So..... Your saying he didn't want to add items? Obviously you have'nt read the Ip and are mindlessly trolling.
0/10
I haven't said anything about not adding items, I'm just saying that it's not needed to make the Pig controllable.
So you're accusing me for trolling, ehh? That is so mature, did you think that up all by yourself?
In that thread he wanted to add 5+ items to the game. To get horses to work you just add horses. In case you have'nt noticed Pigs are not controllable, and were put in the game as a test. They are going to stay uncontrollable.
I rode a pig once, said that's kind of funny, then never did it again. If I could ride a horse to move faster I would do it more. Riding a pig is just stupid. It is.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
So is throwing an egg that hatches and spawns a chicken when it hits it's target. Punching down a tree and building a wooden pickaxe to mine stone is also very stupid, but that's the way Minecraft is supposed to be.
Prove it. How would pigs be better then horses? In no way. Horses give us another mob, which is better, also give us a ride-able mob, that we can control.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
Muncher every thread I've seen you commenting on were comments on how bad the idea was. Why don't you just come up with your own ideas if you're not happy? And I think thief be interesting. I think a large variety of creepers would be nice and I could get some lols out of this.
Anyways to the above, most ideas don't add anything to gameplay and or what they do add hurts gameplay.
But I do like threads that add good things to gameplay. If you look at the aether thread, the more arrows thread, the floracraft thread, the 2X2 crafting table thread, the art of war thread, and the Ghoul thread are all thread I like.
So stop saying I dislike all ideas because your wrong.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
So is throwing an egg that hatches and spawns a chicken when it hits it's target. Punching down a tree and building a wooden pickaxe to mine stone is also very stupid, but that's the way Minecraft is supposed to be.
Prove it. How would pigs be better then horses? In no way. Horses give us another mob, which is better, also give us a ride-able mob, that we can control.
yeah, but why a horse? what if giving a pig a brown mushroom while riding it let you control it, and a red mushroom makes it go faster? Then not only do you have a rideable controllable mob without adding any new blocks/mobs, but it also introduces balance to the feature, since the mushrooms would effectively act as fuel so you don't just get an infinite boost.
I cannot support riding a pig. Sounds way to dumb to me. Pigs can barely carry their own weight, and defiantly not a rider. It's to stupid to me.
Even then, this is minecraft. No, that isn't a catchall to be completely illogical, but there's no reason to insist that the "pigs" in minecraft must only be as capable for riding as what YOU think is realistic. It's silly, so what? Why must minecraft be so godam serious?
I cannot support riding a pig. Sounds way to dumb to me. Pigs can barely carry their own weight, and defiantly not a rider. It's to stupid to me.
Even then, this is minecraft. No, that isn't a catchall to be completely illogical, but there's no reason to insist that the "pigs" in minecraft must only be as capable for riding as what YOU think is realistic. It's silly, so what? Why must minecraft be so godam serious?
Even if minecraft "shouldn't be so serious" (It should, but all you 13 year olds want it to be all happy funland) the pig idea, and this one, both are not useful to gameplay and are extremely overpowered.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
I'm 26 and I still don't think minecraft should become overly serious, for the same reason I don't want guns and high technology. Both put serious dampers on creativity and creative strategies, and neither fits the tone already established by current Minecraft conventions:
1) the splash screen messages which are the very first thing you see in the game and set the tone thereafter; they are silly
2) the way the player character and other mobs move
3) you can already ride pigs
4) you can stick a jackolantern on your head.
5) you can hatch chickens from eggs by throwing the eggs
6) you can't die permanently
7) peaceful mode
8) zombie pigmen
9) breaking trees (or any block for that matter) with your fists
10) you can swim in lava provide you are carrying enough grilled meat with you (same for avoiding drowning in water)
11) you can eat raw pig meat and not get sick
12) you can fire a bow like a machine gun
13) you can make a suit of armor entirely out of diamonds
14) you get records from creepers
15) you can carry lava in a bucket
16) you get feathers from zombies
17) you can send a mob into space using enough TNT and a minecart
18) wooden tools
19) exploding green penises (had to toss that one in somewhere)
20) mobs can get captured by minecarts
21) you can survive a fall from any height as long as you're in a boat/minecart
22) furnaces can run on lava
23) punch ghast bombs back at them
24) TNT = Gunpowder and Sand
25) you can swim up waterfalls
I could go on, but I think I'll stop the list here. You may claim every single one of those ideas as being things that need fixed, but if that's the case, it only proves my point more when I say that you're wrong about how serious minecraft is supposed to be.
And the pig idea I came up with is LESS overpowered than your horse idea, and adds just as much to the gameplay without needing to actually ADD any real content other than some code.
That one makes sense actually. Nobel was almost going out of business, because nobody wanted to buy the TNT, because it had a nasty tendency to blow you up randomly. The company was saved when he figured out the TNT became more stable if absorbed into a type of mineral found on the bottom of the ocean. Sand is the closest thing we have to that mineral.
In fact, the thing that doesn't make sense about that crafting recipe, is that sulfur (the official name for gunpowder, according to the tooltips), is used to make TNT (tri-NITROtoluene)
Though I do agree on the pigs instead of horses thing.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
You have just started
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading
19) exploding green penises (had to toss that one in somewhere)
I don't get how people see this. I just don't.....
More then half of those are just things notch put in as place holders until he could put in something that made sense.
Like the zombie feather thing.
Chickens had yet to be added so there was no way for the player to get feathers.
Also most of the stuff put in there wasn't "silly" just nonsensical or easy.
I just think horses would add more mobs, making the ecosystem larger and make more sense.
Which brings me to another point.
Alot of the thing you put on that list were things that didn't make sense, not silly things.
Like the wood tools Those don't make sense but are'nt "silly"
but you are in favor of riding pigs, which makes almost no sense at all.
I don't get how you people like the idea of riding pigs. It makes no sense to me.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
I'm just throwing this out there, but pigs (and sheep) are the only passive mob(s) with only one use.
Cow:
Leather
Milk
Chicken:
Feather
Egg
Pig:
Pork Pushing you off of cliffs
Sheep:
Wool
If we added transportation to pigs, and made sheep drop something when killed, then each mob would have 2 uses, one that required you to kill it, and one that would not.
Now, I do believe this thread has become quite de-railed.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
You have just started
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading
I'm just throwing this out there, but pigs (and sheep) are the only passive mob(s) with only one use.
Cow:
Leather
Milk
Chicken:
Feather
Egg
Pig:
Pork Pushing you off of cliffs
Sheep:
Wool
If we added transportation to pigs, and made sheep drop something when killed, then each mob would have 2 uses, one that required you to kill it, and one that would not.
Now, I do believe this thread has become quite de-railed.
See? this is can get. This makes more sense.
I don't think the thread matters, the OP seems to be gone.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
Here is my professional opinion:
It won't get into the main game, but once prefix mobs are added this will be easy to mod.
And there are people who will use it if it is a mod.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
I once saw a chicken push a creeper off of a cliff. I never looked at chickens the same way ever again. That is of course until I needed feathers.
0/10
In that thread he wanted to add 5+ items to the game. To get horses to work you just add horses. In case you have'nt noticed Pigs are not controllable, and were put in the game as a test. They are going to stay uncontrollable.
I rode a pig once, said that's kind of funny, then never did it again. If I could ride a horse to move faster I would do it more. Riding a pig is just stupid. It is.
Prove it. How would pigs be better then horses? In no way. Horses give us another mob, which is better, also give us a ride-able mob, that we can control.
Anyways to the above, most ideas don't add anything to gameplay and or what they do add hurts gameplay.
But I do like threads that add good things to gameplay. If you look at the aether thread, the more arrows thread, the floracraft thread, the 2X2 crafting table thread, the art of war thread, and the Ghoul thread are all thread I like.
So stop saying I dislike all ideas because your wrong.
yeah, but why a horse? what if giving a pig a brown mushroom while riding it let you control it, and a red mushroom makes it go faster? Then not only do you have a rideable controllable mob without adding any new blocks/mobs, but it also introduces balance to the feature, since the mushrooms would effectively act as fuel so you don't just get an infinite boost.
PLEASE ALSO SUPPORT:
Sabata & Grey Acumen's "New Nether"
Grey Acumen's Minecraft 2.0 Suggestion Series
Even then, this is minecraft. No, that isn't a catchall to be completely illogical, but there's no reason to insist that the "pigs" in minecraft must only be as capable for riding as what YOU think is realistic. It's silly, so what? Why must minecraft be so godam serious?
PLEASE ALSO SUPPORT:
Sabata & Grey Acumen's "New Nether"
Grey Acumen's Minecraft 2.0 Suggestion Series
Even if minecraft "shouldn't be so serious" (It should, but all you 13 year olds want it to be all happy funland) the pig idea, and this one, both are not useful to gameplay and are extremely overpowered.
1) the splash screen messages which are the very first thing you see in the game and set the tone thereafter; they are silly
2) the way the player character and other mobs move
3) you can already ride pigs
4) you can stick a jackolantern on your head.
5) you can hatch chickens from eggs by throwing the eggs
6) you can't die permanently
7) peaceful mode
8) zombie pigmen
9) breaking trees (or any block for that matter) with your fists
10) you can swim in lava provide you are carrying enough grilled meat with you (same for avoiding drowning in water)
11) you can eat raw pig meat and not get sick
12) you can fire a bow like a machine gun
13) you can make a suit of armor entirely out of diamonds
14) you get records from creepers
15) you can carry lava in a bucket
16) you get feathers from zombies
17) you can send a mob into space using enough TNT and a minecart
18) wooden tools
19) exploding green penises (had to toss that one in somewhere)
20) mobs can get captured by minecarts
21) you can survive a fall from any height as long as you're in a boat/minecart
22) furnaces can run on lava
23) punch ghast bombs back at them
24) TNT = Gunpowder and Sand
25) you can swim up waterfalls
I could go on, but I think I'll stop the list here. You may claim every single one of those ideas as being things that need fixed, but if that's the case, it only proves my point more when I say that you're wrong about how serious minecraft is supposed to be.
And the pig idea I came up with is LESS overpowered than your horse idea, and adds just as much to the gameplay without needing to actually ADD any real content other than some code.
PLEASE ALSO SUPPORT:
Sabata & Grey Acumen's "New Nether"
Grey Acumen's Minecraft 2.0 Suggestion Series
That one makes sense actually. Nobel was almost going out of business, because nobody wanted to buy the TNT, because it had a nasty tendency to blow you up randomly. The company was saved when he figured out the TNT became more stable if absorbed into a type of mineral found on the bottom of the ocean. Sand is the closest thing we have to that mineral.
In fact, the thing that doesn't make sense about that crafting recipe, is that sulfur (the official name for gunpowder, according to the tooltips), is used to make TNT (tri-NITROtoluene)
Though I do agree on the pigs instead of horses thing.
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading
I don't get how people see this. I just don't.....
More then half of those are just things notch put in as place holders until he could put in something that made sense.
Like the zombie feather thing.
Chickens had yet to be added so there was no way for the player to get feathers.
Also most of the stuff put in there wasn't "silly" just nonsensical or easy.
I just think horses would add more mobs, making the ecosystem larger and make more sense.
Which brings me to another point.
Alot of the thing you put on that list were things that didn't make sense, not silly things.
Like the wood tools Those don't make sense but are'nt "silly"
but you are in favor of riding pigs, which makes almost no sense at all.
I don't get how you people like the idea of riding pigs. It makes no sense to me.
Cow:
Leather
Milk
Chicken:
Feather
Egg
Pig:
Pork
Pushing you off of cliffsSheep:
Wool
If we added transportation to pigs, and made sheep drop something when killed, then each mob would have 2 uses, one that required you to kill it, and one that would not.
Now, I do believe this thread has become quite de-railed.
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading
See? this is can get. This makes more sense.
I don't think the thread matters, the OP seems to be gone.
Now your just projecting so much it hurts.
and yet you have'nt been able to post anything to dis prove them
It won't get into the main game, but once prefix mobs are added this will be easy to mod.
And there are people who will use it if it is a mod.
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading