Birch Saplings (The puke green leaves with the white bark is ugly)
Birch Log (The black marks are too rough and dark)
Melons (****-yellow scribble melons? No thanks)
Lapis Lazuli Block (Different from the other ore blocks, but I like the colors)
Chests (Ugly wood color)
Wood (Too plain, too light)
Reeds (Too bright, doesn't fit in with the rest of the terrain really)
Ice (Doesn't look like ice, and the scratch marks look out of place)
Wood Doors (They don't fit in with actual wood, so they look out of place with houses)
Yes, I have quite an extensive and detailed list, but I'm very picky when it comes to texture packs.
I wonder if notch will make new textures (Or who knows, maybe some lucky texture pack artists will have their pack chosen to be in the official game) when it's finally released, or just revamp some of the really ugly ones.
I don't like gravel or mossy cobblestone. The gravel looks kind of bloody (don't know how to explain), and the mossy cobble is only fun to find underground, but once I have it I don't want to build with it.
I like the default pack, except that it isnt in 64x64 (higher res.).
Thats why I use the 'Traditional Beauty'-pack.
The original leaves are a bit rough aswell, and the chests could be a bit more... special.
The stone is too high contrast for a texture that is used as a base,
The wood textures stick out way to much such as on the chest (really, what is with those random darkened lines? Im pretty sure chests don't look like that),
The glass serves the opposite of its pourpose with the huge white streaks,
The cobblestone is yucky completely,
The gravel looks like a bunch of random colors,
The dirt is also way to high contrast and basically just looks like poop,
All of the wool is way to pixelized,
The sandstone is ugly,
The precious blocks are ugly (the old ones were the bee's knees)
The pumpkins cannot be done right at this resolution (if you want something that actually looks like a pumpkin, but there can be the "simplecraft" pumpkins that can look good),
The sand is also too high contrast (developing a theme here),
The top of the cake looks weird (random dots?),
The netherrack tried to get a higher detail than it could,
The tilled land just looks like like the farmer did a bad job,
The birch sappling is just a bunch of random colors,
The redstone wiring also attempted a higher resolution than it could,
The lapis ore is something else entirely,
Last, but certainly not least, the water is just outright grewsome, terrible, terrible job on that.
And thats just the terrain.png
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Im making myself a new signature soon, but im les tired.
I loved every texture before 1.8. The new cooked pork looks like it's full of maggots or something. Rotten flesh looks more appetizing then the new cooked pork. Endermen look really stupid, not "scary" at all. I played from Beta 1.2 to 1.7 and never found a problem, but 1.8 ruined that streak.