I would have him build a city then while he is doing that I'd make an atomic-bomb mod with forge as quickly as I humanly could, install it onto the server, and when he is done ID STRAP HIM TO ONE AND DROP IT ON HIS CITY, THEN ID LOAD A BACKUP AND DO IT AGAIN AND AGAIN AND AGAIN FOREVER AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Then when Im bored of that Id just plain kill him, and tell him he is the reason why half the internet / minecraft community is stupid, including him.
His biggest criticism comes from the fact that his humor is mostly dependent on yelling, arguing, and other such things are very flashy, and not in any way subtle. While I have to agree that is a weakness of his, I think he does it pretty well, and to be honest, it's really funny when Deadlox pushes him off a cliff, or a squid builds a giant robot to destroy him. I can certainly see why other people don't like him though. I just happen to find him funny.