I did (or think I did) everything correct for these villagers to mate. I put the correct doors and made them valid, and I gave them carrots to make them willing, but they won't mate. When the villagers were in that cobblestone area up on top, they were breeding, but I moved the villagers downward because they were being attacked through the corners.
I only see 6 doors, that's only enough for 2 villagers.
If you have 1 villager down by the doors and the rest up top they breed because the ones up top aren't counted since they are so far above the doors.
You could either move all but 1 villager back up top and find some other way to protect them or dig out a room at least 6 blocks lower than the doors to move all the villagers except 1 or add enough doors that there are about 3 times as many doors as you want villagers or move the doors and 1 villager up or down 6 blocks or more.
Gnembon has a couple recent videos exploring the mechanics of villager breeders and village mechanics. It's very much worth your time to sit through them a few times (he's got a rather thick accent, so you might have difficulty understanding him the first time around).
I did (or think I did) everything correct for these villagers to mate. I put the correct doors and made them valid, and I gave them carrots to make them willing, but they won't mate. When the villagers were in that cobblestone area up on top, they were breeding, but I moved the villagers downward because they were being attacked through the corners.
This is a video where I show my setup: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sVzCSKJ_8clseVn8cyoOWZUQgU0cyHNZ/view?usp=sharing
I only see 6 doors, that's only enough for 2 villagers.
If you have 1 villager down by the doors and the rest up top they breed because the ones up top aren't counted since they are so far above the doors.
You could either move all but 1 villager back up top and find some other way to protect them or dig out a room at least 6 blocks lower than the doors to move all the villagers except 1 or add enough doors that there are about 3 times as many doors as you want villagers or move the doors and 1 villager up or down 6 blocks or more.
Just testing.
Thanks, I'll try what you said
Gnembon has a couple recent videos exploring the mechanics of villager breeders and village mechanics. It's very much worth your time to sit through them a few times (he's got a rather thick accent, so you might have difficulty understanding him the first time around).
Nevermind everyone, i was just impatient. My villagers mated with that setup.