty gimmicky considering I can do that with Suspicious Stew with the absence of slowing down debuff.
This item already has a preexisting right-click function (which is throwing).
Again, already has a preexisting right click function.
Why would the Player want to eat that? Also, like the brown mushroom with the preexisting right click function.
Okay, pretty much the same criticism as above. The only reason why I see this being suggested is realism which is already a pretty weak foundation for a suggestion. Overall sorry but No Support.
It sounds a little pointless but it also is logical. It could be handy in a pinch. I would support a suggestion like this.
I don't even play Minecraft much anymore yet here I am on the Minecraft forums for some reason...