If normal cookies also exist, and fat does too, eventually you'll end up with spare resources you don't need, and oreo's could be a cheap craft.
Why not add another generic kind of cookie than copying a brand? I simply see no point in Oreo-like cookies.
Quote from Mr Torb »
If normal cookies also exist, then they would need baking, whereas oreo's don't. They could provide less hp then baked cookies, thus are balanced out as the easier, but poorer cookie to make.
Oreos are baked.
Quote from Mr Torb »
Chocolate bars lead the way to cakes.
Oreo pies. Have you tasted them?
Why do we need cakes? Besides being irrelevant, minecraft does not need 100 billion desserts. We're a survival game, not a cooking game. Same with pie.
Well I'll be damned. They are baked. They don't have to be in minecraft though. Normal cookies, however, are stereotypically baked at home. More responses in quote.
Quote from iKaleb »
Quote from Mr Torb »
If normal cookies also exist, and fat does too, eventually you'll end up with spare resources you don't need, and oreo's could be a cheap craft.
Why not add another generic kind of cookie than copying a brand? I simply see no point in Oreo-like cookies.
There is no point. There's no point in them being chocolate chip cookies either. Theres several cookie types, why is chocolate chip less frowned apon then chocolate creme? And these are generic cookies, theres tons of brands that have two chocolate disks with creme on them.
Quote from Mr Torb »
Chocolate bars lead the way to cakes.
Oreo pies. Have you tasted them?
Why do we need cakes? Besides being irrelevant, minecraft does not need 100 billion desserts. We're a survival game, not a cooking game. Same with pie.
True, true. If cookies get in there's no need for cake, and vise versa.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
~ I've thought about the phrase 'Money is the root of all evil' and I have to disagree. Evil isn't dependant on an object. I say that want is the root of all evil.
If normal cookies also exist, and fat does too, eventually you'll end up with spare resources you don't need, and oreo's could be a cheap craft.
Why not add another generic kind of cookie than copying a brand? I simply see no point in Oreo-like cookies.
There is no point. There's no point in them being chocolate chip cookies either. Theres several cookie types, why is chocolate chip less frowned apon then chocolate creme? And these are generic cookies, theres tons of brands that have two chocolate disks with creme on them.
If you look at that way, there's no point in adding anything. Especially cookies, at that. I don't care that people have produced generic Oreos; you still think "Oreo" when you see them. With chocolate chip, most cookie companies have their variation of the recipe. When you see chocolate chip (or most other cookies) cookies in a store you don't think "Oh, randomcompany incorporated made chocolate chip cookies first while anotherrandomcompany copied them." When you see the copied Oreo brands, you still think that.
Edit:
And about the Oreos not needing to be baked in minecraft. If you want to skip the baking, why not come up with something other than cookies?
Many people enjoy oreos, which is why I thought that I would make light-hearted suggestion of adding them. There isn't an arguement that I can think of that is completely valid and supports oreos. Like I've said before, this is more of a "why not" suggestion, than a serious one. >.>
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
~ I've thought about the phrase 'Money is the root of all evil' and I have to disagree. Evil isn't dependant on an object. I say that want is the root of all evil.
Many people enjoy oreos, which is why I thought that I would make light-hearted suggestion of adding them. There isn't an arguement that I can think of that is completely valid and supports oreos. Like I've said before, this is more of a "why not" suggestion, than a serious one. >.>
I'm quite happy that your not just yelling "NOOOOO!! NUB!" and agreeing that I actually have valid points. I admit, that you do, too.
Anyway, if a suggestion is not serious, there is little chance of it being implemented. I think that many people also enjoy regular cookies, and adding those would be a better choice then adding oreos specifically.
Many people enjoy oreos, which is why I thought that I would make light-hearted suggestion of adding them. There isn't an arguement that I can think of that is completely valid and supports oreos. Like I've said before, this is more of a "why not" suggestion, than a serious one. >.>
I'm quite happy that your not just yelling "NOOOOO!! NUB!" and agreeing that I actually have valid points. I admit, that you do, too.
Anyway, if a suggestion is not serious, there is little chance of it being implemented. I think that many people also enjoy regular cookies, and adding those would be a better choice then adding oreos specifically.
I figured that more likely then not, someone already suggested it. I also had two boxes of oreo's at the time (oddly, im underweight though. I don't really binge on them, I guess) and figured it'd be funny to suggest oreo's.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
~ I've thought about the phrase 'Money is the root of all evil' and I have to disagree. Evil isn't dependant on an object. I say that want is the root of all evil.
I feel like cookies would need some sort of boost to make them worthwhile. Why would I go through all the trouble to make them when I can kill 5 pigs in a minute, or have a constantly replenishing farm? My suggestion would be to give cookies a bonus to the player when eaten, for example a sugar-high where your speed is boosted by 1.5 for 20 seconds and then after that your speed is reduced by .25 for 30 seconds. That way cookies would be useful for escaping tight situations or "sprinting" the last couple yards to safety as night falls.
more food is good but one cookie fills the entire "cookie" niche. Just like if we added cake, there is no reason to make strawberry, vanilla, and chocolate cake. there should just be "cake".
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Quote from mjcabooseblu »
Muncher is right, listen to him, he can cure the blind and make paraplegics walk.
To avoid copying issues, the name would need to be changed, but it would be obvious what type of cookie it is basically.
+1
it would be cool if we also had stuff like reese's cups etc.
Yo Torb, Mind if I make a PastryCraft suggestion forum and put this in? Heck, I might even dance if you sponsor to make more baking stuff for me to sponsor in PastryCraft. But still No Or Yes?
Yo Torb, Mind if I make a PastryCraft suggestion forum and put this in? Heck, I might even dance if you sponsor to make more baking stuff for me to sponsor in PastryCraft. But still No Or Yes?
Yea, go for it. You can even take all the pictures I've got in this thread.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
~ I've thought about the phrase 'Money is the root of all evil' and I have to disagree. Evil isn't dependant on an object. I say that want is the root of all evil.
Yo Torb, Mind if I make a PastryCraft suggestion forum and put this in? Heck, I might even dance if you sponsor to make more baking stuff for me to sponsor in PastryCraft. But still No Or Yes?
Yea, go for it. You can even take all the pictures I've got in this thread.
Why not add another generic kind of cookie than copying a brand? I simply see no point in Oreo-like cookies.
Oreos are baked.
Why do we need cakes? Besides being irrelevant, minecraft does not need 100 billion desserts. We're a survival game, not a cooking game. Same with pie.
If you look at that way, there's no point in adding anything. Especially cookies, at that. I don't care that people have produced generic Oreos; you still think "Oreo" when you see them. With chocolate chip, most cookie companies have their variation of the recipe. When you see chocolate chip (or most other cookies) cookies in a store you don't think "Oh, randomcompany incorporated made chocolate chip cookies first while anotherrandomcompany copied them." When you see the copied Oreo brands, you still think that.
Edit:
And about the Oreos not needing to be baked in minecraft. If you want to skip the baking, why not come up with something other than cookies?
Many people enjoy oreos, which is why I thought that I would make light-hearted suggestion of adding them. There isn't an arguement that I can think of that is completely valid and supports oreos. Like I've said before, this is more of a "why not" suggestion, than a serious one. >.>
I'm quite happy that your not just yelling "NOOOOO!! NUB!" and agreeing that I actually have valid points. I admit, that you do, too.
Anyway, if a suggestion is not serious, there is little chance of it being implemented. I think that many people also enjoy regular cookies, and adding those would be a better choice then adding oreos specifically.
I figured that more likely then not, someone already suggested it. I also had two boxes of oreo's at the time (oddly, im underweight though. I don't really binge on them, I guess) and figured it'd be funny to suggest oreo's.
Why can't we have both
Why should we have both?
What do oreos add other then the
"hurr durr minecraft has oreos hurr durr"
effect.
Because more food
Its true you are :biggrin.gif:
MOD EDIT: Let's not.
+1
it would be cool if we also had stuff like reese's cups etc.
Could you not do this? it makes you look very immature.
Yea, go for it. You can even take all the pictures I've got in this thread.
Done and Done
I vote yes!
I support these!