I think what muncher is trying to say is adding Oreos to the game is a bit weird, while adding a generic chocolate chip or whatever is okay. I, personally, see no point for Oreos, either. And I'm not saying I don't like Oreos, if that's any relevance.
Thanks you.
When I hear "pop culture" I think someone using a popular thing in a way trying to be funny.
but that does'nt matter.
Finding excitement in minecraft. Making something boring fun is funny. but putting something like oreos that are supposed to be something fun is not very fun at all.
Now onto the argument of saying just don't make them.
This is not an argument. Someone could suggest space travel or cthullu or ANYTHING and when people criticize their idea they could just say "don't make them!"
If your idea is not worth making then why put it in the game?
It is the ultimate cop out argument.
Now this is the rock bottom question.
"What is the reason we need oreos? Do they fill a space that no other item could fill? Could something that makes more sense in minecraft"
It took me a while to type this so some more responses came in.
If you renamed them cookies I would be ok with it.
I still have criticism though.
we need them because 66% voted yes we need them because want them and you don't have to make them
MOD EDIT: Don't imagepost. It promotes poor posting habits.
It doesn't matter if it's somehow relevant in the context of the post or discussion. It has to be stopped because people abuse it too much.
Maybe in later times.
Torb, even though I do like a lot of your ideas, mainly possible mobs (and who can forget NecroCraft), I have no choice but to disagree on this one.
Cookies, maybe, but oreos are a bit specific. The amount of ingrediants added to the game, along with all the blocks added to justify adding said ingrediants, new type of tree, and grease marks, might be a bit much just to make oreos a part of minecraft.
Oreos just don't seem "minecrafty", and going to all the extra trouble just to add a cheap laugh from a pop-culture reference isn't really worth it.
If cookies were added, I'm sure at least one person would make a mod turning them into oreos.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
You have just started
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading
I think what muncher is trying to say is adding Oreos to the game is a bit weird, while adding a generic chocolate chip or whatever is okay. I, personally, see no point for Oreos, either. And I'm not saying I don't like Oreos, if that's any relevance.
Thanks you.
When I hear "pop culture" I think someone using a popular thing in a way trying to be funny.
but that does'nt matter.
Finding excitement in minecraft. Making something boring fun is funny. but putting something like oreos that are supposed to be something fun is not very fun at all.
Now onto the argument of saying just don't make them.
This is not an argument. Someone could suggest space travel or cthullu or ANYTHING and when people criticize their idea they could just say "don't make them!"
If your idea is not worth making then why put it in the game?
It is the ultimate cop out argument.
Now this is the rock bottom question.
"What is the reason we need oreos? Do they fill a space that no other item could fill? Could something that makes more sense in minecraft"
It took me a while to type this so some more responses came in.
If you renamed them cookies I would be ok with it.
I still have criticism though.
we need them because 66% voted yes we need them because want them and you don't have to make them
Just because you want something doesn't mean your should have it.
And good job not reading the stuff your QUOTED!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
Guys, what you all have to remember is that Notch or one of his associates will have to use their precious time to plan and program this. Would you rather have cookies or better monster AI, new biomes or even new modes for Minecraft? I know my answer. Also: Snickerdoodles = Win.
I know fat could be used for other stuff. My main problem is how childish and dumb the idea sounds.
Muncher, I respect your rank and critic skills, but what is is with you and your hate for childish fun and jokes? I mean seriously, Notch added snowballs. They are used in fun activities by kids all over the world!(only in cold places though) and even adults play with them! I just read your reply to Lulzferbakon(or something)'s post for pig pets, and I hated every part of his idea, but really, is it because of it being too childish for the game? No. Because flying pigs are not fit for Minecraft. i think this idea for Oreos in Minecraft is cool and still fitting, cream was invented way back in the olden times and I think there should also be chocolate chip cookies. They would both be fun and cool, and make a great addition to the game!
+5
Mr. Torb, i love all of your ideas. except this one. i could see some normal cookies, and i would love that, but oreos? they just dont fit the "feel" of minecraft as much as chocolate chip/peanut butter cookies do.
I don't see much of a connection between exploding humanoid organisms and food items.
I believe the correct term is "exploding penises".
Please stop calling creepers penises. They don't look like penises. If you penis looks like a creeper there is a problem.
And furthermore, I don't mind childish fun. But I do mind unfitting ideas. Like this. It's so silly and unfitting for minecraft it's jarring. If breaks immersion. IF you were watching a island survival movie and the guy made oreos it would be jarring and unfitting.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
also, mabye if you just eat the cream, it would refill 1 heart.
and if you eat the chocklete bar it would give 1.5 hearts
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
GENERATION 22: When you see this, put GENERATION 23 in your Signature.
Yes, i did play during indev. It doesn't make me any better then you though, so stop acting like it does.
[Diamond] [Diamond]
I don't see much of a connection between exploding humanoid organisms and food items.
I believe the correct term is "exploding penises".
Please stop calling creepers penises. They don't look like penises. If you penis looks like a creeper there is a problem.
And furthermore, I don't mind childish fun. But I do mind unfitting ideas. Like this. It's so silly and unfitting for minecraft it's jarring. If breaks immersion. IF you were watching a island survival movie and the guy made oreos it would be jarring and unfitting.
FOAD From this topic and stop trolling muncher. :3
FOAD From this topic and stop trolling muncher. :3
Really? Very mature. How about you be a man and Actually type out your swear words. You can swear on the internet, you mom isn't watching.
Obviously you have nothing to contribute to this thread and have no way to rebuttal my Arguments so you're just resorting to petty insults. So how bout you
Quote from AaronDude7 »
FOAD From this topic
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
The Meaning of Life, the Universe, and Everything.
Join Date:
12/7/2010
Posts:
42
Member Details
Quote from muncher21 »
Quote from AaronDude7 »
FOAD From this topic and stop trolling muncher. :3
Really? Very mature. How about you be a man and Actually type out your swear words. You can swear on the internet, you mom isn't watching.
Obviously you have nothing to contribute to this thread and have no way to rebuttal my Arguments so you're just resorting to petty insults. So how bout you
Quote from AaronDude7 »
FOAD From this topic
I would just like to point out the fact that you are the only individual in this thread to exhibit certain intelligence, And I would like to agree with you that this idea is ****ing retarded.
I mean.. seriously, every other poster, stop to think for a second and you'll notice just how retarded this idea is. Trust me, thinking's not that hard.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from JaxMed »
Shrubberies are my trade. I am a Shrubber. My name is Jax the Shrubber. I arrange, design, and sell shrubberies.
I would just like to point out the fact that you are the only individual in this thread to exhibit certain intelligence, And I would like to agree with you that this idea is ****ing retarded.
I mean.. seriously, every other poster, stop to think for a second and you'll notice just how retarded this idea is. Trust me, thinking's not that hard.
Gee, thanks. I couldn't of ever possibly realised that the suggestion I made was fail, without your immense knowledge guiding me.
Has it ever occured to you that you can make a point without being a douche?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
~ I've thought about the phrase 'Money is the root of all evil' and I have to disagree. Evil isn't dependant on an object. I say that want is the root of all evil.
I would just like to point out the fact that you are the only individual in this thread to exhibit certain intelligence, And I would like to agree with you that this idea is ****ing retarded.
I mean.. seriously, every other poster, stop to think for a second and you'll notice just how retarded this idea is. Trust me, thinking's not that hard.
Thanks but I'm really not the only one. Mr. Torb and others have been able to civil conversation and discussion about this idea. I just get annoyed when people say "OFMG muncher stop trollin you N00b!" That just annoys me.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
I would just like to point out the fact that you are the only individual in this thread to exhibit certain intelligence, And I would like to agree with you that this idea is ****ing retarded.
I mean.. seriously, every other poster, stop to think for a second and you'll notice just how retarded this idea is. Trust me, thinking's not that hard.
Thanks but I'm really not the only one. Mr. Torb and others have been able to civil conversation and discussion about this idea. I just get annoyed when people say "OFMG muncher stop trollin you N00b!" That just annoys me.
I would just like to point out the fact that you are the only individual in this thread to exhibit certain intelligence, And I would like to agree with you that this idea is ****ing retarded.
I mean.. seriously, every other poster, stop to think for a second and you'll notice just how retarded this idea is. Trust me, thinking's not that hard.
Thanks but I'm really not the only one. Mr. Torb and others have been able to civil conversation and discussion about this idea. I just get annoyed when people say "OFMG muncher stop trollin you N00b!" That just annoys me.
WELL LEAVE THIS TOPIC!
And let you win? Not a chance.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
we need them because 66% voted yes we need them because want them and you don't have to make them
That aside, http://maddok.files.wordpress.com/2009/12/do-want1.jpg
MOD EDIT: Don't imagepost. It promotes poor posting habits.
It doesn't matter if it's somehow relevant in the context of the post or discussion. It has to be stopped because people abuse it too much.
Maybe in later times.
APPROVED.
Cookies, maybe, but oreos are a bit specific. The amount of ingrediants added to the game, along with all the blocks added to justify adding said ingrediants, new type of tree, and grease marks, might be a bit much just to make oreos a part of minecraft.
Oreos just don't seem "minecrafty", and going to all the extra trouble just to add a cheap laugh from a pop-culture reference isn't really worth it.
If cookies were added, I'm sure at least one person would make a mod turning them into oreos.
To read the haiku that you
Just finished reading
Just because you want something doesn't mean your should have it.
And good job not reading the stuff your QUOTED!
I believe the correct term is "exploding penises".
Muncher, I respect your rank and critic skills, but what is is with you and your hate for childish fun and jokes? I mean seriously, Notch added snowballs. They are used in fun activities by kids all over the world!(only in cold places though) and even adults play with them! I just read your reply to Lulzferbakon(or something)'s post for pig pets, and I hated every part of his idea, but really, is it because of it being too childish for the game? No. Because flying pigs are not fit for Minecraft. i think this idea for Oreos in Minecraft is cool and still fitting, cream was invented way back in the olden times and I think there should also be chocolate chip cookies. They would both be fun and cool, and make a great addition to the game!
+5
Please stop calling creepers penises. They don't look like penises. If you penis looks like a creeper there is a problem.
And furthermore, I don't mind childish fun. But I do mind unfitting ideas. Like this. It's so silly and unfitting for minecraft it's jarring. If breaks immersion. IF you were watching a island survival movie and the guy made oreos it would be jarring and unfitting.
also, mabye if you just eat the cream, it would refill 1 heart.
and if you eat the chocklete bar it would give 1.5 hearts
Yes, i did play during indev. It doesn't make me any better then you though, so stop acting like it does.
[Diamond]
FOAD From this topic and stop trolling muncher. :3
Really? Very mature. How about you be a man and Actually type out your swear words. You can swear on the internet, you mom isn't watching.
Obviously you have nothing to contribute to this thread and have no way to rebuttal my Arguments so you're just resorting to petty insults. So how bout you
I would just like to point out the fact that you are the only individual in this thread to exhibit certain intelligence, And I would like to agree with you that this idea is ****ing retarded.
I mean.. seriously, every other poster, stop to think for a second and you'll notice just how retarded this idea is. Trust me, thinking's not that hard.
Gee, thanks. I couldn't of ever possibly realised that the suggestion I made was fail, without your immense knowledge guiding me.
Has it ever occured to you that you can make a point without being a douche?
Thanks but I'm really not the only one. Mr. Torb and others have been able to civil conversation and discussion about this idea. I just get annoyed when people say "OFMG muncher stop trollin you N00b!" That just annoys me.
WELL LEAVE THIS TOPIC!
And let you win? Not a chance.