Minecraft Forums

Update: Round 2 of Voting is officially over! Click here for Round 3:

http://www.minecraftforum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=206326

This is the thread for Round 2 of the 1.4 suggestion thread here:

viewtopic.php?f=3&t=191102

Thank you all who participated in the nomination thread. After just one day of nominations, I've gotten more than enough suggestions to begin Round 2 of the voting. Here's how this will work:

I've compiled all the suggestions from the first thread. Anything that was suggested independently by at least two people in Round 1 will be up for voting in Round 2. Obviously, due to the open-ended nature of the first thread, I've had to take some creative liberty with the suggestions - some of your ideas were merged together into bigger over-arching concepts (i.e. suggestions for silver ore and suggestions for copper ore were combined into "more ores").

Rules For Voting:

Below are the most popular suggestions from Round 1, in order of the frequency with which they were suggested.

You may vote on up to 5 (five) of the suggestions below. You can vote for less than five, but any votes beyond your first five will be ignored. To cast a vote, please refer to the suggestion by its number for easy vote counting. Please, please make your votes clear at the top of your post, using their numbers, otherwise it will make tallying the voting a nightmare for me!

At the end of the voting, the top 10 winners will move on to the final round of voting.

And here they are, the suggestions:

1 New Furniture (Including Colored Beds and Wall Clocks) 23 Nominations
2 New Mobs (Aggressive and Passive) 17 Nominations
3 NPCs/NPC-built Villages (Including Pigmen/Pigmen Villages) 13 Nominations
4 Improved Minecart System (Such as Minecart Mk. II) 11 Nominations
5 New Trees (Including Apple Trees/Coconut Trees) 11 Nominations
6 New Lighting Options (Including Lanterns and Fireplaces) 11 Nominations
7 Weather 10 Nominations
8 Nether Update/More Nether Content 10 Nominations
9 New Underwater Content (Including Diving/Breathing Equipment) 9 Nominations
10 New Fruit and Vegetables (Including Watermelons) 8 Nominations
11 Trap Doors/Pitfalls 6 Nominations
12 Gears 6 Nominations
13 New Transportation (Including Cars and Horses) 6 Nominations
14 New Ores (Including Copper/Tin/Bronze/Silver) 5 Nominations
15 New Weapons (Including Guns and Crossbows) 5 Nominations
16 Boss Monsters (Including Dragons) 5 Nominations
17 Pets/Tamable Animals 4 Nominations
18 Higher Vertical Limit 3 Nominations
19 New Stairs 3 Nominations
20 Improved Dungeons 2 Nominations
21 Aether 2 Nominations
22 Fence Gates 2 Nominations
23 Seasoned Wood 2 Nominations
24 Gravestones 2 Nominations
25 Telescopes/Binoculars 2 Nominations

Remember, each forum member may only vote for up to 5 things listed here, and may only vote one time in this thread. Suggestions for bug fixes weren't counted, since that's too obvious. After you vote, feel free to comment on the Great 1.4 Suggestion Poll, ask questions or give suggestions. I don't yet know how long Round 2 will last, but I'll give a fair warning before I close the voting.

My votes:

1 New Furniture (Including Colored Beds and Wall Clocks)
2 New Mobs (Aggressive and Passive)
5 New Trees (Including Apple Trees/Coconut Trees)
9 New Underwater Content (Including Diving/Breathing Equipment)
16 Boss Monsters (Including Dragons)

26) Official modding API
26) Official modding API
26) Official modding API
26) Official modding API
26) Official modding API

1 New Furniture (Including Colored Beds and Wall Clocks)
6 New Lighting Options (Including Lanterns and Fireplaces)
7 Weather
21 Aether
22 Fence Gates

There you go!

6, New Lighting Options (I want a redstone activated light as strong as a torch!)
7, Weather
18, Higher Vertical Limit (ideally at least 300 blocks above sea level)

Only ones in the list I am interested in.

There are so many wonderful things to choose from! :-D To narrow it down though my votes are for 2, 3, 9 , 17 and 21. :-)

3
8
14
20
22

although a MODDING API would be great as well :tongue.gif:

8.
21.
4.
22.
1.

You guys do realize that if the Nether Update and Aether are implemented then we'll get a ton of new ores and mobs right?

There's a ton of great things on this list, but if I had to pick my favorites, they'd be:

3: NPCs/NPC-built Villages
7: Weather
8: Nether Update/More Nether Content
9: New Underwater Content
21: Aether

Shouldn't a suggestion thread go in the suggestions forum?

Here are my votes:

1 New Furniture
3 NPCs/NPC-built Villages (Including Pigmen/Pigmen Villages)
5 New Trees (Including Apple Trees/Coconut Trees)
6 New Lighting Options (Including Lanterns and Fireplaces)
14 New Ores (Including Copper/Tin/Bronze/Silver)

I vote 6. Specifically, I'd love to see...

Redstone. Powered. Light sources. You know, so you could have a light switch.

Throwing my vote to:

4 Improved Minecart System

Would love to finally connect my cities with a proper minecart transit system.

1
6
7
22
23

2
3
6
7
9
8

2 5 6 8 11

Most important of those is the Nether update.

1 New Furniture (Including Colored Beds and Wall Clocks)
2 New Mobs (Aggressive and Passive)
6 New Lighting Options (Including Lanterns and Fireplaces)
7 Weather
18 Higher Vertical Limit


I want the higher limit for my sprites. Btw, in the transportation idea, no cars. >.>

Garbage thread.

Nobody mentioned being able to DYE REDSTONE.

WHATEVER HAPPENED TO WORKING WITH COLORED WIRE? Doesn't even need added functionality. I just want to dye it, with all the dyes that already exist in this game. I want blue wire, green wire, yellow wire, etc etc.

3 ) NPC and Villages
2 ) New Mobs
7 ) Weather
15) New Weapons
17) Pets

Hope something comes of this! :biggrin.gif:

Also, hope I got the voting numbers right (bold numbers next to each suggestion).

1, 2, 3, 4, and 9.