Minecraft Forums

Title says it all I think it'll be unique with fireworks yes or no

*Facewing*

PC version already has fireworks,

Quote from Tommyb3870

PC version already has fireworks,

So xbox should have it aswell.

Quote from SSmoshy

So xbox should have it aswell.

I'm hoping for better fireworks.

I hope we get them. They are really fun to mess around with. You can waste countless hours just having fun with them.

Quote from Mr_Science

I'm hoping for better fireworks.

Don't count on that. I doubt the Xbox could handle that many particle effects at once anyways.

The fireworks they have on PC would be awesome to have on the Xbox 360 Edition. I'm hoping it is one of the things they pull from the PC onto the 360 Edition after 1.2.3.

There's things I want more urgently but yes I would like them to be included.

I don't really get the point of them, but it might be pretty cool to play around with them.

That would be cool.

It would be nice in the future, but as for now I think there are more important things 4j should be working on

I just wanna mess around with them in Creative, they look fun.

Quote from wolfeuk

i think the xbox would go into meltdown if fireworks where added...

not really, especially if they do it like the tnt and set a limit to how many at once can go off. would be nice to have something to celebrate victories in the territories...:D

meh.
Just something else to junk up MC that has nothing to do with gameplay.

Quote from Geneo

meh.
Just something else to junk up MC that has nothing to do with gameplay.

You mean the game play where you build a world and do with it whatever you want??? Not sure I see the logic behind this.

Quote from Geneo

meh.
Just something else to junk up MC that has nothing to do with gameplay.

I get where you're coming from, completely. We're stuck with the XBOX360's RAM.
Honestly, I like fireworks I'd just like to see that RAM go to better use.

Quote from sixstringstrummer

You mean the game play where you build a world and do with it whatever you want??? Not sure I see the logic behind this.

Troll? There is logic, if people didn't hop on the troll wagon, they'd see it.
RAM issues. It's a pretty defining logic when it comes to MCXBLA. Some people would rather see the console do other things than the PC also.

When were you ever able to "do whatever you want"? The game ain't that big or has that many options.

Quote from iCountBlocks

I get where you're coming from, completely. We're stuck with the XBOX360's RAM.
Honestly, I like fireworks I'd just like to see that RAM go to better use.


Troll? There is logic, if people didn't hop on the troll wagon, they'd see it.
RAM issues. It's a pretty defining logic when it comes to MCXBLA. Some people would rather see the console do other things than the PC also.

Quote from Geneo

When were you ever able to "do whatever you want"? The game ain't that big or has that many options.

I am well aware of RAM issues with the XBOX. What I mean is that this is a game where everyone plays differently. There is no set way to play minecraft. I wan't trying to be troll or start an argument, but it seems like when someone mentions something they would like to see in the game then people are quick to say that it isn't "essential to gameplay." By saying this you are saying there is some form of "essential gameplay" - presumably your way of playing. I like redstone - but the pure builders in minecraft could easily say it uses up RAM, slows down the game and they could have more creative blocks without it - and they'd be right (I assume). Personally I think brewing is a waste of time, but I'm sure others find it essential. You can like or not like elements in minecraft, but to say something is not essential to gameplay just doesn't make sense to me in a sandbox game like this.

Quote from sixstringstrummer

I am well aware of RAM issues with the XBOX. What I mean is that this is a game where everyone plays differently. There is no set way to play minecraft. I wan't trying to be troll or start an argument, but it seems like when someone mentions something they would like to see in the game then people are quick to say that it isn't "essential to gameplay." By saying this you are saying there is some form of "essential gameplay" - presumably your way of playing. I like redstone - but the pure builders in minecraft could easily say it uses up RAM, slows down the game and they could have more creative blocks without it - and they'd be right (I assume). Personally I think brewing is a waste of time, but I'm sure others find it essential. You can like or not like elements in minecraft, but to say something is not essential to gameplay just doesn't make sense to me in a sandbox game like this.

Then, I apologize for calling you a troll :).
I see fireworks as a completely opinionated choice for Xbox, there's advantages and disadvantages. I guess 4J's opinion is what it comes down too. I agree on brewing, it doesn't seem refined enough. Takes too long, ingredient drops are unbalanced, etc.
I don't think anything can be essential to Minecraft, besides it's original idea. Like you said, it's a sandbox. They do what they want.

Quote from iCountBlocks

Then, I apologize for calling you a troll .
I see fireworks as a completely opinionated choice for Xbox, there's advantages and disadvantages. I guess 4J's opinion is what it comes down too. I agree on brewing, it doesn't seem refined enough. Takes too long, ingredient drops are unbalanced, etc.
I don't think anything can be essential to Minecraft, besides it's original idea. Like you said, it's a sandbox. They do what they want.

Thanks! No offense taken. Also, for the record, I think the fireworks are cool and would love to play around with them!

At some point (soon?) I think we will really start feeling the effects of the Xbox limitations. I think the December update has shown us a bit of this already.