I have a few ideas for Minecraft.
#1: Craftable chain-mail. I hate having to use my invedit.
#2: No placing blocks directly below you. Sorry guys. I think pillaring is very "noobish".
#3: More gravity affected blocks. I think dirt should defenetly by gravity effected.
#4: A use for slime-balls. For killing a few of these motherf*ckers and getting slimeballs, you should at least be able to use them.
#5:You should be able to make bones into a bone armor. I imagine it would be weaker than iron but stronger than leather.
#6:Torches should only generate level 13 light instead of fourteen. Gives it a more natural feel.
#7: Injures should slow you down. This means getting injured by an explosion should slow you down as if you could be injured in sections.
#8: Saddles should be able to work on cows.
#9: Shears tool that gets more wool from sheep without hurting them. Look at crafting recipe below.
#10:Less redstone, more diamond. I don't think this would appeal to everyone but it would be more useful.
Keep on adding guys! I'll try to edit this post as much as possible to incorporate the ideas you have suggested.
Recipe:
[]
[] []
[]
There ya go!
1,okay
2,how would you build up? you would have to make stairs but why make the game harder?
3,maybe more physics enabled blocks but dirt is a no-no
4,think of an idea before posting
5,cool, i like it.
6, erm, i dunno. It is the only accesible light source. Your houses would be even darker.
7, maybe, but it might be irritating.
8, It is still pointless as you can't controll them
9,what's the matter with hurting them? But, You can always use a fishing rod, no damage.
10, Diamonds are supposed to be rare and people need lot's of redstone for wires.
just my opinions.
Just to prove i'm not a "whiny little brat or a elven year old", I understand that constructive criticism is ok. I'm not whiny nor a brat but I have mis-stated something. I mean positive as in not insulting me or my ideas but just providing constructive criticism. Please just understand that...
Just to prove i'm not a "whiny little brat or a elven year old", I understand that constructive criticism is ok. I'm not whiny nor a brat but I have mis-stated something. I mean positive as in not insulting me or my ideas but just providing constructive criticism. Please just understand that...
If your ideas suck, they will be insulted. If you take personal offense to that feedback, you will be insulted.
Edit the first post, scroll down to poll creation.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Baraq Hussein Osama »
Do you show children your phallus? Is that what you want them to see?
Thanks for the poll thing but insulting is different from constructive criticism. Insulting is for the sole purpose of hurting someone else's feelings. Constructive criticism will have suggestions on how to make it better. Also. Not a wishlist. This is something for everyone to expand on. Where are those ideas?!?!?
Thanks for the poll thing but insulting is different from constructive criticism. Insulting is for the sole purpose of hurting someone else's feelings. Constructive criticism will have suggestions on how to make it better. Also. Not a wishlist. This is something for everyone to expand on. Where are those ideas?!?!?
Terrible suggestions cannot be made better. And this IS a wishlist.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from Baraq Hussein Osama »
Do you show children your phallus? Is that what you want them to see?
#1: Craftable chain-mail. I hate having to use my invedit.
Could happen. I doubt it. Proposing alternative armour is tricky. Simplicity is the name of the game. Sorry, Minecraft is the name of the game, but simplicity is important to Minecraft. There are other games with loads of different types of armour.
There might, just might, be room for more armour types, like chainmail, bone mail, rubber armour (my suggestion), wood armour, wool armour... But for each type of armour suggested, there needs to be justification for why that armour and not every other possible armour.
#2: No placing blocks directly below you. Sorry guys. I think pillaring is very "noobish".
I'm not a fan of this suggestion. Also, what constitutes "directly below" when you're over top of multiple blocks?
#3: More gravity affected blocks. I think dirt should defenetly by gravity effected.
Maybe, but I don't want to lose the ability to craft in the air. This ability sort of defines Minecraft.
#4: A use for slime-balls. For killing a few of these motherf*ckers and getting slimeballs, you should at least be able to use them.
Be patient. It's coming. In the meantime, how about making an actual suggestion. One suggestion per thread, please.
#5:You should be able to make bones into a bone armor. I imagine it would be weaker than iron but stronger than leather.
See #1
#6:Torches should only generate level 13 light instead of fourteen. Gives it a more natural feel.
Doesn't make a difference to me.
#7: Injures should slow you down. This means getting injured by an explosion should slow you down as if you could be injured in sections.
I think this could work for a realism mode.
#8: Saddles should be able to work on cows.
I guess. I don't go around riding pigs all that often, and I don't think I'd ride cows much either.
#9: Shears tool that gets more wool from sheep without hurting them. Look at crafting recipe below.
This is not a bad suggestion. But a lot of people have also suggested this. My suggestion for you is to go and find one of those threads and bump it. Post your recipe in one of those threads. (And just between you and me, avoid the Farmcraft thread.)
#10:Less redstone, more diamond. I don't think this would appeal to everyone but it would be more useful.
I don't think this is a good idea.
EDIT: PLease don't comment unless you are contributing POSITIVELY!
Yeah... are you aware where you are posting?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I think you are going to love my Survival Let's Play series on YouTube! It's called Spaceboot1's Garden. I make pretty things.
I have a few ideas for Minecraft.
#1: Craftable chain-mail. I hate having to use my invedit.
#2: No placing blocks directly below you. Sorry guys. I think pillaring is very "noobish".
#3: More gravity affected blocks. I think dirt should defenetly by gravity effected.
#4: A use for slime-balls. For killing a few of these motherf*ckers and getting slimeballs, you should at least be able to use them.
#5:You should be able to make bones into a bone armor. I imagine it would be weaker than iron but stronger than leather.
#6:Torches should only generate level 13 light instead of fourteen. Gives it a more natural feel.
#7: Injures should slow you down. This means getting injured by an explosion should slow you down as if you could be injured in sections.
#8: Saddles should be able to work on cows.
#9: Shears tool that gets more wool from sheep without hurting them. Look at crafting recipe below.
#10:Less redstone, more diamond. I don't think this would appeal to everyone but it would be more useful.
#11: Exploding arrow. Maybe a recipe with an arrow and a piece of TNT and redstone.
#12: Mirror. Haven't you always wanted to see steve? It should reflect light as well but it should get weaker with every reflection.
Keep on adding guys! I'll try to edit this post as much as possible to incorporate the ideas you have suggested.
Recipe:
[]
[] []
[]
There ya go!
EDIT: PLease don't comment unless you are contributing POSITIVELY!
1. No, that would ruin the game. It is not obtainable for a reason, it would unbalance everything. 2. Why not? Pillaring is perfectly fine and usefull. 3. It could, but it woudn't serve much of a purpose and it would make natural overhangs obsolete. Making MineCraft less intesting. 4. They will be used eventualy, Notch has said they will have a purpose. 5. NO. It would be realy cheap, that would make hide armor irrelevant. Cloth armor that is 1/2 armor point for each garmet and can be diffrent colors is more reasonable. 6. MineCraft is not suppost to be natural, besides, that would screw 100,000+ player's mines worldwide because their efficent torch method is now obsolete. 7. I think that if you take fall damage from a considerable height you slowdown. But the way you launch away from the hit is usefull because it gives that person a chance to live. 8. Sure, it could use more uses. 9. Nah, it would have little to no purpose if we could still punch the sheep to get wool. Very irrelevant. 10. No, that is completely unreasonable! 11. Mabie, I don't think it should have a big radius. 3X3 or 2X2 at max. 12. That can't work in MineCraft's engine.
Over all the OP is wrong.
MineCraft: Where simple things can do a thousand more.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I was the second person to use the avatar I have. The rest took it from me. The first I asked, he said yes.
I know what I'm doing. I plan ahead, or get tired and screw up everything.
I stated again that I meant to say constructive criticism.
The two who have posted above this post are giving reasonable feedback. This is what I want.
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
2/27/2011
Posts:
50
Member Details
Um. On your 12th "Idea"... You can already see Steve, or your character in the inventory. Also, mirrors have already been suggested.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Hold on to cliffs suggestion: viewtopic.php?f=1&t=318707
[url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=309255][/url]
[url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1018&t=149179#Alpha][/url]url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1018&t=149179#Lumberjack][/url][url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1018&t=149179#SMP][/url]
You can't make mirrors because that would require rendering the entire Minecraft world in the mirror. Also, it has been suggested many times. Don't repost ideas that are already suggested. This IS wishlist, as it's just a list of things you want to be in Minecraft that aren't linked in any way.
You can't make mirrors because that would require rendering the entire Minecraft world in the mirror. Also, it has been suggested many times. Don't repost ideas that are already suggested. This IS wishlist, as it's just a list of things you want to be in Minecraft that aren't linked in any way.
C'mon. I started this thread with good intent. I don't want people saying negative things about something that causes no harm.
No Wishlist
No overly suggested topics
This broke the rules.
No overly suggested topics
This broke the rules.[/quote]
Why do you care. If you don't have anything POSITIVE (see top) just don't contribute.
1,okay
2,how would you build up? you would have to make stairs but why make the game harder?
3,maybe more physics enabled blocks but dirt is a no-no
4,think of an idea before posting
5,cool, i like it.
6, erm, i dunno. It is the only accesible light source. Your houses would be even darker.
7, maybe, but it might be irritating.
8, It is still pointless as you can't controll them
9,what's the matter with hurting them? But, You can always use a fishing rod, no damage.
10, Diamonds are supposed to be rare and people need lot's of redstone for wires.
just my opinions.
Why do you care. If you don't have anything POSITIVE (see top) just don't contribute.[/quote]
If it were only positive feedback then what would the point of these threads be. I am guessing you are 11 and got your feelings hurt...just go away.
Mod edit: User warned for flaming
Why do you care. If you don't have anything POSITIVE (see top) just don't contribute.[/quote]
I'm informing you of some rules... so you can HAVE positive feedback
All of that WAS positive, you whiny little brat. It's telling you what you did wrong.
If your ideas suck, they will be insulted. If you take personal offense to that feedback, you will be insulted.
Edit the first post, scroll down to poll creation.
...but you cannot, because there are WAY too many suggestions.
Please avoid making wishlists in the future.
Terrible suggestions cannot be made better. And this IS a wishlist.
Could happen. I doubt it. Proposing alternative armour is tricky. Simplicity is the name of the game. Sorry, Minecraft is the name of the game, but simplicity is important to Minecraft. There are other games with loads of different types of armour.
There might, just might, be room for more armour types, like chainmail, bone mail, rubber armour (my suggestion), wood armour, wool armour... But for each type of armour suggested, there needs to be justification for why that armour and not every other possible armour.
I'm not a fan of this suggestion. Also, what constitutes "directly below" when you're over top of multiple blocks?
Maybe, but I don't want to lose the ability to craft in the air. This ability sort of defines Minecraft.
Be patient. It's coming. In the meantime, how about making an actual suggestion. One suggestion per thread, please.
See #1
Doesn't make a difference to me.
I think this could work for a realism mode.
I guess. I don't go around riding pigs all that often, and I don't think I'd ride cows much either.
This is not a bad suggestion. But a lot of people have also suggested this. My suggestion for you is to go and find one of those threads and bump it. Post your recipe in one of those threads. (And just between you and me, avoid the Farmcraft thread.)
I don't think this is a good idea.
Yeah... are you aware where you are posting?
Want to play Minecraft SSP like Spaceboot1? Try my modpack, all mods made by me, Spaceboot1!
1. No, that would ruin the game. It is not obtainable for a reason, it would unbalance everything.
2. Why not? Pillaring is perfectly fine and usefull.
3. It could, but it woudn't serve much of a purpose and it would make natural overhangs obsolete. Making MineCraft less intesting.
4. They will be used eventualy, Notch has said they will have a purpose.
5. NO. It would be realy cheap, that would make hide armor irrelevant. Cloth armor that is 1/2 armor point for each garmet and can be diffrent colors is more reasonable.
6. MineCraft is not suppost to be natural, besides, that would screw 100,000+ player's mines worldwide because their efficent torch method is now obsolete.
7. I think that if you take fall damage from a considerable height you slowdown. But the way you launch away from the hit is usefull because it gives that person a chance to live.
8. Sure, it could use more uses.
9. Nah, it would have little to no purpose if we could still punch the sheep to get wool. Very irrelevant.
10. No, that is completely unreasonable!
11. Mabie, I don't think it should have a big radius. 3X3 or 2X2 at max.
12. That can't work in MineCraft's engine.
Over all the OP is wrong.
MineCraft: Where simple things can do a thousand more.
I was the second person to use the avatar I have. The rest took it from me. The first I asked, he said yes.
I know what I'm doing. I plan ahead, or get tired and screw up everything.
The two who have posted above this post are giving reasonable feedback. This is what I want.
[url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=309255][/url]
[url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1018&t=149179#Alpha][/url]url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1018&t=149179#Lumberjack][/url][url=http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=1018&t=149179#SMP][/url]
Edit: The poll is completely unrelated.
I'm using it's results to base more ideas off of.