That said, there is no reason why anybody can't make a mod with some of the suggestions in this thread, and no doubt they already have (including myself, if not to replicate everything mentioned here).
Ok, but I think we should recreate some code or idea of that thread.
We should also PM some encoder or creator of Mods to create the project that would like to see the members of this team.
Ok, but I think we should recreate some code or idea of that thread.
A modding thread that's been dead for almost 5 years will provide little to no insight into current modding; countless amounts of changes to the Forge API and Minecraft's own code have been made, and copying anything from that thread would require so much changing and rewriting we might as well just do it on our own from scratch.
We are currently rethinking the way we are going to add suggestions to this project. We will be discussing each suggestion that could potentially have a flaw or reason not to be added (regardless of what list it's been on) individually, with the least likely to stay being discussed first. Feel free to contribute to the discussion here or on our discord server.
It's been a long time since we've posted here, and in the meantime the Community Revamp has made some great strides. As we grow closer to an initial test release, I feel it's relevant to share some progress images of our first implemented suggestion, the Fall Forest by fishg. This wondrous biome is home to giant pumpkins, turkeys, black bears, and even autumnal creepers. There (and in new Maple Forests as well) you can gather sap, and make delicious pancakes. In addition, we've added a few toys- gunpowder blocks for storage and explosions, and a couple new naturally-generating structures for you to discover.
The gallery for the Fall Forest can be found here.
In other news: the Minecraft Forum's days are limited. On June 16, 2019, the forum that birthed the Community Revamp will close its doors. In an effort to preserve the people and culture of the Suggestions Forum that this project draws its life from, we have created a Discord server dedicated to the Revamp. You may join here.
These can be used both as a fuse and an explosive!
Iron Golems are now immune to arrows
You can now repair iron golems and snow golems by right-clicking on them with iron ingots or snowballs
Iron blocks and diamond blocks are now somewhat blast resistant
Terrain Pack
Added Fall Forest and Fall Hills biomes
Added Maple Forest biome
Added maple logs, planks, stairs, slabs, fences, fence gates, saplings, and doors
Added maple trees & fallen maple trees
Found in Fall Forest & Fall Hills
Added pumpkin house structure
Found in Fall Forest & Fall Hills
Has three witches, a skeleton skull, and a bit of loot!
Added pilgrim cabin structure
Found in Fall Forest & Fall Hills
Added turkey
Found in Fall Forest and Fall Hills
Drops raw turkey which can be cooked
Added black bear
Found in Fall Forest, Fall Hills, and Oak Forest
Added tree sap
Collected from maple logs that are a part of maple trees
Added maple syrup
Made from putting tree sap in a furnace
Added pancakes
Made from three wheat, 1 sugar, 1 egg, and 1 bottle of maple syrup
Can be placed and eaten like cakes
Added rotten wood
Currently only obtainable in Creative Mode
Added husk ruins
Found in deserts
Crafting Recipes
Pancake
Maple Syrup
This update we focused mainly on fishg's Autumnal Forest suggestion— but we plan to include much, much more!
This is only the Alpha stage of the Community Revamp. Our goal is to create the ultimate vanilla Minecraft experience with many unique suggestions added to the game.
That has nothing to do with what you think it does, and it has been dead for 5 years (even the last post on the thread is from late 2014):
That said, there is no reason why anybody can't make a mod with some of the suggestions in this thread, and no doubt they already have (including myself, if not to replicate everything mentioned here).
TheMasterCaver's First World - possibly the most caved-out world in Minecraft history - includes world download.
TheMasterCaver's World - my own version of Minecraft largely based on my views of how the game should have evolved since 1.6.4.
Why do I still play in 1.6.4?
Ok, but I think we should recreate some code or idea of that thread.
We should also PM some encoder or creator of Mods to create the project that would like to see the members of this team.
A modding thread that's been dead for almost 5 years will provide little to no insight into current modding; countless amounts of changes to the Forge API and Minecraft's own code have been made, and copying anything from that thread would require so much changing and rewriting we might as well just do it on our own from scratch.
Poll created to decide which ship system is better.
Ocean Improvements
Boats Evolved
We're doing a mod project, check it out:
My suggestions:
What do you guys think of this? Do you think it fits well enough with vanilla?
Works really well imo, almost a necessity.
GENERATION 22: The first time you see this, copy it into your signature and add 1 to the generation.
I found another cool suggestion: https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/84568-improving-trees-and-player-behaviour-around-trees
We are currently rethinking the way we are going to add suggestions to this project. We will be discussing each suggestion that could potentially have a flaw or reason not to be added (regardless of what list it's been on) individually, with the least likely to stay being discussed first. Feel free to contribute to the discussion here or on our discord server.
List of suggestions to talk about:
The Crimson Forest
https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftsuggestions/comments/8kanin/new_biome_the_crimson_forest_and_much_more/
Reason: The phantasmal ward is possibly not useful enough
Whalefalls (Just the whalefalls part of this suggestion)
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2906349-whales-and-whalefalls
Reason: Does it fit in? Would it be worth development time? Could these features be used outside of this suggestion?
Detailed Nether Villagers
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/60692-detailed-nether-villagers-lots-of-images
Reason: May not fit
Scarlet Forest
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2273813-scarlet-forest-biome-potion-of-reflex-and-a-fox-8
Reason: Do we really need another biome, tree, and grass type?
The Lava Kraken
Reason: Is it balanced? Does it fit?
Villager Heredity
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2593266-villager-heredity-never-confuse-villagers-again
Reason: Does it fit?
The Upper Caves
https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftabnormals/comments/8k1pii/the_upper_caves_expanding_the_underground/
Reason: Would it make caves look worse? Is it worth the development time?
Chorans
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2869310-chorans-a-new-danger-to-the-end
Reason: Does it fit? Do creeper variants fit? Would the E-TNT be overpowered?
Fleshins
https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftabnormals/comments/8pwf2o/fleshinsthe_oblivious_defenders_of_the_nether/
Reason: Does it fit in?
Irthwurm- A Desert Min-Boss
https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftabnormals/comments/8npg8c/irthwurm_a_desert_miniboss/
Reason: Is the drop of the mini-boss useful enough? Is the drop overpowered?
Pigeons
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2541860-pigeons-minecrafts-avian-postman
Reason: Are they overpowered? Does it make in-game sense?
Reaches
https://www.reddit.com/r/minecraftabnormals/comments/8omzxg/reaches_the_tendrils_of_the_void/
Reason: Does it fit in? Is it useful?
Ocean Improvements Part 2/3
https://www.minecraftforum.net/forums/minecraft-java-edition/suggestions/2852837-ocean-improvements-part-2-3-sea-content-updated
Reason: A lot of ocean content even though we just got Update Aquatic
If there is a suggestion you think we should discuss, please bring it up. Rember that no suggestion is immune to discussion.
The goal of going through this list is to get a lot of the discussions of "Should this really be added?" out of the way.
The Upper Caves are a good idea
It's been a long time since we've posted here, and in the meantime the Community Revamp has made some great strides. As we grow closer to an initial test release, I feel it's relevant to share some progress images of our first implemented suggestion, the Fall Forest by fishg. This wondrous biome is home to giant pumpkins, turkeys, black bears, and even autumnal creepers. There (and in new Maple Forests as well) you can gather sap, and make delicious pancakes. In addition, we've added a few toys- gunpowder blocks for storage and explosions, and a couple new naturally-generating structures for you to discover.
The gallery for the Fall Forest can be found here.
In other news: the Minecraft Forum's days are limited. On June 16, 2019, the forum that birthed the Community Revamp will close its doors. In an effort to preserve the people and culture of the Suggestions Forum that this project draws its life from, we have created a Discord server dedicated to the Revamp. You may join here.
We're doing a mod project, check it out:
My suggestions:
Core Mod
Terrain Pack
Crafting Recipes
Pancake
Maple Syrup
This update we focused mainly on fishg's Autumnal Forest suggestion— but we plan to include much, much more!
This is only the Alpha stage of the Community Revamp. Our goal is to create the ultimate vanilla Minecraft experience with many unique suggestions added to the game.
Download the mod at our official discord server!
https://discord.gg/ujAqkmu
I'd also like to say a special thanks to fishg for making the awesome logos and trailer for the Community Revamp!