Minecraft Forums

just want to know what you think

i havent seen wats in xtracraft. but i like technic pack

You know, I'm pretty knowledgeable about minecraft, but this IS the Xbox section. I'm sure there are a lot of people here who don't know what those (I'm guessing) mods are. Including me... So please do us a favor and at least describe these items up for a vote.

Where is feed the beast? tekkit is bad, it has 0 permissions from the mod authors and never updates. Why is this in the xbox section anyway?

The poll needs a "neither" and a "both" option to be complete and fair. I would select "neither."

And, like most posted polls, it's very biased- meaning that you only have "yes" options.
Where's the "None" or "Neither" option????

Both are not on Xbox... not sure what you're trying to get at. Which one do we hate, which one do we want, which we prefer, no idea.

shoulnt this be in the computer minecraft or the mod section of the forum. because i dont know either but what i do think i know is that they are both mods.

Quote from Nose_Job_For_a_Cowboy

Did anybody even read the OP? Despite how much fail is contained within the poll's options, it very obviously inquires what you would prefer as DLC... Why on earth would this thread belong in any other section?

Anyway, we're not getting either of those or anything close to them. Pointless poll is pointless.

My reason for my "neither" selection is that neither mod is currently eligible to become available as DLC for the Xbox. Since neither one can currently be made available without first passing Microsoft's certification and approval for download through Live, there is simply no choice possible here. As you said, we're not going to get either of them, so the poll is pointless.

first i made the poll quickly because i was going to school

Quote from Nose_Job_For_a_Cowboy

I was only talking about the users stating this was in the wrong section. The poll itself needs worded differently, or a "neither" option added. The poll is indeed pointless, but any choice is still possible. The plausibility of this happening has no effect on one's opinion

It's not really in the wrong section, but in the narrow scope in which the OP has presented it, it is a question clearly directed at people who play Minecraft on the PC, since only PC users are in a position to assess the internal qualities of either mod at this point in time.

There seems to be an impression that it's always up to 4J to chase down the various PC mods and select which ones they might re-language for the Xbox. However, I say it's up to the PC modders to come up with the funds to have their mod re-languaged for the Xbox and submit to Microsoft for approval and testing. If an already existing mod is to be added to the Xbox, it should be the modders taking the financial risk that it won't sell well enough as DLC to cover the costs of getting it there. The modders would also have to prove that they have a legal right (presumeably through their previous existing agreements with Mojang) to market their mod for the Xbox version.. Personally, I don't think they could prove up this sort of position from the legal standpoint. IF 4J writes original DLC for the Xbox version, then it would obviously be 4J taking the financial risk for the costs of developing, testing and certifying the DLC.

xtracraft is the best mod ever

that i have seen

i edited the poll so if you want vote differently

ok thanks

Quote from MrSpaM

The most advanced 'DLC' you are going to be able to download is the option to switch your game to CTF mode, y'know the mode they promised before the game was even released that we still don't have.

They never actually promised anything like that at all. All that was said is that CTF would come to the Xbox 360 Edition before it came to the PC version. That isn't a promise that it's actually going to happen. Especially since CTF has been rumored on the PC version for years.