Erbas and Rebas are two mysterious, traveling merchants who occasionally sell you items to help you on your way. Erbas is British and Rebas is American, see if you can figure out why. You're quite clever if you can. Obviously that's just made up due to the fact that there are no countries in Minecraft. Erbas rides a horse and Rebas rides a donkey with a chest. If you kill either one, they will pull out iron swords and begin to attack you. Once in a blue moon they will sell spawn eggs - if you attack them, the spawn eggs will "hatch" and attack you as well. So you'd better get out of there.
In short, they are powerful, useful merchants that are rarely seen and seem to disappear with the wind.
Seems like somewhat of a scrambled pot of ideas mashed into one, and therefore, not too Minecraft-ish. I assume these mobs are just traveling villagers? Regardless, what's to stop me from trapping them in some pit and making them my personal market?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Yeah, that guy in the avatar is me. I'm *that* strange. It happens. Sometimes people act like that. Just go with it. I can offer help with suggestions even before you post them - NOT make your suggestions - but help you with them.
Is no one going to question why Erbas and Rebas has possession over items that is only accessible in Creative Mode? Spawn Eggs are for creative use only if you want to spawn in a mob quickly for your own use. In no way should they be available for Survival. Another thing, there is no such thing as a Blue Moon in Minecraft, because if there was, we would have known at least one of the moon phases would have been called a Blue Moon.
Everything else that is stated is what I follow with as well.
I find your suggestion, vague, because you didn't said anything about the mobs Erbas and Rebas. Like for example.
How many are there health?
Are there rare to find?
What do they trade?
And how do they trade like emeralds? or gold?
(Those are some awesome names! by the way :D) Wait, wait if you kill the mob Erbas and Rebas they will pull out an iron sword? So you mean the Erbas and Rebas will try to kill the player, even if there dead? Please tell us more about this "Blue moon" Will it effect mob spawn rate?
So you are suggesting mobs that sell Creative only items? Wouldn't this be abused by players using hostile mobs as trolling items? Also what are these spawn eggs? you mean they sell every mob, exept the Wither the Ender dragon and the utility mobs.
Overall. NO SUPPORT (Sorry it's because it was vague and kinda weird. (To offence) )
Seems like somewhat of a scrambled pot of ideas mashed into one, and therefore, not too Minecraft-ish. I assume these mobs are just traveling villagers? Regardless, what's to stop me from trapping them in some pit and making them my personal market?
Is no one going to question why Erbas and Rebas has possession over items that is only accessible in Creative Mode? Spawn Eggs are for creative use only if you want to spawn in a mob quickly for your own use. In no way should they be available for Survival. Another thing, there is no such thing as a Blue Moon in Minecraft, because if there was, we would have known at least one of the moon phases would have been called a Blue Moon.
Everything else that is stated is what I follow with as well.
No support.
I don't see why they shouldn't be accessible for survival.
And yes, there are blue moons in Minecraft. A blue moon is the opposite of a full moon, i.e. when you cannot see the moon.
I don't see why they shouldn't be accessible for survival.
And yes, there are blue moons in Minecraft. A blue moon is the opposite of a full moon, i.e. when you cannot see the moon.
I think spawn eggs, providing that they are ridiculously rare, would be fine in Survival mode.
And a blue moon is 2 full moons in one month, a rare event. What you are describing is a new moon, which happens frequently in Minecraft. So you essentially made it possible to farm spawn eggs.
Seems like somewhat of a scrambled pot of ideas mashed into one, and therefore, not too Minecraft-ish. I assume these mobs are just traveling villagers? Regardless, what's to stop me from trapping them in some pit and making them my personal market?
It's a pun on their names that no one has seemed to figure out yet.
I don't see why they shouldn't be accessible for survival.
And yes, there are blue moons in Minecraft. A blue moon is the opposite of a full moon, i.e. when you cannot see the moon.
Spawn eggs could mean more precise mob farms. I'd buy a witch spawn egg for a cobweb potion farm.
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Location:
Boise, Idaho
Join Date:
11/26/2014
Posts:
283
Location:
Boise, Idaho
Minecraft:
miner49er876
Member Details
Since they like to use obscure phrases in their suggestion, I will use one in my review.
Maybe this will be added, maybe when the king comes back.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Someone once said, in defense of a poorly thought out suggestion that was not being supported: "Theres so much awesome and rare things to add and youre just like, oh , thats too good, no, i want something common like a grass block"
Considering the elytra isn't real flight, more of a glide, then I would most definitely support it if it were balanced.
Spawn eggs spawn mobs. What can stop you from trapping them and getting as many spawn eggs as you can get? Nothing.
He said in some other post (Not defending him for not including it in the OT) That they would despawn eventually. Also, I'm sure that it would be rather expensive to buy these. He also said that they don't sell them often.
No that is a new moon. A blue moon is the rare event where a second full moon appears within a month, or an extra full moon appears in a season (3 or 4 depending on the season). Hence the phrase "once in a blue moon". If it meant a new moon as you think it does that phrase would basically mean something that happens fairly regularly.
As much as I enjoy discussing idioms and phrases, that isn't why we are here. I have to agree with the first person who said this is both vague and too specific at the same time, but that is more because you decided to give them pretend names for some kind of history or geography pun and then not give us a lot of detail on what all they do. They ride animals, sell... stuff (the only thing we got was "spawn eggs, sometimes"), and attack if they are attacked. We don't care about the pun, we care about the idea's details.
What is the health of these guys? What else do they trade and how much do things cost? Where can they be found and how often can they be found? Do they just look like Villagers, and if they do, how do they hold weapons with no actual hands?
Also, call me crazy but I think the ability to summon something like a Ghast in someone's house or a Creeper right at someone's feet is a little unfair, especially if the odds of seeing these guys is random. But that depends on the cost.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
Still, a creeper spawn egg can cause damage, even if it is a temporary spawn.
And that information needs to be in the OP. If this thread was, say, 4 or 5 pages long, no one wants to go to another page to find information that was already posted but not in the OP.
I know, the info should have been in the OP, but I'm just telling you that its still present. Also, a creeper spawn egg would only cause damage if the user was griefing. Which, really isn't that bad, considering that they can just get TnT, and cause more damage.
Hey.
Erbas and Rebas are two mysterious, traveling merchants who occasionally sell you items to help you on your way. Erbas is British and Rebas is American, see if you can figure out why. You're quite clever if you can. Obviously that's just made up due to the fact that there are no countries in Minecraft. Erbas rides a horse and Rebas rides a donkey with a chest. If you kill either one, they will pull out iron swords and begin to attack you. Once in a blue moon they will sell spawn eggs - if you attack them, the spawn eggs will "hatch" and attack you as well. So you'd better get out of there.
In short, they are powerful, useful merchants that are rarely seen and seem to disappear with the wind.
Thanks.
Vague, too specific, doesn't fit with the theme of minecraft.
No Support.
Oxymoron much?
But yes, this is rather vague. We need some hard stats here. I'd be willing to Support though, as soon as the idea is fleshed out a bit.
Seems like an interesting idea, bit it's too vague. No Support for now.
Seems like somewhat of a scrambled pot of ideas mashed into one, and therefore, not too Minecraft-ish. I assume these mobs are just traveling villagers? Regardless, what's to stop me from trapping them in some pit and making them my personal market?
Yeah, that guy in the avatar is me. I'm *that* strange. It happens. Sometimes people act like that. Just go with it. I can offer help with suggestions even before you post them - NOT make your suggestions - but help you with them.
Unofficial Suggestions Guide (2.0) - by Theriasis
Unofficial Critics Guide - by yoshi9048
Yeah, but why should someone make them british and american? In minecraft the Britain and the USA don't exist...
Is no one going to question why Erbas and Rebas has possession over items that is only accessible in Creative Mode? Spawn Eggs are for creative use only if you want to spawn in a mob quickly for your own use. In no way should they be available for Survival. Another thing, there is no such thing as a Blue Moon in Minecraft, because if there was, we would have known at least one of the moon phases would have been called a Blue Moon.
Everything else that is stated is what I follow with as well.
No support.
I find your suggestion, vague, because you didn't said anything about the mobs Erbas and Rebas. Like for example.
How many are there health?
Are there rare to find?
What do they trade?
And how do they trade like emeralds? or gold?
(Those are some awesome names! by the way :D) Wait, wait if you kill the mob Erbas and Rebas they will pull out an iron sword? So you mean the Erbas and Rebas will try to kill the player, even if there dead? Please tell us more about this "Blue moon" Will it effect mob spawn rate?
So you are suggesting mobs that sell Creative only items? Wouldn't this be abused by players using hostile mobs as trolling items? Also what are these spawn eggs? you mean they sell every mob, exept the Wither the Ender dragon and the utility mobs.
Overall. NO SUPPORT (Sorry it's because it was vague and kinda weird. (To offence) )
Once in a blue moon is an idiom meaning Once in a while
Checkout my mod about Craftable End Portal frames!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/mapping-and-modding/minecraft-mods/2656035-craftable-end-portal-frames
Check out my YT Channel https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCaJyJFtI-BkO1a2OJTZbofw Please subscribe and like my vidz!
They disappear into the wind.
It's a pun on their names that no one has seemed to figure out yet.
I don't see why they shouldn't be accessible for survival.
And yes, there are blue moons in Minecraft. A blue moon is the opposite of a full moon, i.e. when you cannot see the moon.
I think spawn eggs, providing that they are ridiculously rare, would be fine in Survival mode.
And a blue moon is 2 full moons in one month, a rare event. What you are describing is a new moon, which happens frequently in Minecraft. So you essentially made it possible to farm spawn eggs.
They could despawn after three days.
Spawn eggs could mean more precise mob farms. I'd buy a witch spawn egg for a cobweb potion farm.
Why not? Be more open-minded. If you saw a suggestion for Elytra before 1.9 on here, what would you have said?
Since they like to use obscure phrases in their suggestion, I will use one in my review.
Maybe this will be added, maybe when the king comes back.
Someone once said, in defense of a poorly thought out suggestion that was not being supported: "Theres so much awesome and rare things to add and youre just like, oh , thats too good, no, i want something common like a grass block"
He said in some other post (Not defending him for not including it in the OT) That they would despawn eventually. Also, I'm sure that it would be rather expensive to buy these. He also said that they don't sell them often.
No that is a new moon. A blue moon is the rare event where a second full moon appears within a month, or an extra full moon appears in a season (3 or 4 depending on the season). Hence the phrase "once in a blue moon". If it meant a new moon as you think it does that phrase would basically mean something that happens fairly regularly.
As much as I enjoy discussing idioms and phrases, that isn't why we are here. I have to agree with the first person who said this is both vague and too specific at the same time, but that is more because you decided to give them pretend names for some kind of history or geography pun and then not give us a lot of detail on what all they do. They ride animals, sell... stuff (the only thing we got was "spawn eggs, sometimes"), and attack if they are attacked. We don't care about the pun, we care about the idea's details.
What is the health of these guys? What else do they trade and how much do things cost? Where can they be found and how often can they be found? Do they just look like Villagers, and if they do, how do they hold weapons with no actual hands?
Also, call me crazy but I think the ability to summon something like a Ghast in someone's house or a Creeper right at someone's feet is a little unfair, especially if the odds of seeing these guys is random. But that depends on the cost.
Want some advice on how to thrive in the Suggestions section? Check this handy list of guidelines and tips for posting your ideas and responding to the ideas of others!
http://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-discussion/suggestions/2775557-guidelines-for-the-suggestions-forum
I know, the info should have been in the OP, but I'm just telling you that its still present. Also, a creeper spawn egg would only cause damage if the user was griefing. Which, really isn't that bad, considering that they can just get TnT, and cause more damage.
No support
You're supposed to say why you don't support, otherwise it's basically spam.